The budget funds new programs and restores old ones by digging into reserves, spending down one-time funding and making ongoing programs vanish from future financial plans by labeling them as “one-time” expenditures.
By Erica C. Barnett
On an unusual 7-2 vote, the city council’s budget committee, which includes all nine council members, adopted the vast majority of the city’s amended 2027-2028 budget Thursday morning. A final vote, with additional votes on two amendments that would set up fiscal guardrails around the council’s spending, is scheduled for Friday afternoon.
The total city budget, which includes rate-funded departments like Seattle City Light and capital expenditures, is a little over $9 billion, but when I refer to “the budget,” I’m talking about the general fund—the discretionary budget the city debates and passes every fall.
Seattle’s 2027-2028 budget started out as a mayoral proposal that won praise from Wilson skeptics in the business community (and criticism from advocates who support more spending on human services and less on cops) because it closed an estimated budget deficit of $175 million without new taxes. Most noticeably, Wilson’s budget didn’t rely heavily on the kind of budgetary tricks that have allowed the mayor and council to pile on more and more new spending every year, such as using one-time funds to pay for ongoing programs.
This kind of small-c fiscal conservatism meant cutting lots of programs the council had previously paid for on a rolling “one-time” basis, a practice that routinely resulted in nine-figure deficits just over the two-year budget horizon. The council, as I’ve reported in recent weeks, complained bitterly about cuts to programs they assumed would be ongoing and immediately started restoring all the cuts. For a moment in September, though, it seemed possible that some of the council’s unsustainable recent spending, like the $7 million they get each year to fund out small transportation projects in their districts, would go away.
Wilson’s budget didn’t entirely do away with budget tricks. It took $65 million in JumpStart payroll tax revenues out of the Office of Housing and used the money to fund nearly 1,000 new shelter beds, on top of a $173 million transfer from JumpStart to the general fund. Her budget also closed down and used $10 million from an obscure firefighter pension fund, a decision that (along with a much larger, $22 million pension raid that council budget chair Dan Strauss quietly inserted into his proposed consent package) resulted in a lawsuit by the firefighters’ pension board, which says they never consented to the closure of the interest-earning fund.
But Wilson made it clear early on that she didn’t like funding the city’s budget on short-term credit. “It is my hope that they share the value that we should we should be budgeting responsibly and maintaining a balanced budget, not just next year but in the out years as well,” Wilson said in an interview with the Seattle Nice podcast, which I cohost, in October. “And if they want to add things, they also need to find places to to make further reductions.”
As readers of this site probably know already, the council did not make further reductions. Like last year, when they larded then-mayor Bruce Harrell’s already bloated budget with $78 million in additional new spending, the council restored most of the mayor’s cuts and added lots of new spending of their own.
To pay for some of this new spending, Strauss was able to lean on one-time funding from a positive October budget forecast combined with a surprise late JumpStart tax payment, adding up to about $26 million over the next three years. The council’s budget adds far exceeded that amount, however, so the final budget also relies on the transfer of an additional $31 million from JumpStart to the city’s general fund over the next two years, with a built-in assumption of another $11 million transfer in 2029. The city would also grab around $13 million from JumpStart’s revenue stabilization fund in 2028, lowering it to $20 million, the minimum requirement.
In all, the council padded the budget with around $75 million in new spending, the vast majority of it funded with purportedly “one-time” dollars. Of the council’s adds, more than $40 million are programs that are obviously meant to be ongoing, like the $7 million-a-year “district fund” program that lets council members fund small transportation projects in their districts. By pretending. these ongoing programs will end abruptly in 2027 or 2028, the council has managed to create a budget that is balanced on paper but unsustainable in reality. Because many of the new projects are only funded in 2027, the true price tag for these projects, starting in 2029, is close to $60 million. These debts will start coming due next year.
While the council’s budget currently appears balanced through 2030 on paper, it’s on track to fall into an immediate $59 million deficit in 2029, when the council inevitably extends funding for the new programs funded with one-time dollars. Through her budget director, Aly Pennucci, Wilson told the council she has no plans to do their work for them by coming up with sustainable funding for their projects. “[I]tems labeled as “one-time” in the budget for 2027, 2028, or both, will be removed from the 2028 and/or 2029 baseline budget,” Pennucci told the council in a November 6 memo. “That is your direction to [the budget office when you adopt spending as one-time.”
Most on the council saw it differently. In Strauss’ view, the council has fixed the mayor’s “austerity budget” and restored programs she was foolish to propose cutting. “We’re reversing the proposed cuts of firefighters, funding to work funding to stop violent crime, making record-high investments in affordable housing, and all while balancing the budget through 2030. We are proving that Seattle can balance its budget, fund essential services, and respond to urgent needs of our community,” Strauss said.
