Tag: Seattle Police Department

Wilson Says Expanding Police Surveillance System Will Help Make Seattle “The Safest Big City in the Country”

By Erica C. Barnett

Mayor Katie Wilson announced she’ll proceed with an expansion of police surveillance in the Central District, Capitol Hill, and SoDo (where cameras are already installed), subject to a handful of new requirements that were outlined in the NYU Policing Project’s civil-rights audit, released yesterday. The decision, Wilson said, was part of “making Seattle the safest big city in the country—safe from gun violence and serious crime, and safe from authoritarianism from the federal government.” The expansion was proposed by former mayor Bruce Harrell but put on “pause” shortly after Wilson took office. 

Like Harrell, Wilson framed her defense of mass surveillance in terms of community safety and justice. “Our city has too many grieving families, too many communities who rightfully expect crimes to be solved, but are losing hope of their day in court,” Wilson said. “Justice means protecting from harm and preventing it. It means delivering accountability afterward. My decision today strikes that balance.”

At a press conference with the mayor on Tuesday, interim police chief Andre Sayles said the cameras were a big part of the reason there were no homicides in June and that the World Cup was safe; Wilson turned on the cameras near the stadiums during the monthlong event, citing an unspecified “credible threat.”

But the Policing Project audit found that there was “thin” evidence that indiscriminate surveillance—their term for surveillance that applies to everyone in a public place, rather than people suspected of a crime—helps police solve or prevent crime. About 300 communities currently have Real Time Crime Centers like Seattle’s, which layer CCTV surveillance feeds with other data and live communications in an attempt to respond to crimes more quickly and solve them after the fact. The audit also found that while Seattle police often claim the RTCC was instrumental to solving a crime, the reality is that SPD counts any interaction with the system, such as an officer calling up a single camera, as a successful intervention.

The statistics SPD provided “reflect that in 2025, the RTCC  assisted in 17 homicide cases, with its support helping to close 10 of these cases. In SPD’s data analysis, however, it defines RTCC “support’as a case in which an RTCC analyst takes any action (such as checking a camera), regardless of whether that action yielded any useful information or meaningfully impacted the investigation,” the report found.

Asked about this at a press conference on Tuesday, Wilson seemed confident that the cameras help police address crime, despite the lack of a “controlled experiment” proving that they do. She was especially compelled, she said, by arguments that police are short-staffed and need all the help they can get, including from camera footage and the ability to view crime scenes in real time and after the fact.

“I do believe, from my conversations with our RTCC staff and officers, that the cameras are helpful both in investigations and in real time incidents,” Wilson said. “And you can argue about how helpful. But I think [the cameras are] an efficient, effective use of our resources.”

Many opponents of police surveillance have expressed concerns that camera footage could be obtained by ICE or outside law enforcement agencies to track down immigrants or target people seeking abortions or gender-affirming care.

In a statement, the privacy advocates at Community Not Cameras, said, “Mayor Wilson’s campaign platform acknowledged that ‘Seattle can’t be a true sanctuary city if ICE can access data about you.’ Yet the audit makes clear that the City’s policies cannot eliminate that possibility.”

The report itself pointed this risk out explicitly, noting that all that’s required to obtain footage is a subpoena or simple records request (which can be anonymous, and don’t require a requester to state the reason for their request). Wilson, however, said she would “not allow the data that the city collects to be used to harm immigrants, LGBTQ plus people, or others who may be targeted by federal agencies or other bad actors.”

“None of the 19 recommendations [in the audit] puts the footage beyond federal reach,” Community Not Cameras’ statement continued. “A written policy does not stop a subpoena. The Mayor conceded as much today, saying ‘even if we implement all of these recommendations, some level of risk will remain.’”

Asked how she would accomplish this, Wilson noted that the report recommended limiting the amount of time camera footage is retained in a system owned by Axon, the company that provides Seattle’s camera system, when SPD proactively retains footage for investigations. Currently, that footage is stored indefinitely.

