Viva La Cola!

Founded in January 2009, PubliCola is a blog about Seattle written by journalists who are dedicated to non-partisan, original daily reporting that prioritizes a balanced approach to news. Started by longtime local editor and award-winning reporter Josh Feit, PubliCola is the first online-only news site in state history to get media credentials to cover the state capitol.

PubliCola was off and running. In June 2009, PubliCola hired another award-winning journalist, super-sourced Seattle city hall reporter Erica C. Barnett.

People were afraid that blogging would change journalism. Instead, we believe journalism can change blogging. Twenty-first century journalism may look and feel different, and yes Erica isn't afraid to get cranky, but we're committed to making sure online news still delivers independent, reliable, even-keeled coverage. And most of all, we're committed to making sure the coverage sparks honest civic debate.

Bringing you cola for the people, PubliCola is named after Publius Valerius PubliCola, the alias for the authors of the Federalist Papers—the original bloggers.

The first online-only news site in state history to get media credentials to cover the state capitol and Seattle city hall, PubliCola has been called a “must-read” by the Seattle Post Intelligencer and a hot “New Media Mover and Shaker” by Seattle Magazine—which also cited our own Erica C. Barnett as the city's No. 1 news nerd.

Within the Context of the Current Economic Downturn

1. As we’ve reported, the Washington State Board of Pharmacy is considering scaling back current guidelines which direct pharmacies to fill all legal prescriptions, including emergency contraception.

Oddly, after successfully defending the rules in court in the first round against a challenge from religious pharmacists, the board is thinking of lowering standards by allowing pharmacies to refer patients to other pharmacies if they don’t want to carry the medication.

This week, state Sen. Karen Keiser (D-33, Kent), chair of the Senate’s Health and Long Term Care Committee, sent a stern letter to pharmacy board chair, Gary Harris.

State Sen. Karen Keiser (D-33, Kent)

Here’s the letter in full:

Recently, the Board of Pharmacy (BOP) has embarked on a rule making process to possibly allow for the denial of filling valid, legal prescriptions in Washington State.  This rule is often referred to “refuse and refer.”  I am puzzled as to why the BOP would open this process at a time when there is a case in our courts concerning this issue.  I am also concerned about the manner in which this process was started, with little public notice, even after a rescheduling of the first proposed meeting.  The delay was approximately two business days, again not widely announced.

I would like to know specifically what events have led to this rushed process.  As you should know, the issue of pharmacy refusal is one that has been debated previously within the Legislature.  Also, the BOP itself has already ruled on this issue.  The 9th Circuit Court has issued two opinions, both supporting the original BOP rule.  With this matter still before the courts, this appears to be an ill-timed and ill-conceived action.  I would appreciate knowing what the reasons to justify this process are.

Additionally, I am concerned that the idea of “refuse and refer” is, in the cases of some medications, essentially “refuse.”  There are numerous medications that need to have prescriptions filled and taken in a timely manner.  Forcing a patient to go pharmacy shopping places not only an undue burden upon a patient but may, in effect, deny them the treatment which they need.  This policy would not be consistent with providing the best medical care for Washington residents.

I hope you will contact me to discuss this situation as soon as possible.

2. The Stranger posted an elaborate conspiracy theory yesterday about a minor post we’d done .

Making some incorrect and paranoid assumptions, Dominic Holden accused us of falsely claiming we had a scoop when we published the Washington Department of Transportation’s draft environmental impact statement (DEIS) on the deep bore tunnel late Wednesday night.

Our short post made no claims of being a scoop. Because it wasn’t one. The documents we published were already available from WSDOT on Wednesday. And the Stranger had published them Wednesday night before we did.

The Stranger—sounding like a stalker ex—monitored our RSS and Twitter feeds and accused us of going in and changing the time stamp on our post so it would appear as if we published the docs before they did. This is not true. The time stamp correctly showed when the post was written and saved as a draft—6:57 PM.

Here’s a screen shot that shows Erica uploading the WSDOT docs to PubliCola’s server between 6:45 PM and 6:49 PM on Wednesday while she was writing the brief post. (We got a copy of the WSDOT docs from a PubliCola reader who had done their own public records request for them, not—as Holden’s post implies—from the Stranger.)

After uploading the docs, Erica  finished the post and saved it without publishing. (She had a follow-up question for the tipster, and held off on posting until later—1:59 AM.)

