Category: Mayor Wilson

Two Seattle Nice Interviews This Week: Mayor Katie Wilson and Budget Director Aly Pennucci, and Councilmember Dionne Foster

By Erica C. Barnett

Seattle Nice has two interviews for you this week!

On Friday’s show, we sat down with Mayor Katie Wilson and her budget director, Aly Pennucci, to talk about Wilson’s deficit-busting budget proposal, which is already facing stiff pushback from councilmembers who have grown accustomed to writing budgets that are balanced in the short term but assume huge deficits in future years. As I’ve reported, a cohort of centrist councilmembers elected in 2023 (plus Debora Juarez, appointed to replace Cathy Moore, who quit a year and a half into her term) are upset that Wilson failed to fund projects they paid for with one-time dollars last year.

Council members have also said they want a commitment to hire 1,400 officers (rather than the 1,250 the budget funds) and add police surveillance cameras to Seattle Center, where seven people were shot, three fatally, at the Bite of Seattle earlier this year.

We asked Wilson and Pennucci about the council’s initial reaction to the budget and how they’re doing things differently this year.

On CCTV cameras at Seattle Center:

Wilson: “There were not cameras right at the scene of the Bite of Seattle shooting, but there are cameras at Seattle Center, and camera footage from surrounding businesses has been used extensively in in the investigation.

“Seattle Center is not, in general, a high crime area of the city, and has never been talked about, to my knowledge, prior to the shooting as a potential location for CCTV cameras hooked up to the Real-Time Crime Center. … My budget does include $500,000 for security and safety at Seattle Center, and I believe that there’s been some conversation at Seattle Center about a potential use of some of that funding …[for]  mobile cameras that could be used during big events. So there might be some solution there that’s not, you know, permanent 24/7 CCTV cameras.”

On demands to commit to hirng 1,400 officers:

Wilson: “It’s simply not responsible budgeting to promise that we’re going to keep hiring police officers indefinitely without any projected way to pay for them. And in fact, even the near-term hiring plan of 1,250 was established without a way to pay for it, which is why we had to come up with extra money in order to fund these 66 additional police officer positions in order to get up to that 1,250 goal. Let alone 1,400 or whatever numbers people like to throw out there. So, you know, really, this is about what can we afford, and to get to any number higher than 1250, first we have to get to 1250. So let’s get to 1250.

“There’s a lot of different factors which influence how many officers we actually need to do the work. And so I don’t really think it’s that helpful to to try to put a specific number on it.”

On ongoing homeless encampment sweeps by the city’s Unified Care Team:

Wilson: “So the Unified Care Team, for the most part, has been continuing to operate the way that they were before I took office. We’ve been doing work with them to figure out how they can adjust some of their operations to get better outcomes for people experiencing homelessness, and that was a directive that I gave earlier this year. And so they’ve come back with recommendations, and we’re in conversation now about ways that they can change how they do their work to be more effective in matching people with with services, and and also more effective in responding to some of the felt needs in in neighborhoods. …

“My values have not changed, and I don’t think that I ever said during the campaign that I was going to stop the operation of the Unified Care Team. I said that we needed to shift to a model where we were moving people from encampments into shelter, and that is what we’re trying to do. And I’m as impatient as everyone else to have that happen faster.

“When you look at how the Unified Care Team does their work, they prioritize encampment sites based on safety considerations, both safety for the people living there and safety considerations for people in in the surrounding neighborhood. There often legitimate hazards. Obviously, when an encampment is is obstructing a sidewalk or an entrance to a light rail station a space in a park, the method of prioritization is really about safety and also about other high priority uses of that of that public space. And so I think there are good reasons often for needing to remove an encampment, even if we don’t have appropriate shelter to offer to people. And I don’t love it, right? I hate it actually. And also, that is the world that we’re living in until we actually have shelter that’s appropriate to people’s needs, and so that is why that is such a high priority for me.”

Listen to our entire interview—including Pennucci’s succinct explanation of the two budget refrains she’s had to repeat ad nauseam in response to council questions—here:

Earlier this week, we spoke with City Councilmember Dionne Foster about her legislation to give developers with stalled housing projects a deep temporary discount on Mandatory Housing Affordability fees. We asked Foster about her proposal to add some form of MHA fee in former single-family areas, where townhouses and small apartment buildings are now allowed, bringing their potential density in line with the city’s low-rise zones, where MHA applies. (Former councilmember Moore proposed imposing existing MHA fees in these areas.) We also asked why her legislation, which includes a window for new (rather than in-the-works) development to get a smaller discount on fees, excludes much of Southeast Seattle, the Central District and the CID.

On expanding MHA to neighborhood residential: “It is not a proposal to take MHA as is and put it in neighborhood residential. So what it does do is say, I want our our central staff, our team here on the second floor at City Hall, to work on a proposal that includes inclusionary zoning in neighborhood residential.

“There’s also some things that we put in there around approaches to make sure it’s a flat fee, or ways to think about it so it’s not constantly escalating, to make it more predictable for folks who are building in neighborhood residential. So there’s more work to do to figure out this concept. It is specifically not the proposal that former council member Cathy Moore put forward last year. Although I think because it’s talking about a form of inclusionary zoning in neighborhood residential, that is sort of the easiest thing for people to reach for. I understand that response, but it’s where I’m actually asking for something different and to work on a process to identify that and get that right.”