Throughout the budget several councilmembers—notably centrist Councilmember Maritza Rivera, who ended up voting against the budget —pointed out the obvious: The council, Rivera said Thursday, was simply not living in fiscal reality. “In no way am I trying to say that I don’t understand all the priorities everybody put into the budget. I am saying, however, that the way we did this was not the best way to do it, because it is not sustainable,” Rivera said. “I can’t in good conscience support the budget … because those adds should have been made in a fiscally responsible way, and I don’t think that is what’s happening here.”
Progressive Councilmember Alexis Mercedes Rinck also voted against the budget, citing some of the same concerns about fiscal responsibility Rivera raised. Rinck focused, however, on the budget’s $69 million boost for the police department, most of which ($56 million) will pay for huge wage increases that were included in the most recent police guild contract. That contract was rushed through after Wilson, seen at the time as a strong advocate for police accountability, was elected, and it included almost no new accountability requirements in exchange for some of the highest police salaries in the nation.
The mandatory spending on police “means around a dozen city workers who have been told their jobs are on the line,” Rinck said, a reference to city layoffs that the budget defers for six months. “It means cuts to food equity programs. It means millions taken out of the Office of Housing in a city where the lack of housing and homelessness are a core crisis.”
The council’s budget also restores the authority to fill six vacant positions on the Unified Care Team, a $35 million team that removes encampments from public spaces. On Thursday, Councilmember Bob Kettle called Wilson’s move to eliminate these long-unfilled positions “one of the little tells” that show the mayor is opposed to public safety. “The unfunding of public safety is the defining feature of this budget,” Kettle said. The council restored the vacant positions. They did not, however, approve another Kettle amendment that would have spent an additional $11 million hiring more new officers than Wilson’s budget funds.
In recent weeks, I’ve reported on some of programs and projects the council added to the mayor’s budget. The list includes a large illuminated statue of Jimothy, the internet raccoon, which will grace the streets of Ballard at Christmastime for the next 15 to 20 years; a new anti-graffiti “art wall” in Delridge; and another extension of a pandemic-era small business repair fund, which pays, among other things, to fix broken windows. Other “one-time” council adds would pay for ongoing food assistance, sex worker outreach, gun violence reduction, and economic revitalization in specific neighborhoods like Lake City.
The district transportation funds ($14 million over two years); restoring firefighter overtime that Wilson’s budget cut ($14 million); and programs for victims of gender-based violence ($7 million) are among the biggest-ticket items the council added with one-time dollars this year.
In addition to those adds, the council also restored funding for nine vacant long-parking enforcement officer positions, whose funding SPD routinely uses to pay for other priorities, but budgeted them at a cost of $0 on the assumption that the positions will pay for themselves in tickets. (Debora Juarez, who’ll be replaced by Nilu Jenks next week, called Wilson’s proposal to cut these empty seats an example of the mayor’s “offensive” “abolish the police” agenda.) If SPD continues to leave those positions vacant, they’ll continue to cost real money—about $2 million over two years.
PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.
There are arguments to be made for all these programs, and in many case, strong arguments. But it’s hard to argue that putting them in budgetary limbo every year is good for their viability. Making council priorities “one-time” (with a wink) arguably deprioritizes them in the budget, making them the subject of annual scrambles for funding.
Notable items that did not make it into the budget include $2.5 million a year in Seattle Transit Measure funding that Strauss wanted to earmark to expand bus service to northwest Ballard, an area that falls low on the city’s equity-based prioritization list for STM projects; $11 million Kettle proposed adding to hire more police officers; Councilmember Eddie Lin’s proposal to spend $16 million over two years to give human service providers a 3 percent wage equity pay boost; and a proposal from Foster to set aside 50 percent of JumpStart revenues for affordable housing and equitable development, two of JumpStart’s original designated spending categories.
Kettle articulated the council majority’s view on Friday, when he said he sees JumpStart as “something along the lines of a general fund.” The tax, which applies to excess compensation of highly paid employees at the city’s biggest companies, was supposed to help offset the economic impact of a mass influx of wealthy tech workers in Seattle.
The council will vote on two additional budget amendments on Friday, both from Councilmember Dionne Foster.
The first, which failed 5-4 in committee, would require the council to adopt a final budget that’s balanced not just for two years, as required by state law, but in projections that extend four years beyond that. The council adopted a new law holding the mayor’s proposed budget to this standard but declined to apply the same constraint to themselves, citing the imbalance of powers in Seattle’s strong-mayor system, the fact that the council has less time than the mayor to consider the budget, and the idea that they need “flexibility” to fund their own priorities.
The second, which failed by default because Strauss abstained, would direct any money the city recovers from $13 million in police overpayments to the Office of Housing, which gave up $65 million this year in a fund swap that freed up revenues from the JumpStart payroll tax, which would ordinarily go to housing, to pay for homelessness programs. (The mayor has said she has a plan to reimburse OH for the money.) This, too, seems unlikely to pass, but a new vote will force Strauss to pick a side; he abstained from voting in committee, but council rules prohibit abstentions at full council meetings.