Had Holden bothered to call us, we would have gladly told him the post went live on our site late that evening.

We were, in fact, unaware of the 6:57 time stamp. By Thursday, we were busy with that day’s stories, including Erica’s detailed analysis of the DEIS, which you can read here.

We called Stranger publisher Tim Keck last night after we read the paper’s PubliCola conspiracy theory, but he did not call us back.

3. Funding for the city’s human services department has increased consistently over the past six years, contradicting a statement by human-services advocate Dorry Elias, director of the Minority Executive Directors Coalition, that “When cuts have to be made, human services are always first.”

However, the city’s budget policy has, in recent years, explicitly stated that human services are the city’s top budget priority. For example: “Within the context of the current economic downturn, the Council establishes Public Safety and Human Services and Housing as its highest priorities,” legislation adopting the city’s 2009 budget priorities says. “In these difficult times, the City must continue to protect the health and safety of all Seattle’s residents, while at the same time providing essential assistance to the most needy among them.”

The only year in which funding for human services didn’t increase was 2005, when funding went from $113 million to $96 million. In 2006, human service funding went up $9 million; in 2007, it went up more than $13 million; in 2008, it went up $11 million; and in 2009, it went up $19 million.

4. Sightline’s Roger Valdez and the Downtown Seattle Association’s Jon Scholes mixed it up yesterday in Sightline’s comments thread over the so-called “head tax”—the tax on employers whose workers commute by single-occupancy vehicle that was overturned by the city earlier this year.

Valdez, a research associate at Sightline—a local the environmental think tank and blog—did a  post suggesting replacing the head tax with a payroll deduction on employees who drive alone to work, and using that money to pay for sidewalks, bike paths, and transit improvements. Scholes, a DSA lobbyist, argues that such a tax would hurt low-wage workers who have to commute from elsewhere to jobs in Seattle; Valdez responds, “I am so glad to see that the Downtown Seattle Association is taking on social justice issues. Does that mean a change of heart on panhandling legislation?”

It goes on from there.

5. Seattlecrime.com has a neat scoop: In a six-month-long sting called Operation Yellowjacket, the Seattle Police Department just rounded up 15 cab drivers that SPD officials say are responsible for fencing stolen goods in a downtown open-air market at the corner of Stewart St. and Sixth Ave., at a cab stand across the street from the Westin Hotel.

Cops described the cab stand as “an open air bazaar type situation,” with cabbies waiting at the stand to buy and sell stolen goods. Read killer crime reporter Jonah Spangenthal Lee’s whole story here.




  • ivan

    This is what you call “freaking out?” What a sorry lot you are.

  • http://twitter.com/LuigiGiovanni Luigi Giovanni

    Smoking pot causes some users to experience paranoia and hallucinations.

  • ty

    Erica's “detailed” analysis of this “Draft” of a Draft Environmental Impact Statement omits mentioning what we are looking at. Is this the “Second Supplemental DEIS” that is scheduled for release in Fall 2010?
    http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/Projects/Viaduct/eis.htm

    A number of EIS's are being done in this area and it would behoove someone doing “detailed” analysis (ahem) to point out precisely what is being analyzed, and furthermore to point out that the copies linked here in strikethrough are obviously working internal drafts.

  • http://43rddemocrats.org Michael M.

    It is absolutely incredulous that the Pharmacy Board is backing down like this. While I am absolutely opposed to forcing doctors to perform abortions, pharmacists are not doctors, and as such have a role that is simple: fill prescriptions based on the doctor's orders.

    A comparison, if you will –

    What would these people say if a phlebotomist who was Jehova's Witness refused to do a type and screen on a presurgical or emergency patient because it's against their belief system to transfuse a patient? Or a Medical Technologist refused to process the specimen?

    I know, it's not an apples to apples comparison, but the point is simple – pharmacists fill prescriptions, period. It is not their role to determine what people really do need, or to impose their beliefs on others. Access to contraception is a right, and access to emergency contraception is a way to prevent abortions (which everyone believes is a laudable goal).

  • MVH

    A link to an online public document constitutes a “scoop?” Hold the presses!

  • Matt_the_Engineer

    @2 Funny, when I read the post here I was wondering why you didn't just link to the Slog, who had been detailing their back-and-forth with the state getting this document. I didn't imagine this was an independant effort. Doesn't the Publicola reader want credit?