On excluding new projects in areas of “high displacement risk” from the proposal: “It’s not exclusion of housing in those areas, but it was really [designed] to take into account the fact that we want to make sure we’re not accelerating, necessarily, the pace of housing in certain geographic areas that have maybe seen a lot of development or where there’s a high risk of displacement concern. The basis for this is using some of the city’s data around high risk of displacement, so that we’re not over-incentivizing production in those areas during this short period of time.”

Listen to our conversation with Foster here:

SPD Overpaid Officers By $13 Million. Now the City Wants It Back.

.SPD West Precinct

By Erica C. Barnett

The Seattle Police Department overpaid police officers, management, and civilian staff a total of more than $13 million as  part of a police contract, signed in 2025, that gave officers retroactive pay increases for two years when they were operating under a previous, expired contract.

Overall, about 900 SPD employees, most of them represented by the Seattle Police Officers Guild, received more retroactive pay—a payment that represents how much an officer would have made under a new contract during a period when no contract applied—than they were supposed to, thanks to an error by SPD’s budget or HR office. Basically, someone at SPD used 2020 rather than 2024 as a baseline to calculate what officers were owed. Because pay was much lower in 2020 than in 2024, this miscalculation produced a much larger differential between officers’ pre-contract pay and their pay under the new contract. Hence the overpayments, according to the city.

Some of the payments were in the thousands, but a large number were in the five figures. One officer received $32,000 in excess pay, while hundreds more received $10,000 or more on top of their regular “retro” payments. Around 100 SPD employees received at least $20,000 more than they were supposed to, while another 225 received between $15,000 and $20,000, according to the mayor’s office.

It’s unclear whether any officer who received a bloated retroactive paycheck reported the discrepancy to SPD. SPD referred all questions to the mayor’s office, which said they’d get back to us tomorrow.

The Seattle Police Management Association and Teamsters 117, the two unions that represent a small number of the SPD employees who were overpaid, have policies in their contracts for resolving overpayment. Employees who aren’t represented by unions will have to pay the money back, in accordance with state law on overpayments.

That leaves SPOG, whose contract is silent on what happens if SPD inadvertently pays them too much. (Officers themselves have apparently kept silent, too, since the city budget office just found out some of them got checks in June that were higher than they were supposed to be by five-figure amounts).

SPOG’s 2026-2027 contract, adopted last year, boosted starting salaries well above six figures, so the difference between an officer’s 2024 pay and their pay starting in 2026 could be significant—perhaps $20,000, based on a typical raise for an officer now making around $75 an hour. But it’s hard to imagine that none of the hundreds of officers expecting a check in that ranged noticed when their payment was $10,000, $15,000, or $25,000 higher than expected. Come on. No one?

In a statement, the mayor’s office revealed who holds the cards in this situation, and it isn’t the city. “As required by law, the City will engage in bargaining with SPOG over the method by which SPOG members will repay the overpayments,” the mayor’s office said. In other words, the city can’t just take the money back—it has to get SPOG to agree on whether and how and how much money officers will have to repay, and they could choose not to bargain at all.

Of course, “overpayments” are just money that belongs to the city and its taxpayers that the city misspent. What’s the difference between a police officer who knowingly keeps money he didn’t earn and one who grabs $10,000 he found lying around at a crime scene? That will be a question to keep in mind if SPOG argues officers should just get to keep the money.

I hoped to ask SPOG president Kent Loux about this, but he did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

SPD’s error raises questions about the department’s oversight of its budget, which is around half a billion dollars. Wilson’s office said they learned about the discrepancy in mid-July, which is shortly before Wilson asked then-chief Shon Barnes to resign.

SPOG announced a class-action lawsuit over alleged underpayments and nonpayments after the city implemented its dramatically faulty new payroll system, Workday, in 2025. According to the mayor’s office, the overpayments involved officers who were were working at the department between January 1 and August 27, 2024. Although Wilson’s office said the payment errors at SPD had nothing to do with Workday, August 27 was exactly one week before the city transitioned to the new system. I’ve asked the mayor’s office for more information about how those dates were chosen.

The mayor’s office did not identify the person or people directly responsible for SPD’s error.

The mistake, whoever made it, occurred under the watch of former police chief Shon Barnes and current Chief Operating Officer Sarah Smith, who oversees both human resources and SPD’s budget office. According to an FAQ provided by the mayor’s office, the city budget office (CBO) “learned of this error when SPD contacted CBO regarding a budget-to-actuals discrepancy in SPD’s 2026 budget related to retroactive payments.” In plain English, SPD discovered it was paying out more than it had budgeted, and asked the city budget office to take a look.

According to the mayor’s office, the city council first learned about the overpayments in early August. The mayor’s office said they don’t know when they might recover the overpayments, since they have to negotiate with SPOG for that to happen. In the meantime, the overpayments will become a new problem for this year’s budget, as the city looks an extra $13 million to avoid throwing the budget out of balance.

In the future, Wilson’s office said, the city budget office and the Office of City Finance will have to sign off on all retroactive payments before they go forward. “The Office of City Finance is also updating the payroll manual to provide guidance to department staff on this new approval requirement,” according to the FAQ.

The city council has known about SPD’s overpayment problem since late August, according to Wilson’s office. It won’t impact next year’s budget, which the council is currently hashing out. We reached out to public safety committee chair Bob Kettle, who wants to find money to hire more officers next year, but have not heard back.

Council Learns What “One-Time Funding” Means; Podcaster’s Advocacy for Anti-Trans Campaign Didn’t Violate Election Law

1. City council members who funded an unsustainable budget last year by using one-time dollars to fund tens of millions in new spending are finding out this year what “one-time funding” means.

