Category: Mayor Wilson

Yes to Jimothy, No to Bespoke Ballard Bus Service, and More News from a Nearly 12-Hour Budget Meeting

By Erica C. Barnett

The Seattle City Council, meeting as the budget committee, got through the most contentious part of the annual city budget—council amendments—on Monday, in a nearly 12-hour-long meeting that tested the council’s ability to put a polite face on some of its fundamental disagreements about how the city should spend its money.

The budget committee chair, Dan Strauss, could have broken up the meeting into two days, but declined to do so, noting at the beginning of the meeting that this would require the council to come back and meet again to vote the budget through as late as the Tuesday before Thanksgiving—the council’s longstanding practice prior to Strauss’ ascension to budget chair in 2024.

Under the schedule that has existed since 2024, the mayor proposes the budget on the fourth Tuesday in September (that part is unchanged) and the council passes a final budget two days before Thanksgiving, a schedule that reduces the time the council has to meet, deliberate, and make fixes in public by several days. This year, Strauss had planned to adopt every budget amendment, the most time-consuming and contentious part of the process, last Friday, almost two weeks before Thanksgiving.

I’ll cover some of these changes in an upcoming post after the budget passes, but for now, just know that the council approved most of its own new spending proposals from a $235,000-a-year “art wall” to $150,000 for Christmas decorations in Ballard that will include a statue of Jimothy, the meme raccoon, that’s supposed to last for the next 20 years. The council also preserved their own $1 million district transportation funds, which allow them to bypass city planning processes to fund projects they choose themselves, and directed the city to study a “sobering center” that would be redundant with the King County sobering center, currently located right across from City Hall and visible out the windows that face the council dais.

They agreed, though not unanimously, to pile on tens of millions of dollars in new, largely unsustainable spending, using purportedly one-time funds to fund new programs that will need more money again in one or two years. And they didn’t hesitate to earmark funds in order to bypass ordinary city processes—as with an amendment, from budget chair Dan Strauss, repurposing city funds to prevent pass-through traffic at a single intersection in Greenlake.

So it was unusual, and surprising, when one such earmark failed to pass: Dan Strauss’ proposal to direct funding from the just-passed Seattle Transit Measure toward far western Ballard, where Strauss lives, by either expanding service on King County Metro’s Route 17 Express or by bringing back the old Route 15 Express. Neither of these routes would be high-priority using the city’s equity- and demand-based prioritization matrix. Strauss has continually insisted that there is “no direct service” from downtown Seattle to Ballard, which isn’t true; however, direct service to the western edge of Ballard is limited after 6pm, inconveniencing people who live in this mostly single-family enclave.

On Monday, Strauss told his colleagues that if they supported more density in the Ballard Regional Center, they should support his amendment to expand transit service to western Ballard. “I wouldn’t bring this amendment if it wasn’t a regional growth center,” he said, adding, “I’m just looking for direct service between downtown Seattle and downtown Ballard. It should not take the amount of time as it takes to get to Tacoma.”

This claim is also incorrect; traveling from Seattle’s central business district to “downtown” Ballard (I mapped a route to the Tractor Tavern) takes about 35 minutes by bus, about 20 minutes less than getting from downtown to Tacoma on a Sound Transit Express bus. Getting to the neighborhood served by the 17 Express, which is many blocks to the northwest of central Ballard, does take longer, but most bus riders aren’t trying to get there—which is one reason Metro has ranked bus routes as higher priorities. Strauss’ amendment, which he sponsored by himself and originally tucked into a “chair’s package” of items he wanted to pass without debate, lost 6-3.

 

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

The council also rejected, on a 5-4 vote, a proposal from Dionne Foster that would require the council to produce a budget that’s balanced in all four years of its financial plan, not just the two-year budget. Strauss argued that because he had produced a proposal that is (or at least appears) balanced through 2030, there’s no need to impose any new requirements on the council.

Under a ballot measure the council passed (and voters approved) last year, the mayor has to balance her budget for four years, but the council does not. (The measure imposed this requirement on the mayor for one year, but an amendment from Foster, which the council adopted right before rejecting Foster’s companion proposal, makes that mandate permanent). Editor’s note: This post originally said the first amendment was from Kettle. Kettle sponsored the original one-year requirement but Foster sponsored the amendment to make it permanent yesterday.

“I believe it makes sense to hold ourselves to the same standard and to ensure that we are practicing the same kind of fiscal responsibility and sustainability that we are requiring from the executive,” Foster said before the vote.

Prior to this year, with Strauss as budget chair the council has passed budgets with nine-figure deficits beginning immediately after the two-year budget cycle, after piling on tens of millions of dollars to the “out-year” deficits established in the mayor’s budget.

Despite approving huge deficits as recently as last year, Strauss sounded affronted a the idea that he would ever do such a thing  “What I would say is, I don’t need a law to do what’s right in this situation,” Strauss said. “I don’t need a law to tell me, or an executive order to tell me, how to do my job well. What I know is that we need to have these budgets balanced four years out. I think it’s a good idea.”