Wilson also noted that Seattle does not use Flock cameras, which are more widely used than Axon’s, adding that she believes Axon is a more “responsible” company. “Axon will continue to be a partner in designing a system for Seattle that meets our specific needs, fits our policies, and is consistent with our values,” Wilson said. In a video posted on X, Wilson emphasized the fact that there are “no Flock cameras in Seattle.”

“Flock, no. This is a different system managed by a different company,” Wilson said in the video.

But there’s really no difference between Flock and Axon. In an interview, NYU Policing Project’s director of  technology law and policy, Max Isaacs, said that while Flock and Axon have focused on different segments of the market, “it’s not like one is good and one is bad, or either one is better than the other. They’re both trying to do a similar thing, adopting similar business models” in an attempt to become “the Apples of surveillance tech.”

On Tuesday, Wilson acknowledged that “there’s no such thing as zero risk,” adding that Seattle (like Washington state) has directed police not  to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement efforts or help other states track down people who get health care here. “If the city gets a request from law enforcement that it can’t legally refuse, “we will shut down the camera system at least for 60 days,” she said.

Wilson’s announcement did not include the most ambitious recommendation from the NYU report, which said Seattle should require police to get a warrant before they go through footage “retrospectively” to track a person’s past movements. The report said this step was important to protect people from unlawful searches, and noted that it would only apply in the relatively rare circumstances when police want to track where someone went as part of an investigation, not in situations like a real-time response or to look at a crime scene remotely.

Wilson brushed a question (from the Urbanist) about why she didn’t include a warrant requirement in her announcement, saying Seattle police don’t use the RTCC to track people after the fact. An SPD spokesman confirmed that they have not used the cameras this way, largely because it would be a cumbersome process to track someone from camera to camera, given the current limits of the RTCC technology. However, the department does not have an explicit policy preventing them from using footage in this way, which was what the proposed warrant requirement was meant to address.

Among other commitments, Wilson sad SPD had agreed to complete and publish a dashboard on its usage of the RTCC and create an “omnibus surveillance policy,” two commitments the department made in 2024 and in 2025, respectively, but has not completed. Wilson also announced that SPD “will clarify and strengthen its policies and practices around permissible uses, access criteria and logs, data retention periods, requests from outside agencies, regular internal audits, and more.”

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

The city is also setting up an advisory group that will meet over the next few months to “develop additional policies around private camera integration, usage of the RTCC during large-scale events, protests and other First Amendment activity, and criteria guiding any future CCTV camera placements,” according to the announcement. Currently, 23 privately owned cameras at three locations feed directly into the Real Time Crime Center; individuals and business owners have voluntarily registered another 900 cameras at 159 locations, saying they will let SPD to use their private footage on request.

Meeting with the press immediately after Wilson’s announcement, City Council public safety committee chair Bob Kettle had measured praise for Wilson’s decision, which he said made obvious sense based on the conclusions of the study. (Previously, Kettle called Wilson’s decision to hold off on installing new cameras until the audit was complete “unconscionable.”

Kettle said he “disagree[d]” with the Policing Project’s finding that real time crime centers and surveillance do little to prevent or solve crime. In Seattle, he said, “Everybody thinks if you have 100 instances of crime, that you have 100 people doing it,” Kettle said. “That’s not the case. You may have 10 people doing 10 crimes, and then if that one person, if you’re catching them on crime two out of ten, then you’re preventing those next eight.”

Councilmember Eddie Lin said he was disappointed with the decision, and wished that the mayor had waited until the results of an additional audit by the city’s Office of Inspector General and the University of Pennsylvania come out early next year. That study will look into how the RTCC is used and whether Seattle’s surveillance system is effective at addressing crime.

“We were supposed to be getting these reports before we expanded further,” Lin said. “I think this recent report only reinforces the the need for us to have better protections and oversight in place,”

In a statement, the OIG said the NYU report and recommendations “reinforce and further inform issues that OIG identified in its first annual surveillance review; risk of improper data sharing with outside agencies, unclear criteria for expansion of RTCC technologies, and the need to enforce privacy protections on integrated cameras.”