For years, the council has used a combination of one-time spending and magical thinking to approve new budget adds every year, without creating any kind of plan to pay for them in the future. Last year alone, the council added $78 million in one-time spending to a budget that was already deeply unsustainable. (If you search the budget they approved, you’ll see that the phrase “one-time funding” appears no fewer than 107 times!)

One-time does not mean “actually forever, but we’ll find money for it later (wink).” It means one-time—as city budget director Aly Pennucci repeatedly had to remind outraged councilmembers, who complained that programs they failed to fund for more than one or two years had somehow vanished in Wilson’s budget. These included subsidies for private inpatient rehab, a “district fund” for each councilmember, and a long list of small-business assistance programs. (The budget does include between $10 million and $15 million to make some of the council’s 2026 additions permanent.)

Well into the third day of departmental budget presentations, Rob Saka wanted to know why Wilson was not funding a homeownership program the council funded with one-time dollars last year. Pennucci gave the same explanation she’d been giving for days. Saka, using his oratorical shouting voice (if you watch council meetings, you know the one), responded: “So I hear you saying, it’s not technically a cut, because it was a one-time add!”

To his credit, unlike other councilmembers, Saka did not follow up this comment by continuing to refer to the reduction in one-time funds as a cut.

There was one instance when a council member objected not to the end of one-time funding, but to Wilson’s decision to find money for a priority the council and Harrell previously paid for with one-time funds. Dan Strauss zeroed in on $$4 million for food banks and hot meal programs the council funded on a one-time basis this year. These funds, Strauss said, should be closely scrutinized, because unlike public safety, “providing food is not a charter responsibility.”

Bob Kettle brought up a similar objection when he suggested that the Office of Housing could address some of its own significant budget shortfall by building less affordable housing and counting projects built by the Seattle Social Housing developer, which is separate from city government, toward Seattle’s total number of affordable housing units.

Thinking of affordable housing in the city as one big thing, Kettle said, could help the council “ameliorate” some of Wilson’s “wrong choices”—like setting theoretical caps on police hiring after 2028—by freeing up funding for other council priorities. Counting those units as Seattle affordable housing “could provide some flexibility in the budgeting process because, hey, you know, [the social housing developer has] also got their shoulder in and they’re working hard to contribute to the overall process,” Kettle said. 

Social housing (which the council’s centrists tried to stop) is funded by a dedicated payroll tax, and was designed to create a new kind of mixed-income public housing in which higher-income renters subsidize lower-income renters. It is quite different than the subsidized affordable housing OH funds and builds, and the two aren’t fungible. Getting rid of some low-income subsidized housing would actually eliminate housing for low-income people,

(As an side: Elected officials who support more funding for police often raise this claim about “charter responsibilities,” as in “public safety is our number one charter responsibility.” But actually, the charter lays many other basic responsibilities city government is supposed to address, and “health” actually comes before “safety,” followed by “environment” and “general welfare.”)

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

There was also a lot of—what’s the technical term?—nonsense and grandstanding from the council, particular when the Seattle Department of Transportation presented its budget. Struass, in particular, took the opportunity to gripe about hyperlocal issues in his neighborhood, including the fact that King County Metro cut hours on his bus route, which he has consistently characterized as the only bus route from Ballard to downtown Seattle. (It is not). You can read about more of those on my Bluesky.

One other exchange I do want to highlight is Strauss’ suggestion that the city is wasting money by allowing the King County Regional Homelessness Authority to serve as the Continuum of Care for the region. “A bureaucratic system from the county” is “creating inefficiencies for us,” Strauss asserted, adding “I don’t think we have time for that.”

While there have obviously been massive financial problems at the KCRHA—which is why the city is reasserting control over the homelessness contracts it funds—the continuum of care is a federally mandated system that oversees applications for federal funding for programs across King County and its 39 cities. It has never been at the city of Seattle, and a recent forensic audit did not identify it as a source of financial issues.

2. As a few others reported last week (when I was out of town), the state Public Disclosure Commission dismissed a complaint against Let’s Go Washington, the group behind two initiatives targeting children’s rights at school, on September 23. The complaint was filed by Washingtonians for Ethical Government, a nonprofit established in 2015. I reported on the initial complaint back in May

The first initiative would ban trans girls from playing sports in school and require children to prove their sex assigned at birth, through a medically unnecessary physical exam if they don’t have a longtime pediatrician willing to attest that they possess a vagina. The second would give parents access to any notes teachers or counselors make about conversations with students, including conversations about sensitive topics they may feel uncomfortable or unsafe broaching at home, like gender, abortion and birth control, and sexuality.

The complaint alleged that right-wing podcaster Brandi Kruse, who has served as a de facto spokesperson for the campaign, was doing official campaign work when she spoke on the campaign’s behalf. In short, WEG argued that Kruse’s speeches at campaign rallies and fundraisers constituted work on behalf of the campaign, and the campaign should have either compensated her for that work or reported it as an in-kind contribution. The PDC disagreed, agreeing with Kruse and the campaign that the podcaster is just a regular campaign volunteer expressing her personal opinions, and distinguishing her “keynote” speeches to Republican Party groups from her campaign speeches because she does “significant advance planning” for the former.

Kruse argued that the promotion does for the campaign on her own podcast isn’t political advertising either, because the campaign does not directly “control” what she says there. (In theory, she could say something that cast the campaign in a poor light, though she never has). The PDC didn’t address that defense.