Opponents of Foster’s proposal argued it would put the council at a disadvantage, since the mayor has more time to create a budget and does so, as Strauss put it, “behind closed doors.”

Foster pointed out that the budget package Strauss proposed assumes $41 million in “one-time” expenses that are actually ongoing, which would result in an immediate deficit of around $58 million in 2029, right over the budget horizon. Put another way, if the council was not pretending that their proposals for ongoing spending will only be in place for one or two years, the budget would not be balanced for all four years. Budget tricks, once again, are creating an appearance of balance where there really is none. Mayor Wilson, through her budget office director Aly Pennucci, has said she’ll assume in her next budget that any one-time funds are truly one-time by Xing them out in future budgets, setting up a similar fight in the future.

The council also rejected a Foster proposal that would have used any funds the city manages to recover from overpayments that went to police officers this year to fund affordable housing. As we reported, police officers collectively received more than $13 million in lump-sum overpayments in June due to a miscalculation in how much officers were owed in retroactive pay. The police union has suggested they won’t repay the money until the city deals with separate payment issues related to the Workday payroll system.

Strauss amended Foster’s proposal to put oversight of the legislation into his own committee, finance and budget, instead of the housing committee, which Foster chairs. He also claimed he had no idea about the amendment and “learned about it on the dais,” which Foster quickly corrected: She submitted the amendment by the same deadline that every other amendment met. In fact, the budget committee discussed it in October. Then—after getting his way—Strauss voted to abstain, which has the same effect as voting no, so the bill failed in committee. It will come back again in full council, where councilmembers are not allowed to abstain from votes.

The police overpayment money, if and when it’s recovered, will go into the general fund instead, unless someone switches their vote in full council.

 

 

This Week on PubliCola: Lawsuit Throws Wrench in Budget, RV Ban Fails, Police Surveillance Expands, and More

Seattle City Councilmember Maritza Rivera urged the council not to rush through the budget last week.

By Erica C. Barnett

First of all, please check out my breaking-news story, published on Saturday and updated on Sunday, about a lawsuit that could derail the city’s budget. In short, the budget proposal would use a pension fund that pays retirement benefits for some former firefighters and their widows to help pay for new general-fund spending, and the pension fund isn’t having it. Mayor Katie Wilson proposed using $10 million from the fund, but the issue didn’t catch fire until City Council budget chair Dan Strauss proposed grabbing another $22 million by reducing the amount the city puts into the fund each year. Strauss included this amendment in a “consent package,” announced on November 5, that he planned to pass as a whole with no further discussion.

On to the rest of this week’s news!

Monday, November 9

KCRHA CEO’s Departure Leaves Right-Hand Man in Charge

The abrupt resignation of the King County Regional Homelessness Authority’s CEO, Kelly Kinnison, last week left a leadership vacuum that will be filled, at least temporarily, by the deputy whose hiring caused significant controversy: William Towey. Kinnison’s departure appeared to be a foregone conclusion—the board had planned an executive session to discuss her job performance, but canceled it after she stepped down.

City Budget Leader Warns Council About Profligate Spending

Seattle Budget Director Aly Pennucci wrote a letter to the City Council criticizing their plan to pile tens of millions in new spending—including ongoing projects that the council plans to pay for with “one-time” funds—on to the mayor’s proposed budget. “[I]tems labeled as ‘one-time’ in the budget for 2027, 2028, or both, will be removed from the 2028 and/or 2029 baseline budget,” she warned.

Long-Awaited Report Recommends Limits on Real Time Crime Center, Including Warrants for Investigators to Search Surveillance Footage

A long-awaited audit of the city’s Real Time Crime Center, which incorporates all the city’s police surveillance cameras along with private cameras from businesses and residents who opt in, made 19 recommendations to help address “shortcomings” in the program, but noted that there is no way to absolutely ensure that bad actors, like ICE and law enforcement from other states, can access the police department’s camera footage.

Tuesday, November 10

Greater Seattle: Two Notes on the Election, One National and One Local

In this week’s column, Josh warns against getting too worked up about Trump’s predictable reactionary moves—like appointing Stephen Miller chief of staff—in the wake of an extraordinary election night. On the state front, he says, progressive wins may come with bad news for the pro-housing agenda in Olympia.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

Wilson Says Expanding Police Surveillance System Will Help Make Seattle “The Safest Big City in the Country”

No sooner did the city release the NYU report than Mayor Katie Wilson announced that she’ll turn surveillance cameras back on in the stadium district and install new cameras in the Central District and on Capitol Hill. Wilson said she was convinced that the cameras help police solve and respond to crimes and that the footage can be protected from immigration enforcement and others who might use it for nefarious purposes. Wilson also announced the city was adopting many of the NYU report’s recommendations—but SPD, which has failed to implement recommendations related to cameras from 2024, does not have a great track record on following through with voluntary self-policing.

