Police Officers Received Average Overpayment of $12,500; Strauss Quietly Drops Sound Transit Power Grab from Budget

1. Most Seattle police officers who were overpaid for retroactive pay increases earlier this year received checks that were five figures larger than they should have been. On average, police received lump-sum checks that were more than $12,000 too high, PubliCola has learned.

As we reported last month, Seattle Police Department officers received bloated checks for retroactive pay increases totaling more than $13 million earlier this year.

The payments, which officers received on June 12, were part of a new police contract negotiated and approved by former mayor Bruce Harrell and the city council last year, which included both prospective pay increases and retroactive increases that were supposed to represent what officers would have been paid if the new contract had been in effect in 2024. The city has said the overpayments stemmed from an accounting error: Someone at the city used 2020, rather than 2024, as a baseline year, so that officers were paid for the difference between their pay in 2020 and their pay in 2026, a much larger gap.

Nearly 1,000 officers received the excess payments, which ranged from a few hundred dollars to more than $32,000.

One question that may never be answered is why officers don’t seem to have reported receiving checks that were much larger than they should have been expecting. Based on a little back-of-the-envelope math, a typical officer making $75 an hour under the new contract could have expected a lump-sum retroactive payment of around $20,000, representing the difference between their pay in 2024 and their newly negotiated pay in 2026.

One theory—that the extra money just wasn’t enough, in most cases, for officers to notice—is challenged by the actual size of the payments. Through a records request, PubliCola received a redacted list of every excess payment SPD made on June 12. (SPD says it will provide an unredacted copy next March). The list shows that of 966 improper overpayments, the vast majority, 715, were more than $10,000. Fifty-eight officers received checks that were bloated by more than $20,000. The average overpayment was $12,500, and the median was $12,000.

The numbers SPD provided only add up to $12 million, because they exclude city contributions for indirect costs like retirement benefits. Including that extra million would add an average of $1,000 to each officer’s overpayment.

Any effort to recoup the overpaid funds will have to go through legal negotiations that involve the Seattle Police Officers Guild, a process that could take years. In this year’s city budget process, Councilmember Dionne Foster tried to pass an amendment that would require the city to spend any recovered money on affordable housing, but it failed on a committee vote, with Foster, Alexis Mercedes Rinck, Rob Saka, and Eddie Lin voting yes and Dan Strauss abstaining, which amounts to a no. The proposal will be back one last time in full council on Friday, where Strauss will not have the option to abstain.

 

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

2. One day after Councilmember Rob Saka stood beside Mayor Katie Wilson and said he would support her veto of council budget chair Strauss’ proposal to ban overnight RV parking citywide, Strauss explained the thinking behind a budget amendment that would have stripped away Wilson’s authority over the city’s Sound Transit liaison and moved that person into the legislative department.

The two items were about unrelated issues, but both concerned Strauss’ general feeling that the mayor has violated his trust.

The staffer Strauss wanted to bring under the council’s control works for the Seattle Department of Transportation as part of the city’s Sound Transit team, and provides staffing for the mayor and the councilmember who serves on the Sound Transit board, currently Strauss.

“The sponsor’s intent is to have the position remain embedded in the City’s Sound Transit 3 team, but to ensure that there is direct reporting and accountability on the City’s Sound Transit 3 team to the Legislative Department and the legislative representative on the Sound Transit Board,” the amendment said.

At the time, Strauss said he was concerned that “the mayor did not support some of my work, or some of my priorities” for Sound Transit and because “I didn’t receive staffing support” to write his amendment to change the Sound Transit plan.

“I actually lost support at the Sound Transit meeting for my amendment”—a proposal to convince the regional transit agency to build light rail line starting in Ballard—”because I was not able to receive the staffing that I needed from our city staff in my work as a board member at Sound Transit” and had to write the amendment himself. It’s unlikely that a better-written amendment would have changed the vote, which was 14-4, with Wilson casting a vote for Strauss’ amendment.

By this week, though, Strauss had relented, thanks to a late-game memo from a mayoral staffer saying the proposal “will not accomplish the intent” of the amendment and “does not work in practice.”

If the amendment went through, Wilson’s director of mobility, livability, and city infrastructure Hannah McIntosh wrote, the effect would be to remove the person completely from SDOT’s Sound Transit 3 (ST3) planning team.

“While there are opportunities to work collaboratively, a position that reports within the Legislative branch has less points of access to Executive branch operations and decision-making.” In addition, McIntosh wrote, the person might no longer have enough work for a full-time job, since they do more than just staff the mayor and Strauss. “To the extent that this position does more than just staff the Board members, a transfer will reduce SDOT staff capacity for ST3 work.”

Strauss pulled the power-grabbing proposal from the budget agenda with little comment earlier this week.

One thought on “Police Officers Received Average Overpayment of $12,500; Strauss Quietly Drops Sound Transit Power Grab from Budget”

  1. SPS mistakenly overpaid me for a year. I’m a substitute who only worked a few days a week, but it was a substantial sum to me. There was no question that I would pay it back, just how, and if I didn’t decide, they would just take it out of my paycheck. I was dumbfounded. My feeling is their mistake, they pay.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.