Greater Seattle: Inclusionary Zoning, Part 2; Amazon as a Percentage of the Budget; Permitted, but Struggling

By Josh Feit

Last week, I featured Seattle City Councilmember Dionne Foster in an item headlined “Inclusionary Zoning > No Inclusionary Zoning” to reflect her progressive affordable housing stance. However, according to a comprehensive new academic study, she has it backward.

No Inclusionary Zoning > Inclusionary Zoning

So says the study released this summer by an economist at UC Irvine about inclusionary zoning (IZ), a policy that requires builders to couple any market-rate housing they build with affordable housing. Seattle’s version of this—as in Foster’s resolution calling for inclusionary zoning requirements in residential areas where the policy doesn’t currently apply—uses a “fee in lieu” model where developers can pay into an affordable housing fund instead of including the affordable housing in their own projects.

Unlike other (inconclusive) research on IZ, the UC Irvine study had a clean before-and-after look at the policy, thanks to California’s unique history of going through a period when inclusionary zoning (including the fee-in-lieu model) was legal, illegal, and then legal again.

The study indicates inclusionary zoning does the opposite of what it’s intended to do, finding that IZ makes it more expensive to rent. California renters paid approximately $6.97 billion in additional rent in areas with IZ mandates. So, even as IZ funds some affordable units, it comes at a steep cost to renters, including low-income renters, who aren’t “lucky enough to get an IZ unit,” according to the study.

But the real zinger: The study then compared that rent increase to the number of affordable units created and found that it wasn’t worth the tradeoff. As the author bluntly states in the opening summary: “I estimate the cost of generating an affordable unit with inclusionary zoning to be approximately $800,000 [per the 8,990 units created] in ‘excess rents’ paid by market rate renters as a result of the policy’s constraint on supply. This exceeds the cost of directly incentivizing the creation of low-income housing [~$441,00 per unit] in California through existing programs.”

Seattle’s Budget = Amazon’s Stock Price

Speaking of being blunt, Erica didn’t hold back in her report on Mayor Wilson’s $2.5 billion budget proposal last week. And I quote: “JumpStart is Basically Just a Slush Fund Now.”

JumpStart, of course, is the 2020 tax on high-end salaries proposed and passed by former lefty city councilmember Teresa Mosqueda to pay for affordable housing and other progressive priorities. Now, according to a recent economic study commissioned by Seattle’s own Office of Economic Development, it increasingly covers the city’s regular budget shortfalls. Since 2024, when a newly elected city council majority changed the law to eliminate the original JumpStart spending plan, more than half of JumpStart revenues are used to cover the gap between city budget expenditures and general fund revenue.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

I’m not here to cry about that. True believers like me have lost that fight. But here’s a problem with  budgeting-by- JumpStart that everyone should note: The report found that “Seventy-five percent of JumpStart revenue comes from just 10 companies.”

This is emblematic of Seattle’s worrisome status as a one-crop town (big tech). “In summary,” the report states, “the city’s fiscal health now depends on the marginal location and compensation decisions of a handful of employers. It also depends, indirectly, on the stock prices of those employers.”

Zeroing in on the city’s largest company, the report continues: “When Amazon’s stock rises, Seattle’s tax base rises with it; when it falls, the base contracts. (Amazon’s stock price alone has ranged from roughly $85 to $245 over the past three years.) But it means that a fiscal base already concentrated in a few firms is further exposed to the single most volatile attribute of these firms—one the city has no ability to forecast or influence.”

Existing Third Places > New Startups

Wilson explicitly acknowledges the challenge by incorporating her recent “Resilient Economy” executive order  into her budget proposal. Seattle has “become increasingly concentrated on the tech sector,” the EO states. It commits the city to convene a task force “to develop and implement strategies for diversifying and growing Seattle’s economy.”

And while the specifics of the order focus on making it easier to permit and establish startups in tech-adjacent fields, that strikes me as being more top-down than middle-out. As I noted a few weeks ago, the thing that makes Seattle attractive to the talent needed for new startups are third spaces—i.e., existing businesses.

I wish Wilson’s proposal did more for the bars and restaurants and coffeeshops that are already permitted, but increasingly struggling: 67 percent of brick-and-mortar, small, independent businesses told OED they are under more financial stress than during the pandemic. “[Seventy-one] percent reported lower foot traffic than a year earlier, and only 12 percent said customer demand was sufficient to cover their cost structure.”

Josh@Publicola.com

On Wilson’s Budget, the Council Parts Ways With Reality

This is the first year the police budget has exceeded the half-billion dollar mark, reflecting a new contract that boosts starting salaries for newly minted officers well into the six figures. Officers with college degrees get additional premium pay.

An early look at how the council is reacting to the mayor’s deficit-busting budget.

By Erica C. Barnett

Last week, I described Mayor Katie Wilson’s first budget as “small-c conservative,” because it eschews most of the budget tricks of recent years and achieves balance through 2030 not by raising taxes, but by eliminating positions and deferring spending. It also relies heavily on the JumpStart payroll tax—originally created as a source of additive spending on affordable housing and other progressive priorities—to backfill the general fund.

Business groups agreed with my assessment, praising the budget as “a thoughtful approach to a difficult fiscal challenge” (Joe Nguyen, head of the Seattle Metro Chamber of Commerce) and an “important” example of “fiscal discipline” (Jon Scholes, head of the Downtown Seattle Association). The head of the Washington Hospitality Association, quoted in the Seattle Times, said the group was “pleased to see no tax increases, and we’re also pleased to see an increase in the number of police we’ll see on the streets.”