Wednesday, November 11

After Telling Councilmembers To Avoid “Getting into the Depth of Topics,” Strauss Plans to Rush Entire Budget Through on Friday

Strauss, who has run this year’s budget process a bit like a cheerful, aw-shucks dictator, announced this week that he planned to push the entire budget through on Friday, directing councilmembers to hold any discussion of his “consent package”—on which, spoiler alert, it turns out there was much dissent—until that day. Had this plan gone through, it would have meant the council would hold its only real discussion on the consent package and the complete, final budget and vote it out in a single day—leaving little room for debate or changes before the budget passed.

Thursday, November 12

City Council Fails to Override Mayor’s Veto of Proposed RV Ban

In what became a foregone conclusion with Rob Saka’s defection last week, the council failed to override Wilson’s veto of legislation, sponsored by Dan Strauss, that would have banned RVs from parking overnight in Seattle, with a 5-4 vote that fell just short of the six-vote supermajority needed to override a mayoral veto. The supporters of the ban spent most of the meeting giving speeches that denounced the mayor.

Also this week: I live-posted from the Seattle City Council’s budget meetings on Bluesky, which is where you’ll find me tomorrow (Monday, November 16), posting updates from City Hall as the council wrestles with the fallout from the fire pension fund lawsuit and debates the many contentious budget amendments they didn’t get around to on Friday.

I was on City Cast Seattle, discussing the city’s apparent embrace of indiscriminate surveillance and ranking the City Council by how much beef they have with Mayor Wilson (my #1 won’t surprise anyone who’s been reading PubliCola) with host Liam Billingsly and The Needling’s Lex Vaughan.

I was also a guest on KUOW’s Week In Review this week, where host Bill Radke, former state AG Rob McKenna and musician/prolific podcaster John Roderick and I discussed the week’s news, including the initiative banning trans girls from playing on girls’ teams in school, surveillance cameras, the closure of a once-a-year medical and dental clinic for indigent people, and more.

And finally, on Seattle Nice this week, David, Sandeep, and I discussed the election results in Mississippi (my original home state), the NYU audit, and the city council’s profligate spending this budget cycle.

City Council Fails to Override Mayor’s Veto of Proposed RV Ban

City Councilmember Rob Saka, speaking about his decision to vote against the veto last week.

By Erica C. Barnett

In what became a foregone conclusion with Rob Saka’s defection last week, the Seattle City Council failed to override Mayor Katie Wilson’s veto of legislation, sponsored by Dan Strauss, that would have banned RVs from parking overnight in Seattle, with a 5-4 vote that fell just short of the six-vote supermajority needed to override a mayoral veto.

Under rhe legislation Wilson vetoed, the city would have done a one-time-only count of people living in RVs in Seattle and offered some of their residents—those who could prove they owned their vehicles, had up-to-date registration, and whose vehicles were in relatively good repair—a short-term “license” allowing them to continue parking in industrial areas overnight, as they’re currently allowed to do for up to 72 hours.

Anyone who failed to meet those criteria would either have to leave the city or risk having their vehicle impounded, and anyone who wasn’t counted in the one-time “census” would also be prohibited from parking an RV in Seattle. Those who made the cut would get short-term permits on the condition that they participate in services and go to shelter. The bill did not fund any additional shelter or services, but it did refer to funding for an RV safe lot in this year’s budget.

Saka, who joined a 6-vote majority in voting for the legislation last month, said he changed his mind after Wilson issued her own executive order directing city departments to create a plan to better serve people living in RVs and help them transition to housing while also ensuring that people engaging in illegal activities in RVs are held accountable.

“Voting to support legislation and deciding whether to override a veto are two separate decisions,” Saka said. “My principles and values haven’t changed. What’s changed is that we now have a new path to consider. Through her executive order, Mayor Wilson has committed to expanding outreach, advancing RV safe lots and developing an alternative approach. I believe that deserves a fair opportunity.”

Before the votes, several dozen people spoke against Strauss’ proposal. Chanel Horner, who lived in her bus until the city towed it away, was one of them. She said she attends meetings of the KCRHA’s Vehicle Residency Workgroup and volunteers with Stop the Sweeps “to help tow people out of harm’s way.”

“I bring direct lived experience,” Horner said, “Rushing into this without grassroots input is a mistake, especially when the safe lot—an RV lot and tiny house village at Glassyard Commons in West Seattle—is scheduled to open this very month. Waiting to see how that operates first makes far more sense.” Other advocates, including the Seattle-King County Coalition on Homelessness and representatives from SHARE and WHEEL, which run shelters and sanctioned encampments, also crammed their testimony into the 60 seconds they had to speak before having their mics or phone connections cut.

Strauss, who sent out a last-minute “action alert” to get constituents to come out and rally around his proposal, gave a 12-minute speech that hit many familiar notes about his legislation. (Despite Strauss’ efforts, public comment before the vote was overwhelmingly against the ban). Strauss said his bill was “human-centered,” and would “help stabilize and support people living in their vehicles by giving them more certainty about where they can and cannot park, and that they will not be pushed around, that they have more agency, that they are connected with service providers, and that they have a pathway into shelter or housing.”

