Category: Mayor Durkan

Council Budget Amendments Already Top $80 Million in New Spending—and That’s Before the Big Stuff

City Councilmember Rob Saka, speaking to reporters on Monday

The council has about $26 million, over three years, in unanticipated funding “to play with.”

By Erica C. Barnett

After many on the Seattle City Council spent the past few weeks criticizing Mayor Katie Wilson’s budget for failing to fund their priorities, including police officers, fire department overtime, and discretionary transportation funds former mayor Bruce Harrell created for each councilmember using one-time money, the council is getting down to amendments this week.

So far, the council’s budget agendas, which are organized by department, include proposals that would increase general fund spending by more than $80 million over the two-year budget—and that’s before the council even gets to the big-ticket police, transportation, and human services department budgets, where councilmembers will almost certainly propose spending tens of millions more. Between them, councilmembers have proposed more than 160 amendments, most of them for new spending.

The city is required by state law to adopt a balanced budge. Every new program or project must be offset by cuts to someone else’s priorities.

A restructure of the city’s business and occupation (B&O) tax adopted by voters last year includes a section requiring the mayor to propose a balanced financial plan through 2030 this year, but not after that. A proposal from Councilmember Dionne Foster would make this long-term balanced budget mandate permanent, and would also impose it on the city council, requiring them to produce a final budget that’s also balanced in future years.

The idea is to impose some fiscal responsibility on the council after years of profligate spending that has relied on large deficits in future years. “Seattle cannot continue balancing its budget one year at a time while leaving significant ongoing deficits for future leaders to address,” Foster said when she announced the proposal.

Speaking to the media on Monday, Councilmember Rob Saka said he was excited to learn that the city had discovered “a lot of money” recently that “it looks like we have to play with” beyond what the mayor’s office was aware of when they submitted the budget in September.

The first chunk of “new” money, about $12 million over three years (2026-2028), comes from a combination of $7.8 million in net new revenues projected under the updated October revenue forecast and $4 million in interest income from JumpStart (payroll) tax investment revenue. On top of that, the city received an unanticipated $14 million from a JumpStart tax payment that came in late, according to for a total of $26 million across three years.

The council is already busy trying to spend several times that amount, with dozens of potential budget adds. (Saka alone has introduced 20 budget amendments so far).  On Tuesday, when the council’s budget committee moved quickly through amendments involving 16 city departments and signed on as co-sponsors to each others’ amendments, most of the proposed budget adds won sponsorship from at least a five-vote council majority.

Speaking to reporters Monday, public safety chair Bob Kettle derided what he called Wilson’s attempt to present a “Goldilocks budget,” calling it a “bowl of cold porridge” because it slows down police hiring after SPD hits 1,250 officers, which is expected to happen next year or in early 2028. (He also griped that the mayor wouldn’t have presented such a balanced budget if the council hadn’t forced her to with the B&O tax requirement)

“She’s going to own the effects of the budget, particularly as it relates to public safety,” Kettle said. “Ththis is not a budget that one should be celebrating, if you’re looking at it from strictly the public safety perspective.”

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

Kettle said he plans to introduce amendments this week to add more funding to the police department, which Wilson’s budget would increase by more than $68 million, mostly because of the huge raises her predecessor Bruce Harrell negotiated, and the council approved, last year. However, he acknowledged, “the ability to really make changes is going to be problematic” because the budget is so lean, and restoring $7 million a year for Seattle Fire Department overtime, which Wilson’s budget cut, is a higher priority. “It has consensus across the floor, and so that’s going to be the first in line,” Kettle said.

Some of Kettle’s other big-ticket priorities include a proposal to add $1.9 million over two years for graffiti removal (Wilson’s budget removed this funding, which includes a contract with Uplift Northwest to remove graffiti from private property) and $562,000 next year (rising to $715,000 in 2028) to pay for four more assistant city attorneys to prosecute misdemeanors.