But there’s one group that seems to absolutely hate the mayor’s budget: The centrists on the City Council, who spent last Friday’s daylong public safety budget meeting painting Wilson as a “screaming” police abolitionist, obtusely mischaracterizing efforts to cut spending by not funding vacant positions, and suggesting that Wilson should have dramatically boosted police spending to levels completely inconsistent with budget realities.

The biggest of those realities: A $175 million deficit built into the budget these same council members approved last year. As I reported at the time, that budget, proposed by former mayor Bruce Harrell and expanded by the council, “relies heavily on budget tricks to remain balanced for 2026, tumbling immediately into nine-figure deficits in 2027 and beyond.”

Even as it eliminates those annual deficits, Wilson’s budget fully funds 66 new police officers who were hired in 2026 but whose positions were not funded in Harrell’s 2026 budget.

It also includes funding, in 2027 and 2028, to get SPD to a total of 1,250 officers, the goal set by SPD’s own staffing plan. Wilson’s budget office director, Aly Pennucci, told me last week that she expects SPD will hit that number on schedule sometime in 2028 and stick to roughly the same number over the two years after that. SPD will lose some vacant civilian positions—unfilled but funded jobs they’ve historically used to pay for other priorities. And they aren’t slated to gain net new officers beyond those 1,250 after 2028, although that could change two years from now, when the 2029 and 2030 budgets are actually on the table.

Despite some headlines characterizing Wilson’s budget as an almost 14 percent “expansion” of SPD, new hires represent a fraction of the added spending. Most of the new obligation—$56 million—is mandated by the police union contract negotiated by former mayor Harrell and signed by a majority of the current council. Another chunk, nearly $13 million, pays the full cost of new officers hired in 2026 (most of whom didn’t work a full year last year, since they were hired at various times), plus any additional officer hires needed to get SPD staffing up to the 1,250 goal.

Though modest compared to some councilmembers’ expansionist ambitions, those new hires are real, and represent a commitment to adding more police to get the department to the goal it established for itself.

To listen to the tirades coming out of City Hall on Friday, though, you’d have though Wilson was taking a chainsaw to the police budget, or perhaps going across the street and yanking badges and guns away from officers herself.

Public safety committee chair Bob Kettle kicked things off, fulminating that Wilson’s budget really should have funded 150 more officers a year, since the city will “have to have 1,800 officers in our city with population growth” by 2050. (As an aside, although this simplistic officers-per-capita ratio is popular among politicians and many individual police chiefs, the International Association of Chiefs of Police does not recommend calculating police spending this way, because it can lead to redundant and unnecessary hiring.)

“It seems like we’ve given up on the goal of reaching 1,400 plus, which is really the minimum that we need to have for officers,” Kettle said, directing his comments at Pennucci. “In fact, the proposed budget for 2028 is a sustaining budget that has zero new net hires. And should we, as a council, interpret this to mean the mayor’s office no longer wishes to grow the size of the appointment long term?” Pennucci, in what would become a refrain, explained that hiring 150 net new officers over the next to years is not a goal “grounded in financial reality.”

Put another way, if the city council wants to spend another $30 million or so hiring an additional 150 cops, they’ll have to come up with $30 million in cuts to other departments and city services. Where is that going to come from? No one who complained about the proposed police budget on Friday, including Kettle, Rob Saka, Debora Juarez, and Maritza Rivera, offered any suggestions. 

Nor did councilmembers explain how (or why) the city should continue funding nine long-vacant parking enforcement officer positions, which Wilson’s budget eliminates—while retaining funds for six other vacant PEO positions. Both Rivera and budget chair Dan Strauss were optimistic that a new contract with the PEOs, who start out at around $36 an hour, will result in filling the vacant positions; Rivera said PEOs are necessary to enforce the law against “illegal activity” going on inside RVs (actually SPD’s job), while Strauss said a lack of parking enforcement will lead to lower “turnover” in popular areas as people overstay parking limits designed to ensure plenty of spots are available.

Another item councilmembers said should have been somewhere in the budget, but isn’t, was police surveillance cameras in Seattle Center. Harrell himself never proposed adding police cameras at Seattle Center. Instead, it focused on surveilling areas with high rates of specific crimes, including violent crime, drug sales, and prostitution. Despite councilmembers’ insistence that only cameras can prevent (or help police investigate) the next Bite of Seattle-style tragedy, Seattle Center is not some murder hot spot. In fact, in searching the Seattle Public Library’s online media database, I could find only one homicide at Seattle Center, in 1967; two other shootings, at Folklife Festival in 2008 and on another occasion in 2012, resulted in nonfatal injuries.

Nonetheless, council members demanded to know why Wilson’s budget failed to fund cameras all around Seattle Center in anticipation of the next mass shooting there. As I noted on Bluesky, politicians tend to be very good at responding to the last crisis as if the exact same scenario is likely to occur again. This is why we all have to take our shoes off and dump out our water at the airport, even as the TSA fails to detect actual weapons the vast majority of the time.

Rob Saka led the charge. After a little Socratic back-and-forth with Sayles to confirm that, yes, the police chief agreed that more police cameras would have helped the still-ongoing investigation into the July shootings, Saka—who talked uninterrupted for 18 minutes—said he found the “omission” of new cameras at Seattle Center “extraordinarily difficult to understand and incredibly disappointing.”

Specifically, Saka continued, he was shocked that the police had to rely on footage from bystanders and businesses as part of their investigation.