Both Strauss and Councilmember Debora Juarez, who will be replaced by Nilu Jenks later this month, blamed critics of the legislation for opposing it without, according to them, offering suggestions to help. Strauss wondered out loud where all “the service providers, and these are folks who have given chewed my ear off just this week,” were during this morning’s vote. 

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

Juarez addressed public commenters directly, saying they had falsely accused the council of sitting around and saying “‘let’s figure out the worst way to criminalize the homeless and impose draconian bans and punish people.’ No, that’s not the hard work we do here. I know that when people show up and scream at us at city council, they think that. That’s absolutely not true,” Juarez said. “Nobody’s pitting anyone against anyone. Nobody’s criminalizing anyone with their thoughts or their policies.”

Juarez, who changed her mind and sought an appointment to the council after quitting last year, has called Wilson a liar for initially saying she would not veto the bill, then changing her mind. This morning, she accused Wilson of  “dishonesty, inconsistency, [and] lack of leadership.”

Council President Joy Hollingsworth, who also voted for Strauss’ legislation (and to override Wilson’s veto) expressed frustration that the homelessness crisis has continued despite hundreds of millions of dollars a year in spending to address it. “I was at the grocery store the other day and there was a woman with a baby standing outside with her children, asking for a couple dollars, asking to be seen, asking to be helped,” she said. “And I think about the hundreds of millions of dollars that we invest in this city. And I ask myself, why isn’t that investment reaching her? And why is it when I raise that question, why am I then targeted as bad?”

One of the three councilmembers who voted against Strauss’ legislation initially, Dionne Foster, cited the persistence of the homelessness crisis as one of the key reasons she opposed the licensing scheme in the first place. “We know that homelessness is not a static experience, that people’s circumstances change,” she said. “People move in and out of homelessness.” A one-time count, followed by a slamming door, does not respond to this reality, Foster said. “As we continue to try to bring more shelter online, bring more housing online, we are still seeing people become newly homeless. … And from my perspective, having a one-time census and a permit that corresponds with that one time census is not an effective way to address what is an ongoing challenge.”

Wilson Says Expanding Police Surveillance System Will Help Make Seattle “The Safest Big City in the Country”

By Erica C. Barnett

Mayor Katie Wilson announced she’ll proceed with an expansion of police surveillance in the Central District, Capitol Hill, and SoDo (where cameras are already installed), subject to a handful of new requirements that were outlined in the NYU Policing Project’s civil-rights audit, released yesterday. The decision, Wilson said, was part of “making Seattle the safest big city in the country—safe from gun violence and serious crime, and safe from authoritarianism from the federal government.” The expansion was proposed by former mayor Bruce Harrell but put on “pause” shortly after Wilson took office. 

Like Harrell, Wilson framed her defense of mass surveillance in terms of community safety and justice. “Our city has too many grieving families, too many communities who rightfully expect crimes to be solved, but are losing hope of their day in court,” Wilson said. “Justice means protecting from harm and preventing it. It means delivering accountability afterward. My decision today strikes that balance.”

At a press conference with the mayor on Tuesday, interim police chief Andre Sayles said the cameras were a big part of the reason there were no homicides in June and that the World Cup was safe; Wilson turned on the cameras near the stadiums during the monthlong event, citing an unspecified “credible threat.”

But the Policing Project audit found that there was “thin” evidence that indiscriminate surveillance—their term for surveillance that applies to everyone in a public place, rather than people suspected of a crime—helps police solve or prevent crime. About 300 communities currently have Real Time Crime Centers like Seattle’s, which layer CCTV surveillance feeds with other data and live communications in an attempt to respond to crimes more quickly and solve them after the fact. The audit also found that while Seattle police often claim the RTCC was instrumental to solving a crime, the reality is that SPD counts any interaction with the system, such as an officer calling up a single camera, as a successful intervention.

The statistics SPD provided “reflect that in 2025, the RTCC  assisted in 17 homicide cases, with its support helping to close 10 of these cases. In SPD’s data analysis, however, it defines RTCC “support’as a case in which an RTCC analyst takes any action (such as checking a camera), regardless of whether that action yielded any useful information or meaningfully impacted the investigation,” the report found.

Asked about this at a press conference on Tuesday, Wilson seemed confident that the cameras help police address crime, despite the lack of a “controlled experiment” proving that they do. She was especially compelled, she said, by arguments that police are short-staffed and need all the help they can get, including from camera footage and the ability to view crime scenes in real time and after the fact.

“I do believe, from my conversations with our RTCC staff and officers, that the cameras are helpful both in investigations and in real time incidents,” Wilson said. “And you can argue about how helpful. But I think [the cameras are] an efficient, effective use of our resources.”

Many opponents of police surveillance have expressed concerns that camera footage could be obtained by ICE or outside law enforcement agencies to track down immigrants or target people seeking abortions or gender-affirming care.