Saka’s 20 amendments include a two-year, $14 million plan to restore “district funds” that council members can use to pay for small transportation projects in their districts; Saka, who has called himself the city’s “pothole king” would also restore $1.3 million a year for pothole repairs that Wilson proposed cutting to help address revenue shortfalls and higher-than-expected cost inflation at the Seattle Department of Transportation.

Other proposed council budget adds include:

• An amendment from Councilmember Dionne Foster that would spend $10 million a year in Office of Housing funds to support the construction of new affordable housing and the preservation of existing affordable units. Noting that the mayor balanced her budget, in part, by moving $65 million in JumpStart tax funding out of the Office of Housing, Foster said Tuesda, ” I believe it’s our responsibility, and we have an opportunity if we have additional resources, to reinvest those [dollars] back into our affordable housing community.” Foster’s amendment didn’t get any new co-sponsors, possibly due to its size.

Alongside that proposal, Foster introduced an amendment directing the city’s budget office to come up with a plan to direct half of the money the city brings in from the big-business tax toward the Equitable Development Initiative and affordable housing. These were two of the top spending priorities in the original JumpStart spending plan, which the council fully abandoned in 2024.

• A proposal from Council President Joy Hollingsworth (whose cosponsors include everyone on the council) to spend $5 million over two years to expand and make permanent the Central District and Southeast Seattle Reinvestment Fund the council funded, like many of its 2026 priorities, with one-time funding last year.

• Several million dollars for various projects in council budget chair Dan Strauss’ district, including $350,000 in one-time funds for “activation” and “street activation” in Ballard, $500,000 for murals in the Ballard “brewery district,” $80,000 over two years to lease land for a community garden in Ballard, and $300,000 for a new skate dot at the West Magnolia Playfield (technically in Bob Kettle’s district).

• A Hollingsworth proposal that would add dedicated city funding within the Department of Neighborhoods for the city’s volunteer neighborhood councils, at a cost of $100,000 a year. Kettle and Councilmember Maritza Rivera praised the proposal (which also got support from Saka and Juarez), with Kettle saying “everything went sideways at that point” when former Mayor Ed Murray eliminated city funding for the groups.

Then as now, neighborhood councils tended to be dominated by older white homeowners with plenty of time to advocate for traditional NIMBY causes, like preserving single-family neighborhoods in amber. The city stopped funding these insular groups as part of a broader effort to get a more diverse group of people, including renters, younger people, and people of color, to weigh in on decisions that affect the city. 

• Councilmember Maritza Rivera’s proposal to commit the city to a two-year, $418,000 no-bid contract with the  National Network for Safe Communities, whose founder, David Kennedy, came up with the idea of “focused deterrence as a strategy for preventing gun violence. The idea is that in every city, a relative handful of people are responsible for most of the shootings, so cities should target those people with a carrot-stick approach—services for those who want to stop committing crimes, and aggressive prosecution and sentencing for those who reoffend. With focused deterrence, police and service providers that specialize in reducing gun violence work together to identify and target these frequent offenders.

Wilson has repeatedly expressed her support for focused deterrence, but Rivera says NNSC is different than the kind of program Wilson supports because the city would put police “at the table” instead of just “consulting” them.

Asked to elaborate on Monday, Rivera said, “When I’ve spoken to the mayor’s office about this, they have a different understanding of how to work with police. They say they want to work with police, but this particular model involves working with police at the table, with the community service providers, and with the community members working with that individual all at the same time at the same table.”

During a press briefing on Tuesday, Wilson told PubliCola “it is entirely untrue that I do not want police at the table. SPD is firmly at the table in the gun violence plan that I rolled out last month. SPD is collaborating day to day with CARE as CARE is standing up their part in in this gun violence plan. And the definition of focused deterrence is a strategy which includes law enforcement. I think I’ve made that very clear. And NNSC is not the only provider of those services.”

The council has been generally receptive to Mayor Katie Wilson’s proposed shelter plan, which would add nearly 1,000 shelter beds, including tiny house villages and RV safe lots, at a cost of around $37 million over two years.