“Here’s the key contradiction,” Saka said. “After a deadly shooting at one of the city’s most important civic campuses, the Seattle Police Department had to to seek video evidence, footage from tenants, businesses, visitors, and people—pulling cell phones! We’re asking our investigators to essentially pass the hat for simple video evidence after tragedy strikes! Begging, borrowing, pleading, passing the collection plate for simple, simple evidence. Apparently, everyone can have a damn camera in the city, except the city itself!”

Two quick fact checks. First, there are cameras at Seattle Center and they were on. Second, asking for cell phone footage has been a routine aspect of police investigations since at least the advent of the iPhone two decades ago. More on that in a moment.

This was the second time that Saka had demanded to know why the city wasn’t funding cameras at Seattle Center. The first time was at a Parks budget briefing the previous day, when he demanded to know the department’s “plan to install the permanent infrastructure and keep those cameras on at all times, given the main-event threat at Seattle Center?” As chair of the council committee that oversees the Seattle Center Department, it was a little strange that Saka addressed these questions to a staffer in a department with no control over Seattle Center or its budget.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

On Friday, Saka said the city couldn’t say “with a straight face” that “we’re advancing a responsible budget and carrying out our charter responsibility to keep people safe without funding for critical CCTV cameras at the Seattle Center. … When we do that, the public understandably feels like they’ve been hoodwinked. They feel like they’ve been bamboozled, snookered, hornswoggled, duped, swindled, played, hustled, tricked, fooled, misinformed, led, punked, sold a bill of goods.”

Rivera, piling on, said it was “embarrassing that we have to ask the public for their camera footage because we’re refusing to put cameras in places where they need to be, so that when crime does happen, we’re able to solve crime and provide answers to the folks that have been hurt by these crimes.” Whether cameras “need to be”

“We do ask people for their personal footage in order to solve crime. That does not make any sense.”

As I mentioned, asking the public for video footage and using footage from nearby businesses is a routine, standard, and probably universal practice among police departments investigating major crimes committed in public. It’s impossible for police to replicate the near-total coverage of public events that smartphones and business security cameras provide access to; attempting to do so would involve a Panopticon of surveillance cameras so total it would blow the current police budget out of the water.

No Seattle elected official has ever publicly proposed eliminating this essential investigative practice, to my knowledge, until Saka and Rivera did last week.

But the council’s departures from reality didn’t end there. (And I’m not even counting Dan Strauss’ repeated comments about how he “reinflated” his collapsed lungs when he was hit by a car in 2004, something he said he learned to do after falling off the monkey bars a bunch as a kid. This came in the context of a later discussion about a proposed reduction to Fire Department overtime, which—you know what, let’s just keep it moving)

First, Rivera clocked a $500,000 reduction in spending on three (of nine) vacant analyst positions at the Real Time Crime Center, where police monitor surveillance cameras and analyze footage, and said it looked like Wilson was “eliminating” the RTCC altogether. In fact, SPD budget director Dan Eder explained, the six new positions would still enable SPD to expand RTCC staffing from the current 15 positions to 21, enabling the center to operate 24/7 for the first time.

Not to be outdone, Debora Juarez—a former elected councilmember who was appointed to serve out Cathy Moore’s term when Moore quit the council less than two years into her term—accused Wilson of submitting a “political” SPD budget aimed at “defunding” SPD.

“I’m not trying to make this political. I’m trying to make it factual,” Juarez said. “I want SPD to know that we support you and what you’re doing. … And yes, we all invest and will continue to invest and support all upstream programs, diversion, absolutely.”

“But again,” Juarez continued, “I have a hard time believing—because I watched this mayor scream ‘defund,’ come here, in here, and scream ‘Defund the police! Abolish the police!’ So I have a hard time believing that somehow some of this on the executive branch is not political, and I think that’s offensive, and it’s not fair, and it ain’t right. So I’ll leave it at that.”

Wilson did not scream “abolish the police” (or anything else) at the council in 2020; despite efforts to portray her as “angry” and “loud,” she is congenitally quiet and low-key. She did testify in favor of the Solidarity Budget, which her group, the Transit Riders Union, was supporting. In her testimony (around 37:30), she expressed support for hand-washing stations, a women’s shelter, funding for sidewalks, and “extending the police hiring freeze through 2021.”  She did not “come in here”—council chambers—to say any of these things, because in 2020, all the council’s meetings were virtual because of COVID.

During the afternoon half of Friday’s meeting, Rivera said repeatedly that Wilson’s proposal to fund focused deterrence—a strategy that combines resources for young men likely to commit gun violence with swift arrest and punishment for those who do—was not actually focused deterrence at all, and that the mayor was using the term incorrectly to describe a “random” suite of gun violence strategies.

But her claim, like Juarez’ recollection of Wilson standing in council chambers and screaming “Abolish the police!,” was untrue. Wilson’s office confirmed that the mayor’s focused deterrence commitment will absolutely include both service providers and police; the divergence between the mayor’s plan and Rivera’s is that Wilson wants to consider other vendors besides the consultant Rivera has been aggressively pushing, the National Network for Safe Communities, to do that work. Rivera’s plan would add $414,000 to the two-year budget.

Friday’s budget meetings, which also included discussions of deferred hiring for the CARE Team and cuts to overtime at the Fire Department, felt like a turning point for the city council. No longer are they merely griping that the mayor’s office doesn’t consult them before making decisions (a legitimate, if overused, complaint). Now, they’re making up their own facts to fit a narrative that’s out of step even with the city’s conservative business community—painting Wilson as a radical, screeching leftist in the face of a budget characterized by fiscal discipline.