 

Interim Police Chief Based Complaint Against Detective on Right-Wing Characterization of Anti-Trans Initiative

Now-interim Police Chief Andre Sayles at a press conference earlier this year with Mayor Katie Wilson.

In his interview with a city investigator, interim Chief Sayles said he still hadn’t read the initiative and appeared unfamiliar with SPD’s policy on political speech.

By Erica C. Barnett

Seattle’s interim police chief, Andre Sayles, acknowledged that his misconduct complaint against a veteran detective was based, at least in part, on right-wing podcaster Brandi Kruse’s characterization of a statewide initiative that would ban trans girls from playing girls’ sports. The detective, Beth Wareing, faced a backlash from Kruse and other right-wing activists after she spoke at a press conference opposing two anti-LGBTQ initiatives.

Sayles, who was deputy police chief when he filed his complaint, also confirmed that he didn’t read the initiative or seek out other sources of information about it before or after accusing the detective, Beth Wareing of dishonesty and insubordination—both potentially career-ending allegations.

The new revelations come from a recording of Sayles’ interview with an Office of Police Accountability staffer investigating his complaint, which OPA dismissed as unfounded. PubliCola obtained the recording through a records request.

As we reported last month, Wareing retired from SPD over Sayles’ complaint against her, calling it a “poorly considered, unprofessional, and an attempted violation of my First Amendment rights.”

After hearing the details of Sayles’ interview with OPA, Wareing said it was that “Interim Chief Sayles retaliated against me at the direction of a far-right podcaster to damage my hard-earned professional reputation, despite my nearly 30 years investigating child abuse, domestic violence, hate crimes, and other threats.

“He did not read the policies, the language of the initiatives, or endeavor to understand my comments prior to filing what was effectively a career ending complaint. A simple Google search would have revealed the broad availability of analysis regarding these initiatives, which are likely to have extraordinary collateral impacts on children. I am deeply concerned for the LGBTQ+ community and for SPD’s diverse workforce under his leadership. SPD and the City of Seattle can and should do better.”

Kruse, whose claims about the initiatives Sayles parroted in his complaint, is actively involved with the campaign for two initiatives from billionaire Brian Heywood’s group Let’s Go Washington. As a campaign volunteer, Kruse has headlined campaign rallies and raised money for the campaign and used her podcast as a campaign platform

Wareing spoke, with SPD’s permission, at a rally for No Hate in WA State, which is opposing the two Let’s Go Washington initiatives. The first would require school employees, such as counselors, to turn over notes on confidential conversations with students to their parents, raising concerns that students will no longer be able to confide in trusted adults at school about issues like sexuality, gender, and reproductive health care.

The second would ban trans girls from playing girls’ sports. To verify that girls meet the criteria, the initiative would require either proof of an athlete’s sex from a girl’s “personal physician” or—for girls who lack a personal physician—a genital exam or DNA test. Initiative supporters have claimed that girls already have to prove their biological sex to participate in sports, but that isn’t true; the initiative would add proof of sex to the state’s sports physical requirements for girls.

Wareing, a former hate crimes detective who worked on cases involving child sexual abuse, said at the press conference that “sexual predators often set themselves up as authority figures to give themselves more power and access to their victims. I believe this initiative would increase the risk of sexual abuse for girls participating in sports.”

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

In his interview, Sayles strongly disputed this, saying that he has three boys who played sports and “I know [that] having to take a physical doesn’t expose you to a high potential for sexual abuse. I think that was an inaccurate statement, and I believe that statement, obviously, it created some angst among people in our community.” Wareing, Sayles continued, was “saying these things without actual factual proof.” (The initiative would not apply to boys’ sports, and the high prevalence of sexual abuse in girls’ sports is not a matter of  serious debate.)