On Tuesday, Wilson said she welcomed the idea of using the “new” $26 million from JumpStart and the improved revenue forecast to restore funding for the fire department overtime, food access funding that was cut because of an ongoing decline in revenues from the sugary beverage tax, and other programs her budget proposed cutting.

“Obviously, there’s a lot of competing priorities for that money, and I trust the council to make some good decisions there,” Wilson said. “Hopefully, they’re not putting it toward things that people are going to expect to be ongoing programs, but are funded with one-time money, because that is what got us into this problem in the first place. So I hope that they’re able to use that money on truly one-time expenditures.”

Earlier this month, the consultant working to reconcile the King County Regional Homelessness Authority’s finances released a report concluding that the KCRHA overspent its budget by a cumulative total of almost $17 million. That shortfall, which the report calls “unrecoverable” by the agency, will have to be made up by the city and county. On Tuesday, Wilson declined to say how much the city could owe for the eventual bailout, saying the city, county, and KCRHA are in active discussions about that question.

This Week On PubliCola: SPD Exodus, Proposed RV Restrictions, Wilson Derangement Syndrome, and More

By Erica C. Barnett

Monday, August 10

Greater Seattle: Primary Election Edition

In the second edition of his new column, Josh Feit argues that Mayor Wilson is doing better than the mainstream press—who’ve had it in for her ever since she defeated business bro Bruce Harrell—would have you believe. Plus, some more good news for Wilson’s fellow progressives on both ends of the city.

Tuesday, August 11

Strauss Legislation Would Require RV Residents to Get Permits, Accept “Appropriate” Shelter

City Councilmember Dan Strauss says a new set of proposals will give people living in RVs and trailers new opportunities to move into shelter and housing—and, by the way, rid the city of unsightly vehicles. Homeless advocates say the punitive elements of Strauss’ plan, which would create RV permits that could be revoked for a long list of reasons, could leave many desperate people worse off than before.

Wednesday, August 12

Interim Police Chief Andre Sayles Says He Won’t Be Barnes 2.0: “I’m All About Collaboration”

In an interview with PubliCola, new interim police chief Andre Sayles talked about how he’ll be different than his predecessor, Shon Barnes, who hired Sayles as his second deputy chief in 2025. I asked Sayles how he’ll repair broken trust with Seattle’s LGBTQ community, how he’ll work with the CARE Team of first responders, and whether he plans to move to Seattle permanently—like Barnes, Sayles has a home out of state and travels to visit his family there.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

Thursday, August 13

Councilmembers Blame Mayor For Delayed SPD Press Conference, Criticize Removal of Former Chief Barnes

A council meeting billed as a 15-minute “quick look” at SPD’s response to the Bite of Seattle shooting devolved into grandstanding and political theater, as council members fell over themselves to blame Mayor Katie Wilson for a delayed press conference the night of the shooting, conveniently absolving SPD of responsibility for information flow on a night when then-chief Barnes was out of town.

Friday, August 14

Former Chief Barnes’ Top Staffers Leave SPD

The exodus of Barnes’ top staffers—Sayles excepted—has begun, with the departure of chief communications officer Barbara DeLollis and crime prevention specialist Lee Hunt from the department. Barnes brought an entourage of new, highly paid executive staff with him when he started; his reluctance to cut any of these extra positions during a budget crisis was reportedly a source of tension with Wilson.

KOMO Reporters Leave Union

A group of 22 reporters and anchors at KOMO TV will no longer be represented by SAG-AFTRA, after a 9-7 vote to decertify their union last week.

Also this week: I was a guest on Brian Callanan’s podcast News, Views, and Brews, where we discussed Barnes’ resignation, the recent primary elections, and the passage of Mayor Katie Wilson’s legislation banning rental “junk fees.” Brian is the longtime host of City Inside/Out on the Seattle Channel.

And: I covered many of the same topics as a guest (alongside musician and podcaster John Roderick and Washington Policy Center’s Paul Guppy) on KUOW’s Week In Review, where our conversation about Barnes’ departure and the search for Seattle’s next police chief took some surprising twists—turns out John and I share a loathing for management theories and leadership-conference jargon.