Maybe the council has just gotten too comfortable signing blank checks, and forgotten that even the city eventually has to balance its checkbook. What remains unclear, because no one on the council has even broached the topic, is how Kettle, Strauss, Hollingsworth, Saka, and Rivera plan to add tens of millions in new spending to this year’s budget without decimating departments that are already taking cuts. It’s early for predictions, but I’m guessing they’ll rely in part on the same strategy they used throughout Harrell’s term—pushing the budget pain just past the horizon, by piling up deficits in “out” years when they may be somebody else’s problem.

Mayor Wilson Rolls Out Small-C Conservative Budget that Addresses City’s Structural Deficit

The proposal makes real cuts to close a $175 million gap—and reflects the conflict between campaign ambitions and a budget deficit that has gone unaddressed for years.

By Erica C. Barnett

Mayor Katie Wilson’s proposed 2027 budget (announced earlier this week, while I was out of town) would accomplish something that her predecessor, Bruce Harrell, never really attempted: It would close the city’s $175 million structural budget deficit, created largely by the use of one-time funds to pay for ongoing new programs in every budget since 2020. And it would do so in a transparent, sustainable way—by actually cutting departmental budgets, eliminating 128 mostly positions (all but 15 of them vacant), and by foregoing many of the budget tricks that Harrell used to create on-paper balanced budgets that in fact were deeply unsustainable.

What Wilson’s budget does not do, with a couple of notable exceptions (increased shelter funding, new public restrooms, and cuts to civilian police position), is strongly reflect many of the values that got the mayor elected, including a commitment to police alternatives, taxing big corporations, and funding not just hundreds but thousands of new shelter beds.

In particular, it includes no new progressive revenues and heavily relies on the existing JumpStart tax to supplant programs that were previously paid for through the general fund—including $65 million in existing homelessness funding that will now come out of JumpStart. It eliminates funding for long-vacant positions, ongoing new programs for which Harrell and the council used one-time funding, and some of Harrell’s pet-priority projects, like graffiti removal and AI.

The plan has earned Wilson praise from the business community, and from some in Seattle’s conservative and right-wing press. It is small-c conservative in a way that Harrell’s spendthrift, please-everybody budgets never were. It’s possible that many of Wilson’s most hard-core supporters will rally around this budget even though it further institutionalizes the repurposing of JumpStart and other policies that progressives roundly criticized Harrell for, simply because they’re coming from Wilson.

In some ways, it may have taken Wilson—a heterodox housing and transit activist who the mainstream press loves to refer to as an “avowed socialist”—to propose this budget. The council, which overloaded last year’s budget with spending restrictions designed to lock Wilson in to their priorities, will almost certainly have a field day with it, piling on new spending while insisting (as budget chair Dan Strauss did on Thursday) that their budgets have always been sustainable. But if the council decides to knock Wilson’s budget, which is balanced through 2030, out of balance, it will be on them, not her.

I’m going to focus on some of the highlights of the budget, which the city council took up today at an initial high-level today. I’m also focusing on changes to the budget that haven’t been previously announced. Previously announced changes include funding for universal free meals at schools; funding to enforce the city’s ban on residential junk fees and on algorithmic grocery pricing; funding to accelerate shelter construction; funding for a new city prosecutor to pursue extreme risk protection orders and the return of $127 million in city funding for homelessness programs from the King County Regional Homelessness Authority, which I’ve covered elsewhere.

Lots and lots more to come; these are just a few things that jumped out at me as I took a first look at the 735-page budget book.

JumpStart is Basically Just a Slush Fund Now

JumpStart—a tax, paid by businesses, on the compensation of highly paid workers at large companies—was originally supposed to provide additive funding for affordable housing, green jobs, and equitable development, all areas that were related to the spike in Seattle’s cost of living due to the recent influx of high-paid tech workers. Instead, since it passed, every mayor has used a growing portion of the JumpStart fund to pay for basic city needs—which of course means less money for the emerging needs JumpStart was created to address. Wilson’s budget is no different.

Wilson’s budget takes $173 million out of JumpStart to supplant general-fund spending unrelated to the four JumpStart priorities, plus another $65 million to pay for homelessness programs that were previously paid for out of the general fund. The budget counts the existing homelessness programs as “JumpStart” priorities, which is technically true, but because they’re existing general-fund programs I’m going to add them to the $173 million, to get a total of $238 million that Wilson is proposing to takes out of the JumpStart bucket.

Overall, Wilson’s budget repurposes a whopping 59 percent of this year’s $402 million in JumpStart revenues for general-fund purposes. However, because the budget also grabs $43 million out of a fund balance JumpStart has left over from previous years, plus $8 million in earnings from JumpStart fund investments, that total could also be calculated at around 52 percent—still substantially more than the 38 percent Wilson’s budget claims by counting the shifted homelessness programs as essentially new JumpStart spending. (Wilson’s budget uses another large JumpStart balance transfer in 2028, but the fund starts to grow again the following year).

“No More Public Safety” (will be the KOMO headline when they figure this out)

Police spending is projected to grow this year, but not because the mayor is proposing to substantially increase hiring. As we’ve reported, SPD has been put on notice that it needs to slow hiring even as applications pour in from people attracted by huge starting salaries, and Wilson’s budget eliminates temporary hiring bonuses adopted after hiring dropped in 2020; it also cuts millions in funding Harrell added for ridiculous macho recruiting ads.