In a statement, the privacy advocates at Community Not Cameras, said, “Mayor Wilson’s campaign platform acknowledged that ‘Seattle can’t be a true sanctuary city if ICE can access data about you.’ Yet the audit makes clear that the City’s policies cannot eliminate that possibility.”

The report itself pointed this risk out explicitly, noting that all that’s required to obtain footage is a subpoena or simple records request (which can be anonymous, and don’t require a requester to state the reason for their request). Wilson, however, said she would “not allow the data that the city collects to be used to harm immigrants, LGBTQ plus people, or others who may be targeted by federal agencies or other bad actors.”

“None of the 19 recommendations [in the audit] puts the footage beyond federal reach,” Community Not Cameras’ statement continued. “A written policy does not stop a subpoena. The Mayor conceded as much today, saying ‘even if we implement all of these recommendations, some level of risk will remain.’”

Asked how she would accomplish this, Wilson noted that the report recommended limiting the amount of time camera footage is retained in a system owned by Axon, the company that provides Seattle’s camera system, when SPD proactively retains footage for investigations. Currently, that footage is stored indefinitely.

Wilson also noted that Seattle does not use Flock cameras, which are more widely used than Axon’s, adding that she believes Axon is a more “responsible” company. “Axon will continue to be a partner in designing a system for Seattle that meets our specific needs, fits our policies, and is consistent with our values,” Wilson said. In a video posted on X, Wilson emphasized the fact that there are “no Flock cameras in Seattle.”

“Flock, no. This is a different system managed by a different company,” Wilson said in the video.

But there’s really no difference between Flock and Axon. In an interview, NYU Policing Project’s director of  technology law and policy, Max Isaacs, said that while Flock and Axon have focused on different segments of the market, “it’s not like one is good and one is bad, or either one is better than the other. They’re both trying to do a similar thing, adopting similar business models” in an attempt to become “the Apples of surveillance tech.”

On Tuesday, Wilson acknowledged that “there’s no such thing as zero risk,” adding that Seattle (like Washington state) has directed police not  to cooperate with federal immigration enforcement efforts or help other states track down people who get health care here. “If the city gets a request from law enforcement that it can’t legally refuse, “we will shut down the camera system at least for 60 days,” she said.

Wilson’s announcement did not include the most ambitious recommendation from the NYU report, which said Seattle should require police to get a warrant before they go through footage “retrospectively” to track a person’s past movements. The report said this step was important to protect people from unlawful searches, and noted that it would only apply in the relatively rare circumstances when police want to track where someone went as part of an investigation, not in situations like a real-time response or to look at a crime scene remotely.

Wilson brushed a question (from the Urbanist) about why she didn’t include a warrant requirement in her announcement, saying Seattle police don’t use the RTCC to track people after the fact. An SPD spokesman confirmed that they have not used the cameras this way, largely because it would be a cumbersome process to track someone from camera to camera, given the current limits of the RTCC technology. However, the department does not have an explicit policy preventing them from using footage in this way, which was what the proposed warrant requirement was meant to address.

Among other commitments, Wilson sad SPD had agreed to complete and publish a dashboard on its usage of the RTCC and create an “omnibus surveillance policy,” two commitments the department made in 2024 and in 2025, respectively, but has not completed. Wilson also announced that SPD “will clarify and strengthen its policies and practices around permissible uses, access criteria and logs, data retention periods, requests from outside agencies, regular internal audits, and more.”

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

The city is also setting up an advisory group that will meet over the next few months to “develop additional policies around private camera integration, usage of the RTCC during large-scale events, protests and other First Amendment activity, and criteria guiding any future CCTV camera placements,” according to the announcement. Currently, 23 privately owned cameras at three locations feed directly into the Real Time Crime Center; individuals and business owners have voluntarily registered another 900 cameras at 159 locations, saying they will let SPD to use their private footage on request.

Meeting with the press immediately after Wilson’s announcement, City Council public safety committee chair Bob Kettle had measured praise for Wilson’s decision, which he said made obvious sense based on the conclusions of the study. (Previously, Kettle called Wilson’s decision to hold off on installing new cameras until the audit was complete “unconscionable.”

Kettle said he “disagree[d]” with the Policing Project’s finding that real time crime centers and surveillance do little to prevent or solve crime. In Seattle, he said, “Everybody thinks if you have 100 instances of crime, that you have 100 people doing it,” Kettle said. “That’s not the case. You may have 10 people doing 10 crimes, and then if that one person, if you’re catching them on crime two out of ten, then you’re preventing those next eight.”

Councilmember Eddie Lin said he was disappointed with the decision, and wished that the mayor had waited until the results of an additional audit by the city’s Office of Inspector General and the University of Pennsylvania come out early next year. That study will look into how the RTCC is used and whether Seattle’s surveillance system is effective at addressing crime.