Sayles confirmed in the interview that his concerns about Wareing’s “accuracy” and “stance” were initially sparked by an email containing questions from Kruse about Wareing’s comments in which Kruse characterized Wareing’s statements as inaccurate. Kruse (who calls herself a “real girl” and refers to trans girls as “boys”) followed up on these questions with a barrage of podcasts and social media posts calling Wareing a “liar” promoting an “insane ideology” and demanding that SPD fire her.

Sayles filed his complaint against Wareing a few days after Kruse sent over her questions. By then, SPD was receiving more complaints, according to Sayles.

In his interview, Sayles initially called the pro-LGBTQ rally “not my cup of tea” before clarifying, “I didn’t know what it was about.” Once he “skimmed” a transcript of Wareing’s comments, however, he believed her remarks were “basically fearmongering” about “people’s sexual orientation and potentially being exposed to sexual assault due to potentially having to do physicals to participate in sports.”

If she had wanted to be “accurate,” Sayles said, Wareing should have included specific data points in her remarks.

“[She said] there’s ‘high potential'” for sexual assault, Sayles said. “Is [that] 10 cases, and seven of those 10 cases you can identify that because a person had to do a physical with an adult, that sexual abuse occurred for that child, or that person who identifies as LGBTQ plus or whatever a person may identify?” Sayles said. “And then, when she said, ‘increases the risk of sexual abuse for girls participating in sports,’ how is that accurate? Does it increase it just for girls, or can it increase sexual abuse for boys as well,  or whatever they may identify as? So, I think those statements and those comments were inaccurate.”

The OPA investigator also asked Sayles about the other allegation in his complaint—that Wareing had disobeyed a direct order by representing herself as an SPD officer after agreeing in advance not to do so, in compliance with SPD rules for political advocacy. Sayles acknowledged that Wareing never identified herself as a Seattle police officer, but said that was a “tricky line” to navigate in the modern world when anyone can look up information online, and where a member of the media might have asked Wareing where she works.

“There’s probably someone here at this police department or in the city that probably says the police department should have never let her [speak],” Sayles said. “I’m not going to tell people what they should be doing on their off duty time. But my thing is, if we’re gonna speak and we’re gonna say that we’re law enforcement, knowing that somebody can just Google our name unless we paid the money to have our stuff scrubbed on the internet, we have to give them factual information because they’re going to take it and people are going to run with it.”

Wareing, Sayles elaborated, should have been more careful about expressing such a strong political “stance” because people tend to believe anything a police officer says. “I think a majority of our country cherish the work that we do, and they take what we say and they take it, they take it as as gospel.,” Sayles said. “So they … are going to say, ‘Holy smokes! … This person is an expert in this, and what they’re saying is what’s going to occur.'”

Sayles’ complaint was dismissed after the OPA found that Wareing had not violated any policy  and was expressing her right to express her opinions as a private citizen, which is protected by both the Constitution and SPD’s internal policies. At one point, the investigator asked if Sayles, who was previously police chief in Beloit, Wisconsin, whether he had read SPD’s policy on political participation. Sayles said, “I have not.”

After reading the policy and saying Wareing seemed to have followed it, Sayles appeared to backtrack. “It’s that sticky and uneven line that we have to walk,” Sayles said. “Just as much as she’s giving her opinion… with this OPA complaint, is it me giving my opinion as well?” When weighing whether to submit the complaint, he said, it came down to “Well, I think some of the comments were not objective.”

Messages Show SPD Primarily Responsible for Information Gap After Bite of Seattle Shooting

 

The messages also reveal that Mayor Wilson was indecisive about going to the scene of the shooting while advisors gave conflicting recommendations and TV reporters speculated about why she wasn’t there.

By Erica C. Barnett

Mayor Katie Wilson’s office released hundreds of pages of internal Teams messages and texts between her staffers, herself, and Seattle Police Department officials from the night of the July 26 mass shooting at the Bite of Seattle and in the days following the shooting. (Full documents available here.)

The messages, which do not include communications between SPD officials except where the mayor’s office was included, show two things. First, that the mayor’s office dithered and debated whether Wilson herself should go to the scene of the shooting for three hours before she finally went to Seattle Center, partly in response to TV reporters criticizing her for not being there.

