By Erica C. Barnett
The Seattle City Council, meeting as the budget committee, got through the most contentious part of the annual city budget—council amendments—on Monday, in a nearly 12-hour-long meeting that tested the council’s ability to put a polite face on some of its fundamental disagreements about how the city should spend its money.
The budget committee chair, Dan Strauss, could have broken up the meeting into two days, but declined to do so, noting at the beginning of the meeting that this would require the council to come back and meet again to vote the budget through as late as the Tuesday before Thanksgiving—the council’s longstanding practice prior to Strauss’ ascension to budget chair in 2024.
Under the schedule that has existed since 2024, the mayor proposes the budget on the fourth Tuesday in September (that part is unchanged) and the council passes a final budget two days before Thanksgiving, a schedule that reduces the time the council has to meet, deliberate, and make fixes in public by several days. This year, Strauss had planned to adopt every budget amendment, the most time-consuming and contentious part of the process, last Friday, almost two weeks before Thanksgiving.
I’ll cover some of these changes in an upcoming post after the budget passes, but for now, just know that the council approved most of its own new spending proposals from a $235,000-a-year “art wall” to $150,000 for Christmas decorations in Ballard that will include a statue of Jimothy, the meme raccoon, that’s supposed to last for the next 20 years. The council also preserved their own $1 million district transportation funds, which allow them to bypass city planning processes to fund projects they choose themselves, and directed the city to study a “sobering center” that would be redundant with the King County sobering center, currently located right across from City Hall and visible out the windows that face the council dais.
They agreed, though not unanimously, to pile on tens of millions of dollars in new, largely unsustainable spending, using purportedly one-time funds to fund new programs that will need more money again in one or two years. And they didn’t hesitate to earmark funds in order to bypass ordinary city processes—as with an amendment, from budget chair Dan Strauss, repurposing city funds to prevent pass-through traffic at a single intersection in Greenlake.
So it was unusual, and surprising, when one such earmark failed to pass: Dan Strauss’ proposal to direct funding from the just-passed Seattle Transit Measure toward far western Ballard, where Strauss lives, by either expanding service on King County Metro’s Route 17 Express or by bringing back the old Route 15 Express. Neither of these routes would be high-priority using the city’s equity- and demand-based prioritization matrix. Strauss has continually insisted that there is “no direct service” from downtown Seattle to Ballard, which isn’t true; however, direct service to the western edge of Ballard is limited after 6pm, inconveniencing people who live in this mostly single-family enclave.
On Monday, Strauss told his colleagues that if they supported more density in the Ballard Regional Center, they should support his amendment to expand transit service to western Ballard. “I wouldn’t bring this amendment if it wasn’t a regional growth center,” he said, adding, “I’m just looking for direct service between downtown Seattle and downtown Ballard. It should not take the amount of time as it takes to get to Tacoma.”
This claim is also incorrect; traveling from Seattle’s central business district to “downtown” Ballard (I mapped a route to the Tractor Tavern) takes about 35 minutes by bus, about 20 minutes less than getting from downtown to Tacoma on a Sound Transit Express bus. Getting to the neighborhood served by the 17 Express, which is many blocks to the northwest of central Ballard, does take longer, but most bus riders aren’t trying to get there—which is one reason Metro has ranked bus routes as higher priorities. Strauss’ amendment, which he sponsored by himself and originally tucked into a “chair’s package” of items he wanted to pass without debate, lost 6-3.
The council also rejected, on a 5-4 vote, a proposal from Dionne Foster that would require the council to produce a budget that’s balanced in all four years of its financial plan, not just the two-year budget. Strauss argued that because he had produced a proposal that is (or at least appears) balanced through 2030, there’s no need to impose any new requirements on the council. He also suggested it’s unfair that the mayor gets to write her budget “behind closed doors” over five months, while the council only
Under a ballot measure the council passed (and voters approved) last year, the mayor has to balance her budget for four years, but the council does not. (The measure imposed this requirement on the mayor for one year, but an amendment from Bob Kettle, which the council adopted right before rejecting Foster’s companion proposal, makes that mandate permanent).
“I believe it makes sense to hold ourselves to the same standard and to ensure that we are practicing the same kind of fiscal responsibility and sustainability that we are requiring from the executive,” Foster said before the vote.
Prior to this year, with Strauss as budget chair the council has passed budgets with nine-figure deficits beginning immediately after the two-year budget cycle, after piling on tens of millions of dollars to the “out-year” deficits established in the mayor’s budget.
Despite approving huge deficits as recently as last year, Strauss sounded affronted a the idea that he would ever do such a thing “What I would say is, I don’t need a law to do what’s right in this situation,” Strauss said. “I don’t need a law to tell me, or an executive order to tell me, how to do my job well. What I know is that we need to have these budgets balanced four years out. I think it’s a good idea.”
Opponents of Foster’s proposal argued it would put the council at a disadvantage, since the mayor has more time to create a budget and does so, as Strauss put it, “behind closed doors.”
Foster pointed out that the budget package Strauss proposed assumes $41 million in “one-time” expenses that are actually ongoing, which would result in an immediate deficit of around $58 million in 2029, right over the budget horizon. Put another way, if the council was not pretending that their proposals for ongoing spending will only be in place for one or two years, the budget would not be balanced for all four years. Budget tricks, once again, are creating an appearance of balance where there really is none. Mayor Wilson, through her budget office director Aly Pennucci, has said she’ll assume in her next budget that any one-time funds are truly one-time by Xing them out in future budgets, setting up a similar fight in the future.
The council also rejected a Foster proposal that would have used any funds the city manages to recover from overpayments that went to police officers this year to fund affordable housing. As we reported, police officers collectively received more than $13 million in lump-sum overpayments in June due to a miscalculation in how much officers were owed in retroactive pay. The police union has suggested they won’t repay the money until the city deals with separate payment issues related to the Workday payroll system.
Strauss amended Foster’s proposal to put oversight of the legislation into his own committee, finance and budget, instead of the housing committee, which Foster chairs. He also claimed he had no idea about the amendment and “learned about it on the dais,” which Foster quickly corrected: She submitted the amendment by the same deadline that every other amendment met, Then—after getting his way—Strauss killed the bill by voting “abstain,” which provided enough “no” votes to end the proposal. (Council members voted to abstain on budget amendments around a dozen times throughout the day).
The police overpayment money, if and when it’s recovered, will go into the general fund instead.