“We were supposed to be getting these reports before we expanded further,” Lin said. “I think this recent report only reinforces the the need for us to have better protections and oversight in place,”

In a statement, the OIG said the NYU report and recommendations “reinforce and further inform issues that OIG identified in its first annual surveillance review; risk of improper data sharing with outside agencies, unclear criteria for expansion of RTCC technologies, and the need to enforce privacy protections on integrated cameras.”

 

Long-Awaited Report Recommends Limits on Real Time Crime Center, Including Warrants for Investigators to Search Surveillance Footage

 

By Erica C. Barnett

The NYU Policing Project released its long-awaited privacy and civil-liberties audit of the Seattle Police Department’s Real Time Crime Center on Monday, one day before Mayor Katie Wilson plans to announce whether she will expand the city’s use of the surveillance cameras that feed into the center. The RTCC incorporates hundreds of city-operated and private surveillance cameras into a system that allows officers to surveil much of the city in real time, pulling in data from other sources to direct police in the field or investigate crimes after the fact.

The report did not make recommendations about whether the city should expand the center. Instead, the auditors made 19 recommendations to help address “shortcomings” in the program, including the potential for footage to wind up in the hands of federal agents and the lack of formal written policies governing things like data retention and when police can use the RTCC. These recommendations ranged from changes that would be fairly easy to implement—like ending SPD’s policy of retaining some camera footage indefinitely—to bigger lifts, like requiring a warrant any time police want to review someone’s movements retrospectively, which the auditors said constitutes a type of search.

“We think that there is a solid foundation for governance of the RTCC in Seattle… but that there are also significant gaps in policy that the city and SPD can fill,”  NYU Policing Project chief of staff Katie Kinsey said on Monday. “If the RTCC is going to continue to operate, it should do so subject to implementing these additional policy recommendations.”

Earlier this year, Mayor Katie Wilson “paused” the installation of new cameras on Capitol Hill and in the Central District; the city did install and turn cameras on near the stadiums just south of downtown, but only during the World Cup. Critics on both sides have assailed the mayor for her approach to cameras. Law-and-order officials like Councilmember Bob Kettle have harrumphed that she’s putting public safety at risk, while privacy advocates like Community Not Cameras have said police surveillance puts Seattle residents and visitors at risk.

Seattle’s RTCC, which began operations in 2025, provides police with real-time and after-the-fact access to footage from a network of  more than 500 individual cameras, many of them housed in single-location “units” with three to five cameras each, operated by SPD, the Seattle Department of Transportation, and private business owners who’ve volunteered to make their footage accessible to SPD. About 900 more private cameras, at 159 locations, are owned by people who’ve volunteered to make their footage accessible on request.

SPD officers at the RTCC access all these camera feeds using an Axon system called Fusus, which allows officers to call up camera footage and pull in other information to respond to ongoing incidents, overlaying that footage with law-enforcement databases, object-detection software, and other tools to give the police department a far more comprehensive picture of what’s happening in view of the cameras than old-fashioned CCTV cameras alone.

“When you’re connecting a bunch of cameras, when you’re having analysts that are able to look into them, when you’re running AI over them, we’re talking about really a different kind of technology,” Kinsey said.

SPD is barred from using facial recognition. But it does use a system called “object identification” that is supposed to be able to identify a list of object types, including vehicles, purses, and clothing colors. In practice, this system often fails to identify objects and people properly. In one high-profile case last year, police swarmed a 16-year-old student and handcuffed him after his school’s camera surveillance system mistook the bag of Doritos he was holding for a gun. (Speaking to the auditors about problems with the object identification system, Seattle police described a more innocuous example, in which a test search for a person wearing gray pants and a gray shirt turned up footage of a pigeon).

Most of the RTCC’s work involves supporting officers responding to 911 calls,  the report found, but officers working at the RTCC also use the system to investigate crimes by tracking people’s movements, going back through footage to surveil suspects “retrospectively.” The report recommends requiring police to obtain a warrant any time they want to use camera footage to investigate a crime after the fact, allowing “warrantless tracking” of individuals only when officers are responding to a situation in real time, to “prevent physical harm to the officers or other persons, the destruction of relevant evidence, or the escape of the suspect.”

The Policing Project is aware that this will be the most controversial recommendation, and took pains to point out that it would only apply to investigations that take place after a crime is over and the scene is cleared.

“We are not recommending a warrant in what are called exigent circumstances—when there is a public safety hazard, there’s a shooter, there’s someone who  represents a threat to public safety. Nor are we saying that SPD is powerless to check the cameras at the crime scene to see who may have been there,” said Max Isaacs, the Policing Project’s director of  technology law and policy.

Of all the recommendations, he said, the warrant requirement was “a hard pill for [SPD] to swallow. But “it is not the case that [a warrant requirement] would impede investigations. If the investigation is warranted, then they can always go to a judge and get signoff.”

The report also notes that many of SPD’s existing policies, like a commitment from Axon that it will disable new surveillance features by default, are “informal” and not a part of SPD’s policy manual or law, meaning that they can be changed at any time.