And second, that the primary reason for the delay in information, as well as almost all of the delay in holding a press conference that night, was that SPD delayed the release of information repeatedly, withholding any new information information from the public and press until the press conference finally took place around 11pm.

SPD, the messages show, knew critical details about the shooting, including the fact that it was not a random mass shooting or terrorist event within an hour of the shooting—that is, before 7:30pm—but did not put any of that information out broadly until after 1:00 in the morning on July 27.

The messages include texts from mayoral communications staffer Jonah Spangenthal-Lee to SPD Chief Operating Officer Sarah Smith asking her why SPD had not provided any information since a tweet warning the public of a shooting with “multiple shooting victims” at Seattle Center at 6:29pm. “Sarah, where is SPD”s statement?” Spangenthal-Lee wrote at 8:36. “It’s been two hours since you guys have posted anything? Even some tweets at this point…”

A few minutes later, Spangenthal-Lee told other mayoral staffers in an internal Teams chat, “It’s fucking embarrassing that SPD has waited HOURS to put anything out. … I’m just saying this is a massive fucking disaster and hit to public trust.”

Responding to the text, Smith wrote,”The team is actively handling the situation on the ground and with the media on scene. Still very chaotic right now. We will have more information out soon. A few minutes later, Wilson’s interim communications director, Dawn Schellenberg, wrote that another SPD staffer was “working on getting something on Twitter”—the only social media site SPD uses. Moments later, Smith corrected her, saying SPD would have no further updates until “after 9.”

Wilson’s own statement on the shooting went out at 8:46. It did not include information SPD was still withholding, including the critical information that the shooting appeared to be between groups of people who knew each other and that there was no need for he general public to be afraid.

At 9:26, Smith sent an update: Assistant Chief Tyrone Davis, who was filling in because Barnes and both his deputy chiefs were out of town, would be doing media interviews at 10pm; SPD would put up a Blotter post “right afterwards.” Ultimately, the press conference was delayed until almost 11pm, with both Congresswoman Pramila Jayapal and Governor Bob Ferguson, who had driven into town from Olympia, in attendance.

None of the messages include an order from the mayor’s office to withhold information from the public so that “dignitaries” could arrive at Seattle Center, as one of SPD’s communications staff told TV reporters who have repeatedly suggested that this was the reason SPD did not release information to the public all night.

While SPD was withholding information and failing to communicate with the press, a chaotic debate was going on within the mayor’s office about whether she should go to the scene of the shooting. The discussion began shortly before 6:30, when Wilson said she was available “as needed” and her interim communications director, Dawn Schellenberg, said Spangenthal-Lee had said she should go to Seattle Center. The mayor’s public safety advisor, Alison Holcomb, advised against this “until we know more.”

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

At 7:26, Wilson texted, “It would be good to get clarity soon whether we’re planning a public conference tonight v. tomorrow morning, so we can communicate that to other elected officials. (Just talked with Ferguson and Jayapal. Ferguson is in Olympia but can head this way shortly.)”

Holcomb replied, saying to wait until after a conference call for elected officials that was being organized by SPD. That conference call didn’t take place until around 9pm, possibly because Barnes wanted to get briefed on the situation from Dallas before participating in a call with elected officials. (A release of similar internal Teams chats and text messages from SPD would shed light on what Barnes and other SPD officials were doing between approximately 7:30 and 9:45.)

By around 9:40, it was still unclear whether the mayor would go to Seattle Center. At almost 9:30pm, Spangenthal-Lee wrote, “I reaaaaaaally think the mayor should go down there,” but Holcomb disagreed, writing, “Harborview, where victim’s families are, makes more sense, and I’m not sure that makes sense.”

“Media aren’t looking for an in-depth conversation about gang violence, they’re. looking for sound bites,” Holcomb continued. “Good time for the Mayor to be letting first responders do their jobs and not be armchair quarterbacking.”