This Week On PubliCola: October 18, 2025

Still from new SPD recruiting video

By Erica C. Barnett

Monday, October 13

Harrell Says King County Public Health is “Failing Us,” Talks Tough on Trump, and Muses About an AI Wall Where You Can Ask MLK What He Had for Breakfast

Speaking to a friendly audience at the We Heart Seattle-sponsored “Great Debate” at the Washington Athletic Club, Mayor Bruce Harrell was cheerful and expansive as he complained about the healthy department, talked about how “cool” it would be to project an interactive AI version of MLK on a downtown wall, and suggested he’d be open to prohibiting protesters from wearing masks.

Tuesday, October 14

Seattle Spent Thousands on “Organized Retail Theft” Operation at Marshall’s, Arresting Five and Recovering $400 in Merchandise

An SPD operation that involved a stakeout to catch shoplifters at a Marshall’s discount store in West Seattle cost the city thousands of dollars‚ including pay for the 10 officers involved in the sting, and netted low-priced merchandise like knit beanies, children’s shoes, and two sweatshirts—the highest-value items, at $30 each). Police made five shoplifting arrests.

Seattle Nice: CoLEAD Brings a New Approach to 12th and Jackson

This week’s special guest on Seattle Nice, Purpose Dignity Action’s Director of Outreach and Special Initiatives Nichole AleThis Week On PubliCola: October 18, 2025xander, spoke with us about the work PDA’s CoLEAD program is doing with drug users at a longtime “hot spot” in the Chinatown International District.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

Wednesday, October 15

Council Takes Up Harrell’s “Inherently Unsustainable” Budget; New Spending Includes $800,000 in Speculative AI Spending

Mayor Bruce Harrell’s proposed budget is unsustainable and relies heavily on fiscal sleight-of-hand to come up with a balanced budget in 2026, a city council staff analysis concluded These tricks include relying on a one-time $141 million fund balance left over from 2025, which won’t be there to balance the budget next year; funding programs that will be necessary long-term with one-time resources, and assuming a $10 million “underspend” every year in the future,.

One of many new spends in the budget is $800,000 to implement unspecified new AI software at the Seattle Department of Construction and Inspections that, the city believes, will speed up permitting times by pre-checking applications and automating some functions currently provided by city employees.

Thursday, October 16

“It Was Cold”: Mothers Who Lost Children to Gun Violence Say Harrell Ignored Their Pleas for Help

Mothers who lost their sons to gun violence told PubliCola they felt ignored and disrespected by Mayor Bruce Harrell, who they accused of exploiting their tragedies for political points. Several described a healing circle where Harrell turned out to be a special guest, but left early after a verbal clash with one of the women, telling the group “I didn’t even want to come here.”

Friday, October 17

SPD Can’t Find Funds to Recruit Women While Spending $3 Million on Macho Ads; Affordable Housing Tax Will Pay for Police Surveillance Instead; Pro-Harrell PAC Goes Low

Harrell’s proposed budget for the police department includes more than $3 million in annual costs for (yet another) recruiting firm that has created (yet another) series of high-octane, macho ads; meanwhile, it fails to fund a staffer to advance recruitment of women, on the grounds that SPD doesn’t have enough money.

Meanwhile, Harrell’s budget uses the JumpStart payroll tax—originally earmarked for affordable housing, Green New Deal programs, and equitable development—for policing at next year’s World Cup games and the expansion of CCTV surveillance cameras into the Stadium District.

A new mailer from the pro-Harrell PAC headed up by his deputy mayor, Tim Burgess, sent out a condescending, misleading mailer featuring his opponent Katie Wilson’s resume as of 2015, when it went back to 2006 and included jobs at a bakery and as resident manager of an apartment building. The flip side featured Harrell’s resume, which revealed that he hasn’t applied for a job since 1990 at the latest.