In one unwritten policy, SPD says it retains surveillance footage no longer than five days unless it’s needed for an investigation—but because there’s no formal policy, the department could increase that period to as long as 30 days without  any policy change. This casual approach is at odds with the seriousness of “‘indiscriminate’ surveillance,” the report found, and recommended that SPD adopt five-day retention as a formal policy. “We think [the lack of a written retention policy] is a mistake, and it should be made a matter of binding policy,” Isaacs said.

The auditors also recommended getting rid of footage used as evidence once it’s no longer needed. The current policy of keeping that footage indefinitely makes it more likely that bad actors, such as ICE or outside law enforcement, can file a public records request or issue a subpoena for SPD footage. “We think that creates unnecessary risk, and SPD should change it,” Isaacs said.

Other policies are vague to the point of meaninglessness—like an official policy that says the RTCC can be used to assist with “serious and violent” crimes. In practice, the report found, “SPD currently interprets” this phrase to include “misdemeanors of all kinds.” When there are no clear guardrails around how a police department can use surveillance, Kinsey said, “there is this tendency to have mission creep. So a tool that starts to be deployed or procured for one reason ends up being used for lots of other reasons because you have it on hand.” 

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

The report recommends setting clear standards for when police can access the RTCC, and says that in any future “review of the RTCC’s authorization, the City Council should consider whether to further limit the circumstances in which the RTCC [can] be activated.”

Police surveillance is a relatively new project in Seattle, unlike other cities where Flock-branded cameras have become a ubiquitous, often controversial feature of everyday life. (SPD’s cameras are from a different company, Axon, which also manufactures Tasers.) Proponents argue that the RTCC and its cameras deter crime and help solve crimes; in Seattle, they’ve been sold as solutions to sex trafficking, gun violence, drug sales, and more. But, as the NYU report notes, the evidence that they actually do any of these things is “thin.”

“SPD has published some data on RTCC impact, including that officers and detectives are three times more likely to arrest a suspect when they receive support from RTCC analysts.,” the report notes. “SPD statistics also reflect that in 2025, the RTCC assisted in 17 homicide cases, with its support helping to close 10 of these cases.”

“In SPD’s data analysis, however, it defines RTCC ‘support’ as a case in which an RTCC analyst takes any action (such as checking a camera), regardless of whether that action yielded any useful information or meaningfully impacted the investigation.” In other words, SPD is mixing up correlation and causation—they could just as easily claim that driving an SUV instead of a patrol car improved investigation outcomes, or that better in-car computers make it more likely that an officer will solve a crimde.

Wilson will make an announcement Tuesday morning about her plans for the RTCC. (On Monday, the mayor’s office declined to respond to written questions). For months, she’s been telegraphing that the report’s release is a final step before she announces plans to keep the RTCC and preserve or expand its surveillance footprint in Seattle. What’s unclear is which recommendations from the report she will try to put in place and whether she’ll make the RTCC’s ongoing existence and future expansion conditional on meeting them.

Speaking to PubliCola late Monday afternoon, Kinsey said she was “relatively optimistic about the adoption implementation of a lot of these recommendations, and for a few reasons. One is that we were asked to do this audit by the mayor’s office.  I think it always makes a really big difference when you’re doing something because leadership is actually asking you to do it, and not because some less empowered entity is asking you to do it.”

The other reason is that the Policing Project worked with stakeholders inside and outside the city for eight monts to come up with these recommendations. “Having a certain amount of buy-in, a certain amount of understanding through the process that these things are actually doable, helps me feel a little optimistic,” she said.

This is a developing story. We’ll have an update tomorrow after Wilson’s press conference, which will also feature interim police chief Andre Sayles.

KCRHA CEO’s Departure Leaves Right-Hand Man in Charge, City Budget Leader Warns Council About Profligate Spending, No Concession Yet in Lopsided Council Race

KCRHA CEO Kelly Kinnison reads her resignation letter on Friday.

1. King County Regional Homelessness Authority CEO Kelly Kinnison likely forestalled her own firing by resigning abruptly on Friday, November 6. In a brief, 153-word resignation letter, Kinnsion wrote that given the KCRHA governing board’s recent decision to “right size” the agency and move the administration of the region’s homelessness contracts back to Seattle and King County, “I believe it is in the best interest of the agency for me to make room for those changes.”

The KCRHA began to unravel earlier this year, when a forensic audit found that sloppy accounting and fiscal practices had resulted in the apparent disappearance of $13 million, which was not fully accounted for until late September. Last month, a followup report found that because of miscalculations that lasted for the duration of the agency, the KCRHA had overspent its budget by almost $17 million, which the city and King County (the KCRHA’s two primary funders) will now have to pay.

Kinnison’s announcement took place at the beginning of a KCHRA governing board meeting that was  scheduled to include a closed executive session, called under a subsection of the Open Public Meetings Act that allows closed meetings to review the performance of a public employee, a typical step before a governing body fires an executive. During the meeting itself, that item was apparently removed from the agenda and the board held a brief executive session to discuss litigation, but not the performance evaluation, which would have become unnecessary once Kinnison resigned on her own.

