By Erica C. Barnett
Throughout 2020, PubliCola provided ongoing coverage of the year’s top stories, including the COVID-19 pandemic, efforts to shelter and house the region’s homeless population, budget battles between the mayor and city council, and efforts to defund the Seattle Police Department and invest in community-based public safety programs.
Still, there are a number of stories we didn’t follow up on, because of time constraints, lack of information, or the nonstop firehose of news that was 2020. So if you’re wondering what became of the people who were suddenly kicked out of an Aurora Avenue motel by the city, a proposal to keep track homeless system clients using fingerprints or digital IDs, or the detective who had the city’s Navigation Team haul away her personal trash, read on.
The Everspring Inn Eviction
One of the saddest and most complex stories we covered this year was a sudden mass eviction at the Everspring Inn on Aurora Ave. N—a semi-derelict motel that was home to dozens of people who were already living on the margins when the pandemic hit. The ouster was unusual among COVID-era evictions because it was instigated not by the landlord, but by the city—specifically, the Seattle Police Department, which declared the property a “chronic nuisance” after two shootings, multiple reported rapes, and ongoing drug activity.
In the days after the eviction notices (which said they had to leave “immediately,” almost certainly in violation of landlord-tenant law), tenants reported that security guards hired by the motel’s owner, Ryan Kang, had boarded up their doors and windows, locked them out of the property, and offered them as little as $100 to leave. Not all of the tenants did, and they said Kang cut off their hot water and towed their cars in retaliation.
Perversely, once a person is in any kind of housing, however tenuous, they become ineligible for many of the supports that could keep them housed.
Since then, most of the tenants have been moved temporarily to another hotel with the help of the Public Defender Association, whose LEAD and Co-LEAD programs help people engaged in low-level and subsistence crimes such as drug dealing and sex work. Although it took a while, the city of Seattle eventually gave the PDA authorization to use money left over from its 2020 contract to move the Everspring residents to another hotel and released funding so that they could enroll many ofthe residents in the LEAD program. (SPD, which was aware that many of the tenants were engaged in low-level criminal activity, had the authority to refer them to LEAD all along, but did not do so.)
It’s a common misconception that people experiencing homelessness, or who are at risk of homelessness, all require expensive interventions such as permanent supportive housing, mental health treatment, or jail if they’re engaged in low-level criminal activity. In reality, many just need a place to live that they can afford with a little financial help. However, precisely because they are not disabled, addicted to drugs or alcohol, or unable to work, people in this category are generally last to receive subsidies through rapid rehousing programs, which prioritize clients with more barriers to housing, not those who can almost pay for housing on their own.
The former Everspring tenants typify a group of homeless or marginally housed people who work in the illegal economy because they can’t find legal jobs that pay enough to cover rent, Daugaard says. They’re “high-functioning but economically insecure, and many have had no alternative to the illicit economy.”
The PDA has paid for the former Everspring residents to stay in a hotel for the next several months. By pre-paying for hotel rooms, rather than providing short-term rent subsidies for “permanent” housing, LEAD ensures that its clients remain eligible for other housing subsidies and assistance that’s only available to people who are “literally homeless”; perversely, once a person is in any kind of housing, however tenuous, they become ineligible for many of the supports that could keep them housed.
But funding for the PDA’s other hotel-based programs, including Co-LEAD and JustCare, which uses federal relief dollars to move people directly from encampments (like the ones near the downtown King County Courthouse) to hotels, is running out. If the city (or county) doesn’t come up with a new funding source for these hotel-based shelters, many will have to close at the end of January.
If you’re reading this, we know you’re someone who appreciates deeply sourced breaking news, features, and analysis—along with guest columns from local opinion leaders, ongoing coverage of the kind of stories that get short shrift in mainstream media, and informed, incisive opinion writing about issues that matter. Earlier this month, we took a look back at just some of the work we’ve been able to do thanks to generous contributions from our readers, but those pieces represent just a handful of the hundreds of stories we’ve published this year.
We know there are a lot of publications competing for your dollars and attention, but PubliCola truly is different. We cover Seattle and King County on a budget that is funded entirely and exclusively by reader contributions—no ads, no paywalls, ever.
Being fully independent means that we cover the stories we consider most interesting and newsworthy, based on our own news judgment and feedback from readers about what matters to them, not what advertisers or corporate funders want us to write about. It also means that we need your support. So if you get something out of this site, consider giving something back by kicking in a few dollars a month, or making a one-time contribution, to help us keep doing this work. If you prefer to Venmo or write a check, our Support page includes information about those options. Thank you for your ongoing readership and support.
Digital IDs for people experiencing homelessness
Back in 2019, PubliCola reported exclusively, Mayor Jenny Durkan ordered the Human Services Department to study biometric tracking of the city’s homeless population, using fingerprints or other unique identifiers. The idea was to create “efficiencies” in the homelessness system by making it easier for service providers (and clients themselves) to keep track of clients’ personal records, such as medical documents, IDs, and the services they access across the homeless system.
HSD staffers recommended that the city not move forward with biometric tracking (citing, among other reasons, the likelihood that people with mental illnesses whose symptoms include paranoia might not willingly submit to mandatory fingerprinting), and Durkan settled on the idea of “digital IDs” that would enable people to move through the homeless system without providing (and having to hang on to) physical cards.
So what has happened since then? Basically, nothing. The pandemic hit, and the idea, which was not especially popular within the homelessness division to begin with, got dropped. According to Durkan spokeswoman Kamaria Hightower, the city decided that digital IDs were “ultimately an issue that could be evaluated by the regional [homelessness] authority.” In practice, this means that the idea is dead for now.
Navigation Team Hauls SPD Detective’s Personal Trash
Another PubliCola exclusive this year was the revelation that an SPD detective who headed up the police side of the Navigation Team—a group of police and city social workers who removed encampments and offered shelter and services to their displaced residents—ordered the team’s trash contractor to haul away some bulky items from her house on their way to the dump. The incident prompted an investigation by the city’s Office of Police Accountability.
According to OPA director Andrew Myerberg, the case is now complete “and in the findings stage,” but none of the documents are available online. We’ve requested the case file from SPD, and will update this update when as we receive the documents.
4 thoughts on “2020 In Review: Following up On the Everspring Inn, the Navigation Team, and “Digital IDs” for Homeless Residents”
I meant to say I’ve been kicked out of co lead saying my lodging is expired bs nobody else was just me now I’m homeless again lots of good that did
Evicted by co lead
I think the city did a favor to the homeless living at the Everspring Motel. They were all subject to dangerous criminals in their midst as evidenced by the 2 murders, multiple rapes and continued exposure to drug dealing (making it hard to overcome addictions). Also, the LEAD Program needs to provide data on its results. The goal of the program is reduced recidivism (very small goal to prove). The public should be told how much reduced recidivism has occurred in the last 7 years of the program and how much we have spent in tax dollars to achieve this result.
I was apart of the everspring evicted and currently was evicted by co co l saying my lodging has expired and there’s nothing they can offer me now how and where do I go go now
Comments are closed.