Durkan Told SPD To Ignore Law Imposing Expiration Date on Police Hiring Bonuses

By Erica C. Barnett

Last year, as the city was debating how to address skyrocketing attrition from the Seattle Police Department, Mayor Jenny Durkan signed a controversial emergency order that offered signing bonuses between $10,000 and $25,000 to new SPD officers and staffers at the city’s 911 call center.

The city council, which had spent months trying to get the department to stop spending beyond its means, was reluctant to agree to an open-ended hiring bonus program and subsequently voted 8-1 to amend the executive order so that it would expire at the end of 2021. (The lone “no” vote was socialist Kshama Sawant, who opposed funding even temporary hiring bonuses.) The council also rejected Durkan’s efforts to add $1.1 million to the 2022 budget to fund hiring bonuses this year. Executive orders, including any amendments, have the force of law.

Instead of accepting the council’s changes, Durkan decided she could just ignore them.

On December 30, Durkan sent a directive to Police Chief Adrian Diaz and Community Safety and Communications Center Chris Lombard telling them to disregard the council’s changes to her order and keep issuing bonuses after the expiration date. 

Her explanation was vague. “Based on consultations with legal Counsel, it has been concluded that the City Council’s actions to limit the Emergency Order were not effective,” Durkan wrote. “Thus, you should continue to hire and implement the terms of the Order, until incoming Mayor Harrell or the City Council effectively act [to] extend or alter the terms of the Order.”

“Based on consultations with legal counsel, it has been concluded that the City Council’s actions to limit the Emergency Order were not effective,” Durkan wrote. “Thus, you should continue to hire and implement the terms of the Order, until incoming Mayor Harrell or the City Council effectively act TO extend or alter the terms of the Order.”—Ex-Mayor Jenny Durkan, directing SPD to ignore the expiration of the city’s hiring incentive law

Durkan staffer Julie Kline (currently an attorney at Schroeter, Goldmark, & Bender, Durkan’s former firm) sent a letter, signed by Durkan, to then mayor-elect Harrell’s office the same day providing slightly more detail about her legal reasoning. “[I]t was concluded,” she wrote, “that Council’s failure to act on my Emergency Order in the time frame imposed by ordinance renders their actions ineffective as they did not endeavor to act in 48 hours as required by law.”  In other words: Because the council didn’t act to amend the mayor’s emergency order within 48 hours, the expiration date never took effect.

“Accordingly,” Durkan continued, “I sent the attached letter to Chief Diaz and Director Lombard advising them that Council’s late action was not effective and that they should continue hiring according to the terms of the Emergency Order, until such time as you act to remand or revise the Emergency Order or Council takes effective legislative action.” In other words: Not only was Durkan ordering SPD to keep offering hiring bonuses in defiance of the council’s action, the only way to halt the bonuses would be to pass a brand-new law rescinding or changing it.

The problem with Durkan’s “48-hour rule” argument is that there is no 48-hour rule. There’s no deadline at all. Instead, the Seattle Municipal Code says the council must “endeavor to act on any order within 48 hours of its being presented to the Council by the Mayor.” That’s a recommendation, not a mandate.

A spokesman for Harrell’s office, Jamie Housen, said the administration “learned of the directives from Mayor Durkan on Thursday, January 27th and learned the bonuses were still in effect on Friday, January 28th. This new information directly conflicted with how the Durkan administration had previously briefed the incoming Harrell administration on these bonuses.”

Housen said Durkan’s email went to Harrell,  Senior Deputy Mayor Harrell’s email, three top Durkan staffers, Diaz, Lombard, and one of at least two non-public-facing email addresses for Durkan, mayorjennydurkan@seattle.gov.  “There was no additional follow up to the Harrell administration about this change,” Housen said, and “[t]he letter was not seen or read by the mayor or the deputy mayor until we became aware of it in late January.

According to Housen, Durkan’s office gave the incoming administration a briefing that included a slide stating that the emergency order would end on January 1 and recommending that the Harrell administration take action to extend it.