The biggest cost increase in the SPD budget is a $56 million in wage and benefit increases from the Seattle Police Officers Guild contract Harrell and the city council agreed to last year; that contract, as we’ve reported, boosts the salaries of newly hired cops well above six figures.

The rest of the increase, about $12.6 million, will pay for 66 net new officers who were “hired in 2026 but only partially funded” in Harrell’s 2026 budget, plus funding for two SPD mental health professionals that Harrell’s budget only funded for nine months of this year (speaking of unsustainable budget tricks). The budget essentially calls for capping the number of police officers at 1,250 after 2028, a figure that will unquestionably surface as an issue during the budget process, when the city council has a whack at the budget.

SPD’s budget also goes down in one area where Harrell allowed it to balloon unaccountably: The police chief’s office, which former chief Shon Barnes expanded dramatically by establishing a cadre of new positions, each more elaborately titled than the last, will lose three positions. Barnes’ Chief Communications Officer (FKA communications director) Barbara DeLollis and his Executive Director of Crime and Community Harm Reduction Lee Hunt left earlier this year. Alex Ricketts, Barnes’ chief of staff, is still a member of SPD’s command staff, while Andre Sayles, one of Barnes’ two deputy chiefs (most chiefs have just one deputy) is now interim police chief.

Overall, the budget provides funding for 1,866 positions each year through 2030—24 fewer, thanks to cuts to mostly vacant civilian positions, than last year. These positions include parking enforcement officer jobs that have been unfilled for years; PEO jobs are perennially hard to fill because they pay relatively poorly and are high-stress, which is one reason why cutting the empty positions does not actually mean cutting back on parking enforcement.

What it does mean is that SPD will lose some of the funding it uses for other purposes, in an annual sleight-of-hand that is not visible in budget documents. Although the department gets funding for overtime, they routinely use more than they ask for at the beginning of each year; to make up this predictable shortfall, the department uses SPD’s funded but vacant positions to pay for their overspending. (Further routinizing this lack of spending restraint, SPD routinely asks the council to add more money to the department’s budget later in the year as part of a less-visible “supplemental” budget process.) The budget’s $6.5 million or so in civilian savings, in other words, is also $6.5 million SPD can no longer use as a slush fund to pay for overtime; if these reductions become part of the budget.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

Just about every other department takes cuts to vacant positions in Wilson’s budget, but SPD’s are the most likely to raise objections from the council. Councilmember Bob Kettle was already fulminating against them at the council’s initial budget briefing on Thursday.

Council members also signaled Thursday that they have big questions about Wilson’s decision to reduce funding for the Community Assisted Response and Engagement (CARE) team to defer funding for 14 new crisis responders, the previously planned expansion for this year. (The budget doesn’t propose eliminating any of these positions).

CARE is also taking over a bunch of gun violence prevention initiatives from the Human Services Department as part of the gun-violence plan Wilson announced last week.

CARE department Chief Amy Barden said in the past that the 34-member team has had challenges filling its time because of excessive restrictions in the SPOG contract (CARE team members were told not to respond to a crisis in a grocery store parking lot, for instance, because of a contract provision saying they could only respond to crises that occur on publicly owned land), but has said in recent months that SPD has shown more willingness to allow the team to respond to the type of calls for which it was explicitly created. Wilson’s budget also eliminates funding for nine vacant 911 call taker positions, another potential point of conflict with the council.

The proposed budget also cuts overtime at the Fire Department by $7 million, requiring “the department to manage staffing within available resources.” Expect council fireworks over this one as well.

A few little things that could become big things

Stuff to look out for as the budget conversations go on this fall:

• The Seattle Department of Transportation’s budget is seriously out of whack, thanks largely to revenue shortfalls in SDOT’s Transportation Fund and Transportation Benefit District fund that I’m sure will get explained in more detail when the council discusses the department’s budget.

Transportation fund revenues have been declining every year. In Wilson’s budget, declining revenues in these two funds translate into cuts to both new capital projects and basic maintenance, as well as a shift in funding for “high priority” projects, like sidewalks and curb ramps, to the city’s automatic traffic camera program, which is expected to bring in more revenues once it expands to include automated speeding cameras (in addition to cameras that red-light and other traffic violations). The budget also increases taxes for parking in commercial

• Wilson’s budget proposes eliminating an awful lot of council (and mayoral) adds from previous years, which will undoubtedly rub some councilmembers the wrong way. For instance, the budget for the Parks Department cuts seven new positions the council added last year; I’ve asked the budget office which positions these are, but the possibilities include two anti-graffiti staff and three new park rangers. The budget would also cut some vacant positions on the Unified Care Team, which removes homeless encampments; Harrell and the council have repeatedly expanded the team and the council placed a restriction on the budget last year that makes it nearly impossible to cut the size of the 116-member team.

Wilson’s Parks budget also eliminates $500,000 in “discretionary graffiti funding”; Harrell, by his own admission, was absolutely obsessed with ridding Seattle of graffiti, and the word “graffiti” appears 71 times in his 2026 budget, compared to six times in Wilson’s.

The budget would also cut $500,000 Harrell added to last year’s budget for an AI system that was supposed to “streamline the permitting application process and improve customer services using Artificial Intelligence and data integration.”

• There’s also a new $500,000 for the (still troubled, from the complaints I continue to hear) Workday payroll system—this time, to pay for “surge” tech support to deal with changes to labor union contracts in real time. You would think that things like pay increases and classification changes could be handled by the city’s very large citywide and departmental HR staffs, but this is Workday we’re talking about.