By Erica C. Barnett
On Tuesday, after PubliCola reported on turmoil at the city’s Office for Civil Rights, SOCR director Wheeler-Smith sent a lengthy email titled “COMPLAINT re DEPUTY MAYOR Brian Surratt” to the city’s Human Resources department and the City Attorney’s office, cc’ing a list of city officials, reporters, and editors (though not PubliCola).
“I write to submit a formal complaint against Deputy Mayor Brian Surratt who engaged in workplace misconduct by threatening me while I was on vacation celebrating my 50th birthday,” the email begins. “Given the city’s efforts to tarnish my name, character, and reputation through defamatory accusations and allegations, I thought it imperative to get my complaint filed quickly despite being on FMLA to support my mother” through a health challenge.
The complaint is based on two assertions. First, Wheeler-Smith says Surratt told him to resign before my story came out or it would be “really bad” for him. Second, he says Surratt and possibly other Wilson cabinet members “worked in tandem” with me to craft a false story about Wheeler-Smith based on “anonymous sources, mistruths, and misrepresentations.”
“It is devastating to learn that people in the Cabinet would work to coordinate such a piece going so far as to direct a few disgruntled staff—current and former—to the reporter,” Wheeler-Smith claimed.
PubliCola’s story was about allegations by Wheeler-Smith’s employees that their boss and his deputy engaged in “discrimination, retaliation, harassment, and mismanagement,” in the words of a memo to Wilson from their union, PROTEC17. Acting on behalf of represented staff, PROTEC17 asked Wilson to remove Wheeler-Smith shortly before she took office. Under a law passed in 2017, the SOCR director can only be removed for “just cause.”
Nine current SOCR employees and one who recently left the department spoke with me on condition of anonymity because they feared retaliation. In all, I spoke with about a quarter of SOCR’s current staff.
Surratt, Wheeler-Smith claimed, had informed him on February 7 that “a story would be coming out from Erica Barnett and that it was really bad.” Wheeler-Smith wrote that this was the first time he had heard of such a story, and that he was “flabbergasted” at this news.
In fact, I told Wheeler-Smith I was writing a story more than a week before he said Surratt contacted him. On January 29, I reached out to Wheeler-Smith directly and through SOCR’s communications staffer, Sage Leibenson, describing each of the allegations individually. I requested a phone or Zoom interview with Wheeler-Smith but said “email is fine” as an alternative, and I included dozens of detailed questions.
My email concluded, “‘I apologize for the voluminous number of questions in this email; however, I always think it’s better to put everything out there than for anyone to be blindsided by allegations or concerns that they were unaware of or would like the opportunity to respond to.”
After I received no response to that email, I sent the list of questions again on February 20, writing, “I’m following up on these questions. I’m planning to publish a story next week about the union’s request, on behalf of staff, for Director Wheeler-Smith to be removed for cause and the experiences described to me by staff, and I’m re-sending these questions to provide another opportunity to respond.” I never heard back.
In the email he sent Tuesday, Wheeler-Smith said he knew Surratt was “the source” for my story, because he had “made a rookie mistake. Generally, when someone can point to a story coming out, its author, and its contents—they were in fact the source. … It is devastating to learn that people in the Cabinet would work to coordinate such a piece going so far as to direct a few disgruntled staff—current and former—to the reporter.”
Surratt was not a source for the story. Wilson’s office did not respond to PubliCola’s questions on Tuesday.
Wheeler-Smith alleged that during their call on February 7, Surratt said he should resign or “things would ‘get really ugly’ for me.” Quoting a text message he sent Surratt, his complaint continued, “I am confident that an investigation will absolve me of any wrongdoing and I will be vindicated. I am in discussions with counsel about legal action to protect my character and reputation given the defamatory nature of the allegations.”
“I would urge [Human Resources investigators] and the City Council to redirect their energy from these baseless claims and examine why 50% of Black department heads have been relieved of their duties under this administration,” Wheeler-Smith wrote. “This alone signifies why I must stay and so must this Department.”
Wilson replaced two of Harrell’s seven Black department heads: former transportation department director Adiam Emery, who was previously Harrell’s deputy mayor, and Office of Immigrant and Refugee Affairs director Hamdi Mohamed, who spoke with PubliCola about her departure last month.