 

In an email to city council members and staff last week, Senior Deputy Mayor Harrell apologized for overlooking Durkan’s memo to Harrell about the hiring bonuses. “It was my belief (as per all the information provided to us by the outgoing Executive’s team via transitional in-person briefings and prior written documentation) that the incentive pay was ending on December 31st,” Deputy Mayor Harrell wrote. We have sent followup questions to Harrell’s office and will update this post when hear back.

As Matt Markovich reported for Q13 Wednesday, SPD has removed all references to hiring bonuses from their website.

The council did not allocate any money for police and call-center hiring bonuses beyond 2021. So far, SPD has hired at least five new officers this year, and the CSCC has hired at least 13 new staffers. Depending on whether those were new ($10,000) or lateral ($25,000) hires, the cost could be anywhere from approximately $180,000 to $450,000 or higher.

A spokesman for the police department responded to a list of detailed questions with the following statement: “Our capacity to offer these incentives is currently under review.” SPD did not answer questions about the directive and its implementation, how much hiring bonuses have cost the city in 2022 and how SPD will pay for them, why they stopped advertising hiring bonuses, and other questions about its decision to keep paying bonuses this year despite the council’s action in 2021.

According to Housen, the Harrell administration “is coordinating with Council and drafting legislation to ensure the bonuses offered to newly hired officers and dispatchers are fulfilled. The Mayor’s Office will continue to work with Council on future strategies to improve SPD, CSCC, and citywide staffing.” Last year, the council formally requested a study of a citywide hiring bonus program to fill frontline positions in all departments, not just SPD.

Seattle’s Hotel-Based Shelters Racing Against Deadline to Close at the End of the Month

King's Inn
King’s Inn in Belltown

By Erica C. Barnett

With less than three weeks remaining before their contracts expire, the organizations that run two hotel-based shelters the city funded last year are scrambling to find housing for more than 100 homeless clients. One, the Chief Seattle Club, needs to relocate about 60 people from the King’s Inn shelter in Belltown; the other, the Low Income Housing Institute, must find shelter or housing for about 90 people still staying at the Executive Pacific hotel downtown.

Under their current contracts, which the King County Regional Homelessness Authority took over and declined to extend late last year, both hotels must empty out on January 31. (The actual contracts last another month, to give the agencies time to clean and repair any damage to the properties.) Both agencies stopped accepting new clients last year, and LIHI started moving hotel guests into other properties it operates, including tiny house villages, shelters, and permanent housing. Chief Seattle Club, meanwhile, made plans to move people from King’s Inn into two housing projects it had under development, including one, ?al?al, that was supposed to open in October.

Since then, however, the upsurge in COVID cases have combined with a longstanding shortage of construction industry workers to delay ?al?al and other housing projects and put the agencies’ timelines in question. Anne Xuan Clark, a development consultant for Chief Seattle Club, described a cascade of delays that have pushed back the opening date for ?al?al again and again: Rescheduled fire inspections, the discovery of an underground conduit that upended the schedule to pour a sidewalk outside the building, interminable waits for utility hookups. “Every construction project in the city is facing delays,” Clark said.

Not every person at King’s Inn will move into Chief Seattle Club’s own housing; some will use federal emergency housing vouchers, and some will use short-term rapid rehousing subsidies; the same is true for those currently staying at the Executive Pacific, and those have stayed at both hotels in the past and moved into other shelter or housing.

Since last year, the upsurge in COVID cases have combined with a longstanding shortage of construction industry workers to delay ?al?al and other housing projects and put the agencies’ timelines in question.

LIHI is facing similar challenges, its director, Sharon Lee, said; if several new projects where LIHI had hoped to move hotel guests aren’t finished by the end of January, “we may have to put some people in another temporary [shelter],” such as a hotel. “We don’t think that’s the best solution either—to move them from one hotel to another hotel.”