  • ericacbarnett

    It was sent off the record, but they're more than welcome to comment here. The state made the document publicly available to anyone who wanted to read it on Thursday afternoon; I don't know, but would imagine, that lots of people requested it. Records requests and threats of injunctions are pretty routine stuff (I filed three this week, for example), not the high drama they were represented as being elsewhere.

  • tpn

    I wish that the writers would take as much care analyzing the DEIS, as they did trying to prove that the Stranger et al is a crazy stalking ex.

  • http://sciencevsromance.net joshc

    I think the screenshot shows when the files were uploaded; I hope it wasn't actually taken while uploading them to the server.

    Otherwise that would reflect a pretty odd habit of continuously taking screenshots of every interaction with the server just in case they're needed to fend off wild accusations.

  • Jakers

    Pretty decent argument that swayed my thinking (swayed, but I'm still undecided).

    As I ponder my position, I think of two opposing concepts that I hold to be true:

    1) Conscientious objectors should be given the option of civil service when a draft is imposed.
    2) The executioner is not involved in the decision to execute and so holds absolutely no guilt if the judge and jury finds an innocent person guilty of a crime punishable by death per state law.

    So on one hand, I think that the pharmacist should be able to refer a patient to someone else, but on the other, they have no guilt if the person using only one very very small aspect of their profession (cause surely no one is a full time executioner in our state and thus someone has to do it under 'other duties as assigned”) decides to end a pregnancy with a prescription from a doctor which is allowed under state law.

  • Jakers

    Public agencies constantly try to make public documents the least public as possible and so I would count it as a scoop, albeit small.

  • Jakers

    I kind of thought the same thing, which led me to believe that something else is up with this whole story. But then I realized it just wasn't worth my time to thing about something so stupid.

  • http://twitter.com/VoteSizemore Scott Sizemore

    Come on, guys, don't fight. We're still not out of the proverbial woods yet, and if you guys keep bickering we'll all be eaten by bears. I'm not sure where the bears fit into this metaphor, I assume it's either economic ruin or general despair. Do you want that, Publicola or Stranger? Do you want us to be eaten by the despair bears?

  • http://43rddemocrats.org Michael M.

    And there is the important part of the equation – Emergency Contraception (EC) is not something that ends pregnancy. At its most basic level, what it does is induces menstruation. If there is fertilization and implantation, the embryo remains. I believe there is a very minor chance that a fertilized egg would be, for lack of a better term, flushed out, but it is not akin whatsoever to abortion, or to RU-486 (the abortion pill).

    If I remember the controversial rule correctly (and I'm sure ECB would know this better than I), it allowed for a pharmacist to not dispense, but only if there was another pharmacist in the same pharmacy willing to dispense.

    It's bad enough that the state allows for some hospitals to deny EC to women who have just been raped (Catholic hospitals don't have to), which makes some communities, Everett, for example (which only has two hospitals, and both are Catholic) have reduced access to EC. Allowing this to go a step further, and deny access from people who have no business making health care choices for women, or have any business being involved in the health care decision making process, is incredulous.

  • Guest

    Name one other injunction threat that wasn't big news?

  • ericacbarnett

    Police reporters, in particular, get injunction threats all the time.

  • ericacbarnett
  • Jakers

    I'm undecided on if EC counts as ending a pregnancy or not, but either way, it definitely should be available to rape victims by force of law.

  • David B.

    Hi Josh – The screen shot was taken last night showing what time the files were originally uploaded. We're not sitting here taking a screen grab every time we link a new file to one of the posts.

    The screen shot is only provided to clear up any confusion about what time the DEIS files were in PubliCola's hands.

    Hopefully that helps clear up any confusion!

  • http://43rddemocrats.org Michael M.

    Again, I'm only citing medical fact of how it works (I spent years working in health care, the first few in reproductive health care, prior to the legal field). For the slim possibility that a fertilized egg may be “flushed”, the question of what you believe – does pregnancy begin at fertilization or at implantation – is very valid and definitely comes into play. I've seen this a very difficult question for some of my more conservative friends (who are pro-life, but support EC) to grapple with, and I do not envy people that have to reconcile that question with their personal moral and religious beliefs.

  • http://sciencevsromance.net joshc

    That makes sense. I think it was just a matter of usage.