Around the. same time, Deputy Mayor Brian Surratt, who had been on the scene for two hours, told Wilson, “I just talked to [Assistant Police Chief] Davis. His recommendation is no.” In other words, shortly before 9:40, SPD was still saying the mayor should not come to Seattle Center.

But after KOMO reporter Chris Daniels called the mayor, and another KOMO reporter said on air that they would expect the mayor to be there if she was in town, Wilson wrote, “We should consider whether I should come down to talk to KOMO, if that expectation has been created. I’m sure they would love to spin an ‘absent mayor’ story.” (Daniels has been among the mayor’s harshest critics, and a chief ringleader of the narrative that the mayor was solely to blame for the lack of information about the shooting.) “I’m inclined to have you come down,” Surratt responded. 

Wilson was on the scene less than a half hour after that text, shortly after 10pm. The press conference happened shortly before 11.There was a brief delay for Ferguson and Jayapal to arrive from other parts of Seattle, but it was, at most, around 30 minutes—at the end of a long night in which SPD had still put out no information beyond its initial, alarming post on X saying that multiple people had been shot.

SPD’s first post on the evening’s events went up early the following morning, at 1:08 am.

Wilson and interim Police Chief Andre Sayles announced some changes to how police and the mayor’s office will communicate with each other and with the public earlier this week. The city’s Office of the Inspector General is supposed to release a report about the communications breakdown sometime this fall.

Editor’s note: This story originally reported that Chris Daniels was on the scene at Seattle Center; he was not. We regret the error.

Mayor Wilson Says City Will Improve Crisis Communications In Wake of Shooting

Mayor Katie Wilson, with interim police chief Andre Sayles on the left

Wilson rolled out the changes before a report that is supposed to explain how communications broke down after the Bite of Seattle shooting.

By Erica C. Barnett

Mayor Katie Wilson and the Seattle Police Department rolled out a new communications plan for emergencies this week that includes a few updates to the old communications plan, which broke down in still-unspecified ways during a shooting at the Bite of Seattle festival in July that left three people dead. SPD arrested a 15-year-old on the night of the shooting, but still has not found “persons of interest” who may have also been involved.

Former SPD chief Shon Barnes and both of his deputy chiefs were out of town during the shooting. Barnes’ absence was one of several factors that may have contributed to a five-hour delay before SPD and Wilson held a press conference the night of the shooting. Barnes resigned under pressure—walking away with a severance package worth at least $740,000—after his over-the-top reaction to a reporter who asked about his frequent absences turned into a national story.

The new rules, which Wilson announced earlier this week, would include clearer lines of communication between SPD and the mayor’s staff, which appear to have broken down during the chaos after the shooting. A new SPD policy, which the department says is still being drafted, would allow no more than three members of SPD’s “executive staff” to be out of town at the same time; it’s unclear if this will include all command staff or just the chief and his deputies and assistants.

In the future, Alert Seattle, an opt-in system that pings people’s phones during emergencies, will alert residents when any “significant incident” happens, although the parameters that term will include are still undefined. During major incidents like active shooter events, the city may use the system to push wireless alerts to every cell phone within a certain radius—warning them to leave the area, for instance. And there will now be an “expectation of providing information to the media within one hour of a significant incident, when it’s safe and possible to do so,” according to the announcement.

Wilson has deflected questions about what caused the five-hour delay, saying that information will be revealed in a review by the Office of Inspector General, which her office requested, later this fall.

In an interview, Wilson said she decided to announce new communications policies prior to the publication of the OIG review “because it’s very important that the public has confidence that we’re prepared for Bumbershoot this weekend and all the big events coming up. … What this is about is saying there were gaps. We did not measure up to the standard that we have set for ourselves in terms of communications with the public. And we are fixing that moving forward.”

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

Wilson’s communications office has seen significant turnover throughout her eight-month administration, including the firing of a multimedia specialist last week. Currently, Wilson has a temporary press secretary and temporary communications director, along with multiple consultants working on communications.