It’s unclear what litigation the board was discussing. Former KCRHA employee Xochitl Maykovitch filed a lawsuit against the agency in June, alleging that Kinnison had illegally withheld records related to an investigation into staff complaints against Kinnison. That investigation, by an outside lawyer, found that Kinnison retaliated against Maykovitch and the KCRHA’s general counsel, Edmund Witter.

In July, PubliCola reported that it appeared Kinnison did attempt to conceal her correspondence from public disclosure law, cutting off the public disclosure officer’s access to her emails and asking an IT staffer to label all her communications “deliberative” to categorically exempt them from records requests.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

The KCRHA’s governing board, made up of elected officials, had seemed stubbornly dedicated to keeping both Kinnison and her recently promoted chief operating officer, William Towey, on board. For more than a year, the board more or less ignored staff complaints about Kinnison (including allegations of racial bias) and demands that the board fire executive staff, including Towey and Kinnison, before getting rid of critical workers.

Board members were tepid about Kinnison’s tenure on Friday; only Mayor Katie Wilson and King County Executive Girmay Zahilay spoke. “We appreciate your work and also acknowledge the tremendously challenging job that you had with the federal landscape, with the structures in this entity, that are very challenging to navigate and the complexity of the homelessness crisis in general,” Zahilay said.

Ironically, it will be Towey, who Kinnison hired over widespread objections, who will now take over as effective leader of the agency until the board can appoint an acting CEO. Since last year, Towey has served as Kinnison’s right-hand man, speaking on the agency’s behalf at meetings from which she has been absent or at which she sat next to him in silence.

Kinnison has not signed a separation agreement, according to a KCRHA spokesperson, suggesting that she will not receive severance.

2. Seattle Budget Director Aly Pennucci, a former longtime City Council staffer, didn’t mince words in her assessment of the council’s plan to pile tens of millions in new spending—including ongoing projects that the council plans to pay for with “one-time” funds—on to Mayor Katie Wilson’s proposed budget. Had the budget “accurately reflected” many of thse “one-time” items “as ongoing investment,” Pennucci wrote in a letter to the council on Friday, the budget deficit in 2029 would be $41 million. Which—go math!—is what we reported as the council’s unsustainable long-term commitment last week.

“I heard clearly from many of you over the last two months that you consider ending one-time funding as a ‘budget cut,’” Penucci wrote. “So, I want to be clear with you, City employees, and community partners, that items labeled as “one-time” in the budget for 2027, 2028, or both, will be removed from the 2028 and/or 2029 baseline budget. That is your direction to CBO when you adopt spending as one-time.”

“In addition, given the continued economic uncertainty, and the use of fund balances and reserves, we will need to proceed very carefully with authorizing some of this new spending in 2027 so councilmembers should expect that some of the proposals may be frozen, at least until we see the April revenue forecast.” (Emphasis in original).

Pennucci also expressed concern about council budget committee chair Dan Strauss’ decision to dip into financial reserves meant to shore up the JumpStart tax in case of an unexpected revenue shortfall, bringing it below the level required by law. The JumpStart payroll expense tax falls most heavily on a small number of huge companies with highly compensated workers, so it’s inherently volatile, which is why the council previously established a reserve amounting to no less than 10 percent of projected tax revenues.

Finally, Pennucci cautioned against all the “earmarks” in the budget—spending that the budget says will go to an organization “such as” a specific, named group—warning that the council may want funds to go to their preferred organization, but the city is still required to follow state and federal contracting law. This is a perennial losing battle—the mayor and council often specify which groups they want to receive city funding in the budget, using weasel words to avoid explicit earmarks. This year, however, Wilson’s budget included almost no earmarks; the exceptions included adds for Throne and Portland Loo-style public restrooms.

The council’s budget amendments would add at least 21 new earmarks to the budget, including seven for neighborhood associations and business groups in West Seattle, Magnolia, the University District, and SoDo as well as the Seattle Sports Commission, Red Barn Ranch, Lakeside Milam treatment center, and many others.

“If a contracting process results in an award to Council’s desired recipient, the ‘such as’ language can call into question the validity of the process,” Pennucci wrote. “If the contract is awarded to an entity other than Council’s preference, the language results in a disgruntled organization that expected to receive the contract

3. District 5 City Council candidate Julie Kang has still not conceded to her winning opponent, Nilu Jenks, who was leading Kang 59 to 41 on Friday. Concessions, while not legally required, are customary once it’s clear who has won an election. On Friday, Kang posted on Facebook and Instagram that she was still waiting for King County Elections “to finalize the results.” By next year’s election (when Jenks will have to run again for a full four-year term) Kang wrote, she hopes “we will see a safer Aurora, better access to essential services in Lake City, and measurable progress on the commitments made to #seattle residents.”

In an interview with PubliCola in October, Kang said that whether she won or lost, she would run for the North Seattle seat again next year.