Bellicose Seattle Police Chief Claims Police Access to Tear Gas Could Have Saved CHOP Shooting Victim’s Life

Seattle Police Chief Carmen Best said Monday that the life of Horace Lorenzo Anderson, the 19-year-old who was shot in the Capitol Hill Organized Protest (CHOP) zone on Saturday night, “might have been saved if not for the circumstances created by hasty legislation” barring police officers from using tear gas, pepper spray, rubber bullets, and other “less lethal weapons” to disperse protesters.

Best made her comments at a press conference Monday afternoon to announce the imminent shutdown of CHOP and the reopening of the East Precinct as a police station. “It is time to restore order and eliminate the violence on Capitol Hill,” Durkan said.

Best accused protesters of creating circumstances that allowed several Black men to be shot and then prevented Seattle Police Department officers, the Fire Department, and EMTs from coming in and delivering care. “I cannot stand by, not another second, and watch another black man or anyone here die in our streets while people aggressively thwart the efforts of the police and other first responders,” Best said.

Support The C Is for Crank
During this unprecedented time of crisis, your support for truly independent journalism is more critical than ever before. The C Is for Crank is a one-person operation supported entirely by contributions from readers like you.

Your $5, $10, and $20 monthly donations allow me to do this work as my full-time job. Every supporter who maintains or increases their contribution during this difficult time helps to ensure that I can keep covering the issues that matter to you, with empathy, relentlessness, and depth.

If you don’t wish to become a monthly contributor, you can always make a one-time donation via PayPal, Venmo (Erica-Barnett-7) or by mailing your contribution to P.O. Box 14328, Seattle, WA 98104. Thank you for reading, and supporting, The C Is for Crank.

The police department has presented no specific evidence to indicate that anyone at the protest was violent against police officers. In fact, both bodycam video released by SPD and the police department’s official timeline of events contradict this claim. According to the timeline, officers showed up at to a staging area on 12th and Cherry, about seven blocks from the shooting, around 2:30 in the morning and entered the area around six minutes later, when they were informed that medics had already taken the victim away. The bodycam footage shows protesters stepping aside for police while screaming that the victim has already been taken to the hospital. I don’t know what else was happening outside the frame, or how much is left out of the timeline. But what the police and mayor have offered so far are assertions, not evidence.

“SPD spent years developing the gold standard of use-of-force policy. Let that work. Allow us to use these [weapons] when absolutely necessary.”—Seattle police chief Carmen Best

And speaking of assertions: Best insisted that none of her statements were political before producing a stack of police reports and waving them in the air while asserting that “there are groups of individuals engaging in shootings, in rape, assaults, burglary, arson, and property destruction.” It’s unclear what was in the reports Best was holding or whether they indeed contained evidence that there were “groups” of people engaging in multiple assaults, rapes, and other crimes. One man was arrested last week in the and charged with sexual assault against a CHOP resident, and another man was arrested during a burglary in White Center for allegedly breaking in to an auto shop in the area and setting a desk on fire.

“This is happening,” Best continued. “We cannot walk away from the truth of what is happening here. This is not about politics and I am not a politician. This isn’t a debate about First Amendment rights—this is about life or death! So we need a plan. The council legislated away officers’ access to less lethal weapons,” Best continued—not mentioning that the legislation barring these weapons is not in effect yet—leaving officers with no options beside “a riot baton or a gun. … SPD spent years developing the gold standard of use-of-force policy. It was done in coordination with the federal monitor, the Department of Justice, and the federal court. Let that work. … Allow us to use these [weapons] when absolutely necessary.”

“The council legislated away officers’ access to less lethal weapons,” Best continued—not mentioning that the legislation barring these weapons is not in effect yet—leaving officers with no options beside “a riot baton or a gun.”

It’s unclear to what extent Durkan, who echoed Best’s narrative that police tried to respond to Saturday’s shooting but were forced to stay outside by a hostile crowd, agrees with her chief that tear gas and pepper spray could have allowed police to save Anderson’s life. Historically, and without exception, when police have attacked protesters in the area with chemical and “less-lethal” weapons, it has resulted in an escalation, not a deescalation, of conflict along with injuries to protesters, some of them grave.

Durkan may be attempting to distance herself from Best and her bellicose statements, but to what end? If she doesn’t fire the chief (and this seems vanishingly unlikely, given the optics of sacking a black female police chief who enjoys support from many Black clergy and other community members), seeming like the more “reasonable” public servant has its own obvious political advantages—including the fact that it allows the mayor to be the “good cop” when proposing a midyear budget later this week that will fail to meet one of the protesters’ chief demands: Defunding the police by 50 percent and reinvesting that money into community programs.

9 thoughts on “Bellicose Seattle Police Chief Claims Police Access to Tear Gas Could Have Saved CHOP Shooting Victim’s Life”

  1. Yes I saw the police video – the WHOLE police video – they were screaming at police, being aggressive while the officers were clearly explaining over the loud speaker why they were there. I saw the CHOP “medics” leave after dropping of the kid at harbor view, fists raised as if they accomplished something a part of something important. Their actions probably resulted in that kids death. Fire/ medics don’t enter a scene with an active shooter without police escort. And CHOP “security” doesn’t allow police. Please explain your logic in the your next article, but first learn how the world around you works. This is a long standing policy for nearly all services across the country. Clearly this is news to you.

  2. The crowd did not refuse to guide the police to the injured people. When the police arrived, the injured people had already been transported to hospital.

    1. Watch the WHOLE video. Wasn’t exactly a welcome party. CHOP backers do not own those blocks. Medics!?!?! WTF. Their actions are probably why that kid is dead. CHOP protesters or no better than the racist cops.

  3. I also saw video of that scene and the crowd was enraged and violent when the police entered the area. They didn’t part and guide the police to the injured people even though that’s what the police asked them loudly and calmly to do multiple times. That area has lots of people who openly carry weapons – the crowd was telling police to leave – and yelling anti police slogans while surrounding the group of police and following them through the area. Then, when police were leaving they surrounded their cars in an attempt to intimidate? or maybe prepare to break the car windows? It was unclear. All the while the peaceful protesters were trying to tell the unruly crazies to stop surrounding police. I think Chief Best meant that if police had been allowed to continue holding the protesters from their East Precinct instead of letting CHOP be created – and they would do this by use of non-lethal methods they had at their disposal – 1 person would still be alive today – 1 more would not be fighting for his life and two more would not have gunshot wounds to heal.

    Remember ZERO people died from tear gas and pepper spray in the protests.

    In CHOP ONE already died – ONE is fighting for his life and TWO are healing from gunshot wounds.

    1. My friend held him as he died. The police were late, he was already transported. This is the bullshit they need to justify doing what they want. Fuck 12! Not to mention they DID almost kill someone with a flash grenade to the chest so fuck off unless you have been there. I have.

    2. Agreed that this article seems to misrepresent Best’s implied argument that that restricting tear gas led to the creation of CHOP.

  4. C: EMT’s are not authorized to go into an area with an active shooter. You appear to be unfamiliar with legitimate police procedures. Have another drink!

    1. Steve, instead of a drinking game, I’m playing a trolling game. Every time you troll Erica about her recovery, I send her $10. I count 2 overt trolling events so far.

      1. I thought it was more than two. Please send her the money anyways. She needs to stay in business for my entertainment.

Comments are closed.