  • Algernon

    Does anyone other than a journalist (and a publisher) care who gets a story first? Of course a writer wants a deserves credit, but this nonsense of “we got it a few hours before you did” is childs' play. Squabbling between publications is sometimes amusing, and I suppose that if one publication changed some time stamp to look like it got a scoop is worthy of a very small mention because it addresses credibility. But even defending yourself is pointless, although perhaps difficult to resist. The Stranger (which I read, enjoy and respect) does have a silly history of attacking the competition, namely The Weekly. The Stranger has cut that back measurably, perhaps because it realizes that The Weekly is, simply, dull, but when it was happening it was so…college newspaperish?

  • Jeff Welch

    Erica Barnett swipe a story from another blog? Heaven forbid. A journalist of her high caliber and staunch work ethic would NEVER take such a shortcut. Heaven forbid. Boo. Perish the thought.

  • Josh Feit

    How does defending ourselves implicate PubliCola in juvenile “squabbling?”

    Without contacting us—Dominic went ahead and reported a make believe theory about PubliCola. That's the juvenile part.

    We provided the facts about what happened.

  • seabos84

    c'mon ivan – how can they peddle their phony creds as moderate or independent if they don't repeat right wing lies over, and over, and over … as their “reporting”.

    How would they report an atheist biology teacher refusing to teach kids who are Christian who believe in … whatever.

    this entire “issue” is a complete crock pushed by fanatics pushing their beliefs down everyone else's throats. IF they want to open a business which discriminates, maybe they should open a private club or their own church, instead of a pharmacy -

    BUT, we got erica & josh “reporting” by repeating lies, so this complete crock issue lives longer than it should.

    rmm.

  • Barleywine

    The main thing here is that to the reader this is lame.

    To the “parties” involved, it may be business as usual.
    No different than a family member involved in a nasty break-up. Meaningful as hell to them, but lame to the rest of the family.

  • Barleywine

    Jakers, I like that you wrestle with this; but I have a little problem with your thinking that the pharmacist (or the executioner) is some kind of monkey “and so holds absolutely no guilt”
    We all hold guilt, and are responsible for our own actions.

    Or we need to back off of Osama's driver. Or any tired Nazi reference.

  • Barleywine

    Again you rock, with all your common sense. F.U.

    I've been a Med Tech for lots of years and never been faced with a moral decision like those pharmacists, and I bow down to them who will not bow down.

  • Barleywine

    My humble opinion:
    “Pregnancy” begins at implantation. “Life” begins at conception.

    Parenthood begins…when the parents realize they aren't all that.
    And that may never occur.

  • The Information

    #2.

    Publicola and SLOG are going at each other's jugulars because they know only one propped up “blog” can be the party press organ for all of City Hall's wheeler dealer schemes like the Tunnel.

    Both blogs are mouthpieces for the high density, transit, super tax crew that wrecked Seattle in the last ten years. Only one can survive….

  • http://www.joeszilagyi.com/ Joe Szilagyi

    THERE CAN BE ONLY ONE.

  • RLP

    Some food for thought on this issue:

    http://www.helium.com/items/1512962-pharmacists…

  • Guest

    What's “the Stranger”?

  • Guest

    Seriously, who even reads that paper anymore? Dan Savage gets mad that people actually leave the shitty paying jobs he gives them to go and try to make their own way and then get's all bitchy about it. Why does he have to be such a sore loser instead of supporting people who gave him so much of their talent and hard work for years? What is wrong with Dominic always getting pissy with Publicola? I mean besides he is a terrible reporter. Anyway who works at City Hall knows that Erica is there working the beat 24/7. It's disapointing that the Stranger has decided to get pissy with Josh & Erica rather than taking the high road and supporting these folks in their venture. Publicola fills a huge gap in the news. I got so tired of having to slog through all the crap on the SLOG to read what I wanted to read…local, city hall type news.

  • Barleywine

    I may have been misunderstood:

    I am in no way pro-life.
    I can't stand fetuses, especially when they get to that “no, no, no”, “mine, mine” stage. That peanut-buttery fingerprints all over everything stage.

    I don't particullary care where the line is drawn, but for God's sake please snuff 'em before that stage. Yucky.

    I support anyone who gives their free time to anything they support, including Pro-Life, NARAL, NAMBLA, PETA. Whatever.
    God love 'em all.