
By Erica C. Barnett
For those following along with the City Council’s budget process, budget chair Dan Strauss’ effort to wrap the whole thing up with a bow on Friday failed dramatically, after the city firefighters’ pension fund filed a lawsuit over budget maneuvers that would empty out and close down an obscure fire pension fund to supplement general-fund spending.
The lawsuit, linked on CivicTide last week, accuses the city of unlawfully closing down the pension account. As of this posting, the document is not available because the King County Superior Court website is down.”
In a letter to the council last Thursday, Seattle Fire Fighters union president Kenny Stuart wrote, “We believe that it is fiscally irresponsible, and just plain wrong, to use dedicated pension reserves for non-pension purposes. These pension reserves have been legally dedicated to the retired fire fighters who have served this community and many of the current recipients are their widows.”
“Seattle Fire Fighters never forget, and our City should never forget the promises made to those who served,” Stuart wrote.
The firefighters’ pension fund provides retirement benefits for firefighters who retired before 1977. Every year, the city is required to transfer funds into a related account, called the actuarial account, that serves as a kind of interest-earning reserve for the “pay-as-you-go” pension fund; in 2027, that amount was supposed to be almost $3 million. In her budget, Wilson proposed closing down this second account and using $10 million of the money, over two years, to support the city’s general fund on a one-time basis. The rest of the actuarial fund would go into the main firefighters’ pension fund, and the annual transfers would end.
Strauss’ separate proposal would have gone much further, reducing the amount the city transfers into the firefighters’ pension fund by $11 million a year, or $22 million over the two-year budget cycle and freeing that money up to pay for some of the approximately $75 million in new spending council members proposed adding to Wilson’s budget. That last-minute decision, which Strauss announced last week, appears to be what spurred the lawsuit.
On Sunday, Stuart said transferring money around this way is like moving money from a savings account set aside to pay a mortgage into a checking account. “If I [set aside that money] and my wife and I agree, and then one day, without telling her, I decide I want to put all that money in our checking account, my wife would say, ‘What are you doing? You can’t just unilaterally decide that.” Council members have argued that they’re keeping the pension fund whole while freeing up more general fund dollars for other spending, but Stuart said, “I can follow the bouncing ball—yes, you can call it general fund money, but the reason the general fund is bigger is because you made this deposit.”
PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.
Strauss put his $22 million proposal in a “chair’s package” of consent amendments—amendments where there was supposedly council consensus, allowing the council to vote the whole thing through as a package without any discussion or debate. Earlier this week, he predicted the council would be able to conduct all discussion of every amendment, including those on his consent package and those that would definitely require more discussion, and pass the entire budget through committee on Friday.
Some council members objected, both in public and behind the scenes, to this accelerated schedule, since the consent package included many new amendments with less than majority support and many no one had ever seen before last week, sponsored only by Strauss himself. These included a sales tax increase that would directly reduce King County’s ability to prioritize its own human services projects, directives that would move spending on higher-priority projects to bus routes in Ballard, and a slew of new spending in the “Ballard Brewery District.”
Maritza Rivera, who asked for discussion of several “complicated and controversial” amendments in Strauss’ consent package on Friday, directed her comments at Strauss on Friday. “Chair, I have to admit that at times this process has felt less than forthright. … It feels like we don’t have all the information at the proper time we should have it and it also makes our constituents distrust government,” she said.
The firefighters’ letter threw an additional wrench into those optimistic plans, forcing the council into multiple executive sessions to discuss the potential litigation and causing visible frustration from council members on the dais. “We were not made aware of the complications surrounding the use of the firefighter actuarial fund, and we’ve learned the firefighter pension board and the firefighters were not in support of this,” Rivera said. “That should have been flagged from the start.”
The council concluded its day-long Friday meeting a little after 6pm, with most council members looking wilted and ready to go after they adopted what remained of the consent package after nearly 20 amendments were pulled out for additional discussion.
Strauss said he hopes to wrap up the budget on Monday. Whether that happens will depend on what advice the city attorney’s office gives the council on the budget’s use of the pension fund to pay for general spending. Restoring the actuarial account would blow a massive hole in the budget that the council has little time to address this, when the full budget, including all council amendments and related legislation, is supposed to move through committee.
Even if the proposed budget, with the reductions to the pension contributions and the closure of the actuarial account, prevails, the funding only goes through 2028, meaning the city will have once again set itself up to either make significant cuts in the near future or come up with more budget tricks, such as additional raids on the JumpStart payroll tax fund, to keep all the new spending the council piled on this year.
Stuart said the firefighters’ union wasn’t aware of the pension fund issue until they found out about the lawsuit. “If they’re in a fight, I’m in a fight. We’re not going to go along with it just because it creates more money. It’s dirty money, and the council shouldn’t use dirty money.”
Mayor Katie Wilson’s office declined to comment on the firefighters’ response to Strauss’ amendments, except to say that “the mayor is aware of the lawsuit.”