The problems LIHI and Chief Seattle Club are facing as they wind down their hotel-based shelters are only partly the result of housing construction delays. In fact, the biggest challenges were baked into the contracts from the very beginning. Former mayor Jenny Durkan, who initially resisted accepting federal COVID relief dollars to move people from the streets to hotels, agreed to a very limited hotel-based shelter program last year on the condition that the hotels would serve as way stations for people moving swiftly into housing, rather than long-term shelter. The idea was to move people from encampments to hotels to market-rate apartments, using “rapid rehousing” subsidies as a bridge between unsheltered, often chronic, homelessness to self-sufficiency.

Rapid rehousing is generally a poor fit for people who have been living outdoors for a long time or those with conditions that make it hard to work. Yet those are precisely the people the city prioritized for the new hotel-based shelter beds.

As we’ve reported, rapid rehousing is most effective for people with minimal barriers to housing and employment—those who can get jobs quickly and earn enough to afford an apartment in Seattle. It is generally a poor fit for people who have been living outdoors for a long time or those with conditions that make it hard to work. Yet those are precisely the people the city prioritized for the new hotel-based shelter beds. As a result, people did not tend to move from hotel rooms to apartments; instead, they ended up back on the streets, moved into other forms of shelter like tiny house villages, or stayed put. Continue reading “Seattle’s Hotel-Based Shelters Racing Against Deadline to Close at the End of the Month” →

Seattle’s Winter Homelessness Response: A Look Back (and Forward)

By Erica C. Barnett

On Christmas Eve 2008, after a series of snowstorms paralyzed the city for most of a week, then-mayor Greg Nickels made an offhand comment that became a major factor in his election loss the following year. Asked to grade his administration on its response to the winter weather, Nickels gave himself a “B,” praising his transportation department and its director, Grace Crunican, for performing admirably during several successive snowstorms that hampered the city’s ability to clear roads and sidewalks.

Nickels was roundly derided for his blithe self-assessment. Since then, mayors have been reluctant to publicly reckon with their performance during weather emergencies, even as those emergencies have become more frequent.

Jenny Durkan presided over Seattle’s response to the most recent weather emergency; Bruce Harrell, and the new King County Homelessness Authority, will oversee the region’s next one. And while the city has undoubtedly become more savvy and prepared when it comes to clearing snow and slush from streets, its efforts to keep unsheltered people alive and warm during the harshest weather have not kept up with the growing need. Here’s a look at how the city’s systems for keeping unsheltered people alive in the cold held up during the winter weather emergency, and some thoughts about how they could do better in the future.

Shelter

As PubliCola reported last month, under Mayor Jenny Durkan, the city ended its past practice of funding winter-only shelters, saying that they have “replaced” these seasonal shelters with year-round options that are open 24 hours a day. While 24-hour, year-round shelters are undoubtedly an improvement on shelters that close in the spring, they are not a substitute. And the number of new shelter beds represented a tiny fraction of the growing need over the last four yers. In total, the Durkan Administration added just 350 permanent shelter beds during Durkan’s time in office (a number that does not include 150 hotel-based COVID shelters that will shut down at the end of this month).

In lieu of winter-only, 24-hour shelters, the city set aside funds to open two short-term, nighttime-only shelters for up to 15 days each, with an initial capacity of just over 200 beds. The two bare-bones shelters, run by the Salvation Army at Seattle Center and the Compass Housing Alliance in Pioneer Square, respectively, opened at 7pm and closed 12 hours later. Compass runs a day center at the same site as its nighttime shelter and allowed clients and shelter guests to stay there until the center closed at 4pm each day, while Salvation Army guests had to walk to the Seattle Center Armory and wait for it to open at 10am each day.)

“We hear a general disinterest in leaving personal property unattended or behind, a preference for use of the 24-hour year-round locations with services specific to people experiencing homelessness like hygiene services or other supportive services, a preference for any locations open to have food, a preference to shelter in place with request for harm reduction warming supplies.” —Jenna Franklin, Human Services Department

Once it was clear there would be more demand for overnight shelter than the city originally anticipated, officials acted quickly, expanding the size of the Salvation Army shelter and opening City Hall as an overnight shelter run by the Urban League, with initial room for about 30 people. (City Hall expanded to 24 hours on December 27.) Three additional shelters opened outside downtown, two in Lake City and one in West Seattle, with a total capacity of about 70 people, on December 27 and 28. Only one, a 16-bed shelter at a VFW hall in West Seattle, was open 24 hours a day.