Asked whether the lack of a permanent comms team was a factor in the communications issues that arose after the shooting, Wilson said, “No, I don’t think so. We have excellent interim leadership in our comms department. And I’m not just saying that because my interim comms director,” Dawn Schellenberg, “is sitting here,” she joked.

It’s unclear how much the changes will impact how quickly the public receives direct information about major incidents, and how often.  The new rules say Alert Seattle subscribers will get push notices about “significant incidents,” an SPD term of art that includes everything from robberies to reports of shots fired to assaults to “any other event a sergeant believes is significant.” Notifying the public every time one of these incidents occurs could contribute to fear—or apathy. Wilson said her office would get back to me on the new threshold for alerts. “We’re not going to spam people,” she said.

Wilson said her office will also direct people to X, SPD’s platform of choice for putting out timely information, “when appropriate,” and confirmed that her office hasn’t asked SPD to put out information on additional platforms, such as Instagram, Reddit, and Bluesky. Most people in Seattle are not on X, the controversial, Elon Musk-owned platform that has become a haven for right-wing disinformation and hate speech.

Most of the mainstream media in Seattle have focused their coverage of the communications breakdown on Wilson’s responsibility, almost to the exclusion of SPD—the organization that actually conducts media briefings after shootings and other major events.

Asked about the media’s singular focus on her role, Wilson said, “I’m not going to sit here and complain about the media.”

“What’s unfortunate,” Wilson continued, “is that so much of the media narrative has focused on communications, in a way that has gotten away from gun violence and the victims and really just what we can do moving forward as a city to make sure our public spaces are safe.”

While the mayor has declined to comment on SPD’s role in the communications breakdown or discuss how much the former chief’s absence from the city contributed to the information bottleneck, Barnes has been making the media rounds to give his own version of events.

Earlier this week, for instance, he told KOMO’s Chris Daniels that his absence from the city during the shooting wasn’t an issue, because he had access to Teams and a copy of the Active Shooter Incident Management Checklist on his phone. (As I reported, Barnes had planned to be out of the city until mid-August.)  “What I did, virtually, if you will, is what I would have done if I was here on the ground here in in Seattle,” Barnes told Daniels.

Police Accountability Office Investigating Retaliation Complaint Against Interim Police Chief

The investigation comes after the Office of Police Accountability said any “further investigation” of Sayles’ complaint against a detective who spoke at a pro-LGBTQ press conference could violate her constitutional rights and open the city to a lawsuit. 

By Erica C. Barnett

The city’s Office of Police Accountability is investigating a complaint filed against interim Police Chief Andre Sayles alleging that he retaliated against a detective who spoke at a pro-LGBTQ rally with SPD’s permission last year. The complaint, filed last month, also accuses Sayles of violating SPD’s policy on professionalism.

As PublCola reported exclusively last week, Sayles filed a potentially career-ending OPA complaint against longtime SPD detective Beth Wareing after she spoke at a press conference held by No Hate in WA State. The group is opposing two initiatives that would take away students’ ability to speak in confidence to school counselors and require girls to submit to genital exams to prove they have vaginas before participating in school sports.

Wareing had written permission to speak at the rally as long as she didn’t mention she worked at SPD or purport to represent the views of the department, and she followed those guidelines in her remarks, which lasted roughly three minutes and were available online shortly after the rally.

It’s not uncommon for police to speak publicly on political issues; former police guild president Mike Solan spouted off every week on his incendiary podcast. What is unusual is for police to express left-leaning views. Wareing’s comments got the attention of right-wing podcaster Brandi Kruse, who promptly told SPD Wareing had misrepresented the initiatives when she spoke. At least partly on the basis of Kruse’s claims, Sayles filed his complaint against Wareing, accusing her of disobeying a direct order and being “dishonest in saying inaccurate and untrue things at the press conference.”

