City Quietly Eliminates Seattle City Council Listen Line, Saying Cost, Low Usage Killed the Decades-Old Transparency Tool

Billy Brown, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

By Erica C. Barnett

The Seattle City Council Listen Line—a number, 206-684-8566, that I can dial without looking and memorized more years ago than I can count—was quietly shut  earlier this month, eliminating the only offline option for people to listen in on meetings in council chambers remotely.

The loss of the call-in option doesn’t just impact people without ready access to the internet. Anyone who wants to listen in on meetings now will now have to burn up data and their phone battery keeping a Youtube window open just to listen to council meetings. I watch council meetings on the Seattle Channel’s Youtube page (which I prefer to the main Seattle Channel page because you can scrub backward if you miss something) all the time, but the Listen Line provided an option when I couldn’t be glued to a screen. There are many times when I’m on the go and just want to pop in earbuds to keep track of council meetings.

For me, listening to the audio of a live Youtube video that’s playing in my pocket while I run around the city (often on my way to City Hall) is a poor substitute for dialing up the trusty, phone battery-friendly call-in line. Since I posted about the abrupt, unannounced end to this decades-old option last week, city hall staffers and regular readers have let me know they also routinely tune in to meetings this way Line. It may seem like an antiquated bit of technology, but people use it in specific circumstances where the online options is actually a clunkier, less user-friendly substitute.

Asked why the city shut down the line, the council’s communications director, Brad Harwood, said the city decided not to renew its contract because of “the high monthly operating costs ($15,000), low and sporadic community usage, and aging hardware requiring replacement.” I’ve filed a records request to find out exactly how many people are using the Listen Line.

The city’s IT department “has a responsibility to make financially responsible decisions,” Harwood continued. “In this case, continuing the Listen Line service during a time of ongoing budget challenges was not fiscally appropriate.” Harwood said people who want to watch council meetings remotely can tune in to the video or sign up to give a public comment.

PubliCola is supported entirely by readers like you.
CLICK BELOW to become a one-time or monthly contributor.

Support PubliCola

 

The second option reflects another problem with getting rid of the Listen Line: The Seattle council, unlike the King County Council, does not make the call-in number for its Zoom meetings public. This means that the only way to call in and listen over Zoom is to sign up for \] public comment using an online form. Yes, anyone could pretend they want to give public comment and then just stay silent when the council calls their name, but this doesn’t strike me as an option most people are likely to take. (I considered it myself when the Seattle Channel’s live feed crapped out last week—hey, another argument for keeping a dial-in option available!— but didn’t feel comfortable registering under false premises.)

Council President Joy Hollingsworth said last week that the council is working with the city’s IT department “to figure out a more financially feasible option” for call-in access and hoped to be able to announce a “pathway forward” after Thanksgiving. Simply including the Zoom call-in number on council agendas would be an easy fix—though one that would require people to look up a new number for each meeting and dial in a long meeting code every time they want to listen in.

But I also question whether $15,000 a month is actually that big a price for a vital public transparency tool that serves those with the least access to technology, along with people who just want offline access to meetings as an alternative to video, like me. After all, the council found room in the budget to spend half a million dollars on murals in the “Ballard Brewery District,” $150,000 on holiday decorations that will include a large, illuminated statue of Jimothy the internet raccoon, and $100,000 to pay cops to supplement the security officers that already guard council chambers. Isn’t better access to public meetings worth at least one Jimothy?

 

One thought on “City Quietly Eliminates Seattle City Council Listen Line, Saying Cost, Low Usage Killed the Decades-Old Transparency Tool”

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.