Although hundreds of people did go into shelter at night, the shelters were not completely full, and those outside downtown Seattle were especially underutilized. One common reason people do not come into emergency nighttime shelters, as opposed to 24-hour shelters with storage and (in some cases) semi-private sleeping quarters, is that they don’t want to risk losing all their stuff by abandoning their tents, including survival gear and sleeping bags that can be difficult to haul from place to place.

“.We hear a general disinterest in leaving personal property unattended or behind, a preference for use of the 24-hour year-round locations with services specific to people experiencing homelessness like hygiene services or other supportive services, a preference for any locations open to have food, a preference to shelter in place with request for harm reduction warming supplies like blankets, hand warmers, hats, gloves, etc. (which we continue to order and provide),” Jenna Franklin, a spokeswoman for the Human Services Department, told PubliCola last week. These barriers to shelter are longstanding and ongoing, and familiar to the city from its experience with previous weather emergencies.

Transportation

Another reason people frequently don’t come indoors during harsh winter conditions, according to the city and service providers, is that they lack a way to get from wherever they ordinarily stay (an encampment in a public park in Northwest Seattle, say) to a temporary shelter or daytime warming center across town.

While the city did send out a handful of vans to pick up unsheltered people and bring them to shelters, their offers of transportation consisted primarily of Metro bus tickets, which were useless on routes that were canceled or only running sporadically because of the snow and ice. People with mobility impairments were particularly challenged—those who use wheelchairs or walkers can’t easily get into vans without lifts, and larger vans with lifts can only be operated by drivers with commercial driver’s licenses, who were also needed to run snow plows.

“There has been some reticence about, if go to this particular shelter right now and it closes, and don’t have the opportunity to get to the warming shelter, what will I do?”—Jon Ehrenfeld, Health One

The fact that the city’s primary form of outreach was through the HOPE Team probably didn’t help. The team, which ordinarily does outreach to people living in encampments the city is about to remove, was out looking for people throughout the week, but encampment residents often mistrust a team that, for the majority of the year, is directly associated with sweeps.

The city’s decision to open separate daytime and nighttime shelters, instead of ensuring that people could stay inside, in one location, for the duration of the winter emergency, also created transportation issues. Although Franklin said many of the warming centers were “adjacent” to nighttime shelters, this was only true in the case of the Pioneer Square (Compass) and Seattle Center (Salvation Army) shelters; the Lake City Community Center warming center was located a half-mile away from the nearest shelter, and the other four community center-based warming centers were nowhere near any nighttime shelter at all.

“From what I’ve heard, it’s the discontinuity between daytime and nighttime shelters” that led many unsheltered people to decline shelter offers during the emergency, Jon Ehrenfeld, a program manager with the Seattle Fire Department’s Health One program, said. “There has been some reticence about, if go to this particular shelter right now and it closes, and don’t have the opportunity to get to the warming shelter, what will I do?”

Ehrenfeld said Health One focused mostly on handing out blankets and other survival supplies, thermoses filled with hot water for soup, and food. The mobile units, like other city departments responding to the emergency, were short-staffed due to COVID and still responding to non-acute emergency calls unrelated to the weather, Ehrenfeld said.

Daytime Warming Centers

In addition to the daytime warming centers at the Compass and Salvation Army shelters, the city opened up four community centers and one park building as warming sites—Lake City, Northgate, Rainier Beach, International District/Chinatown, and Building 46 at Magnuson Park. Almost no one used these locations. On several days, the Rainier Beach, International District, and Magnuson locations stood empty (according to the city’s Parks Department, the “average” usage at the Magnuson site was zero), while the other locations served one or two people at a time. The most-utilized site, Lake City, peaked at a total of eight people over the course of one day. Continue reading “Seattle’s Winter Homelessness Response: A Look Back (and Forward)” →