OPA, which is housed in the police department, quickly dismissed the complaint, noting that any further investigation would clearly violate Wareing’s right to free speech and open SPD up to a lawsuit. The complaint against Sayles was opened after the investigation into Wareing concluded.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

According to a notice that went to select city officials, including the mayor, city attorney, and Councilmembers Joy Hollingsworth and Bob Kettle last week, the complaint against Sayles “alleges potential violations of department policy relating to retaliation and professionalism by the Interim Chief of Police.”

Since 2022, when the city codified the first formal process for complaints against the police chief, city law has treated complaints against the chief of police differently than complaints against all other officers. Anyone, including OPA itself, can file a complaint against the chief. Once that happens,  OPA decides whether to consider the case and whether to dismiss it as a “contact log” or conduct a full investigation into whether the chief has violated an SPD policy or a law.

Police chief investigations are rare. At the end of 2025, for example, the Office of Inspector General, an independent police accountability office that certifies OPA cases as timely, thorough, and objective, reported two open police chief investigations and 29 cases that were closed without an investigation.

OPA would not comment on the complaint against Sayles, other than to confirm that it exists. But the existence of an investigation itself indicates that the city’s police accountability system is taking the complaint against Sayles seriously. OPA’s findings (and recommended discipline, if any), along with OIG’s review of those findings, will include the agency’s assessment of whether Sayles violated Wareing’s First Amendment rights or retaliated against her for exercising them.

SPD Officer Alleges Retaliation by Lieutenant at Center of Discrimination Lawsuit

SPD West Precinct

By Erica C. Barnett

Valerie Carson, one of four female police officers who split a $2.6 million settlement in a lawsuit alleging sexual harassment and discrimination by former SPD chief Adrian Diaz, former assistant chief Dan Nelson, and current Lieutenant John O’Neil, has filed a new complaint against O’Neil with the city’s Office of Police Accountability.

PubliCola covered a previous retaliation complaint Carson filed against O’Neil, who accused her of refusing to follow orders after she declined to do a TV interview and went on mental-health leave. In an interview for his complaint, O’Neil said Carson was “combative,” “angry,” and “hostile,” and claimed that her only “mental health condition” was being too emotional about a recent breakup.

Carson’s new complaint accuses O’Neil of making unprofessional, dishonest, and retaliatory comments about Carson and her co-litigants, Lauren Truscott, Kame Spencer, and Jean Gulpan during a recent staff meet-and-greet event.

Carson worked for O’Neil when he was a sergeant heading up SPD’s communications office. He has since moved on and up, and is now a lieutenant overseeing SPD’s traffic investigation unit, crime scene investigations, and SPD’s evidence unit—high-profile positions that coincided with a pay increase of nearly $50,000 between 2025 and 2026.

O’Neil filed a counter-claim against the four female officers, who included two women of color, accusing them of being racist and retaliating against him; he ended up with a settlement of $200,000.

In her complaint, Carson says that during a getting-to-know-you meeting with his new staff in June, O’Neil badmouthed all four of his accusers—Carson, Lauren Truscott, Kame Spencer, and Jean Gulpan—and told his staff that “he is the most innocent man that has ever been investigated and that his accusers … are liars.” Carson’s allegations were based on accounts from two officers who were at the event.

By making derogatory statements about the four women, Carson wrote,  O’Neil was “telling our peers we can’t be trusted”—and that as a high-ranking official at SPD, he was doing so on SPD’s behalf. Spencer, Carson, and Gulpan remain at SPD, while Truscott left.

“This was not a situation in which he was free to express his own personal opinions —he was speaking as a representative of the department and as a supervisor and manager of our peers,” Carson wrote. “These are people we work with at events and crime scenes, people we coordinate with for casework, and in my case, people I see in my building. His words foment a hostile work environment.”

“Plus, in slandering us and delegitimizing the accountability and legal processes we went through, O’Neil’s actions would dissuade a reasonable employee from raising their own concerns about possible violations,” Carson wrote.

A spokesperson for SPD declined to respond to our questions, saying they were a matter for OPA to address. O’Neil did not respond to a request for comment, and Carson declined to speak to PubliCola on the record.