Viva La Cola!

Founded in January 2009, PubliCola is a blog about Seattle written by journalists who are dedicated to non-partisan, original daily reporting that prioritizes a balanced approach to news. Started by longtime local editor and award-winning reporter Josh Feit, PubliCola is the first online-only news site in state history to get media credentials to cover the state capitol.

PubliCola was off and running. In June 2009, PubliCola hired another award-winning journalist, super-sourced Seattle city hall reporter Erica C. Barnett.

People were afraid that blogging would change journalism. Instead, we believe journalism can change blogging. Twenty-first century journalism may look and feel different, and yes Erica isn't afraid to get cranky, but we're committed to making sure online news still delivers independent, reliable, even-keeled coverage. And most of all, we're committed to making sure the coverage sparks honest civic debate.

Bringing you cola for the people, PubliCola is named after Publius Valerius PubliCola, the alias for the authors of the Federalist Papers—the original bloggers.

The first online-only news site in state history to get media credentials to cover the state capitol and Seattle city hall, PubliCola has been called a “must-read” by the Seattle Post Intelligencer and a hot “New Media Mover and Shaker” by Seattle Magazine—which also cited our own Erica C. Barnett as the city's No. 1 news nerd.

Seattle Cops Must Earn Our Respect. And They’re Not.

KIRO TV released a new video Friday morning of two officers assaulting an innocent man. One officer used racial language during the assault, saying he would “beat the fucking Mexican piss out of you, homey.” Officers were responding to a complaint about an armed robbery in the parking lot of the China Harbor restaurant at around 2 in the morning April 17; the victims told dispatchers the men appeared to be Hispanic.

The video shows the two officers repeatedly kicking the man in the head as he lay on the concrete, then letting him go after confirming he was not the suspect.

The incident comes at a time when many of our political leaders are proposing ordinances that expand police powers, ostensibly to make the city more “livable” and safe. These sorts of laws usually address real problems (for example, I supported City Council member Tim Burgess’ proposed panhandling law), but many Seattleites oppose them because they fear police bias or outright abuse. I myself have made this argument in the past, when I opposed new rules governing nightlife. This latest incident just confirms for me that those fears are justified.

Law and order proponents constantly say the citizens of Seattle should show more respect for our police. And I agree with them. Our police do a very difficult, very important, and often very dangerous job. But to get this respect, SPD needs to earn it. Police have a lot of power. And with more power comes greater responsibility. When the department acts responsibly, they will get the respect they want.

Unfortunately, over and over, we see SPD officers abuse their power with no consequences. If a group of friends and I attacked an unarmed cop who was innocently strolling down the street, we’d be prosecuted and harshly punished. But does anyone think the officers involved in this current incident will be prosecuted? It’s an old story, one we hear far too often, and one that no one seems to be doing anything about.

We need stronger citizen oversight of the police. We need it now. The police union, the department itself, and our politicians have proven they are not qualified to control the bad cops.

So while the city considers proposals to add police and give them expanded powers, they must hold cops  to higher standards, with better oversight and increased punishment for cops who abuse their powers (and those who witness abuse without acting).

And let’s get a new chief who will not only address the problem of crime on the streets, but also take a hard look at crime within the department. Then the police will get the respect they desire, and the politicians will be able to pass new ordinances without so much outcry from citizens concerned with fairness and social justice because they justifiably fear police abuse.




  • justagurlinseattle

    WELL put David.. VERY well put….

  • gogetthempete

    >>>In a statement, Mayor Mike McGinn said: “I watched the video and found it disturbing. Chief (John) Diaz has informed me that SPD and the Office of Professional Accountability are investigating the incident. We won't have any further statement until that process is complete.”<<<

    So don't worry, the Police are investigating themselves, and as always, that's sure to get to the truth.

    This will be a great test for new City Attorney Pete Holmes, who was opposed by the Police Guild in his run for office, mostly due to his strong service as head of the OPA. Will his strong advocacy for better policing continue, or will he back down now that he's in office.

  • seandr

    Well argued, Dave, and I agree with you.

    However, I think reform becomes more salable to cops and their supporters if the proposals include reward as well punishment incentives. To date, we've focused on punishment and gotten nothing. Maybe a new chief can change that, but I suspect any serious reform would be quickly followed by a no-confidence vote from the union. The fact is, Seattle simply doesn't have to power to punish its unionized officers, even if it does have the will.

    However, we do have the power to offer financial incentives for good performance, and the city should try to negotiate them into the union contract. If the union balks at meritocracy, however, external agencies can be set up to provide honorary prizes to officers with clean records (e.g., $20,000 for 5 years with a clean record).

    I think rewards are more appropriate, anyway. Police work is a tough job, and it would be very easy to lose your cool on occasion. The cop who can deal with all that BS calmly is truly remarkable and should be recognized as such.

  • Norte Americano

    We need to deport this cop back to Ireland or Sweden or wherever the fuck this cop's folks came from.

    this cop is not American, and does not get our values. Que vaya!

  • Meinert

    Seandr – agreed, and I should have included that. Though I believe it's both – reward the good cops and harshly punish the bad ones. And yes, we need a better contract with the Union.

  • giffy

    Officers like this should be immediately fired and prosecuted. No second chances, no counseling, nothing. Just remove them from the force and be done with it.

    That more than any outreach, or oversight committees, or townhalls would help restore confidence in the police.

    Its a few bad actors in an otherwise great police force, but the actions of bad cops are covered-up or ignored it brings down the whole force.

  • Soapboxin'

    This is case in point why McGinn, and liberals like him (including myself) resist the temptation to cowtow to the law-and-order crowd that always advocates for more cops.
    -
    Nickels promised more cops – when the economy was good – out of political expediency. It allowed him to counter the accusation that he was all about big picture, save the world stuff. Maverick-y Mike McSandbag doesn't play that way.

  • Anc

    There is a reason people have little to no respect for cops, b/c cops have little to no respect for the people. Combined with power, shit like this is bound to happen.

  • Larry E

    Let's be careful about indicting ALL cops by the actions of a few.

  • morning fizzy

    I believe Holmes has already taken the police review board to court for overturning the Chief's discipline ruling on the lying cop.

    I have no doubt that Holmes will support the Chief and the OPA if they discipline these cops, and they should.

    I believe that criminal charges would not fall on the city attorney.

  • morning fizzy

    Are you kidding? Reward cops for not being thugs? They average about $100,000 a year, isn't that reward enough?

    If you add a financial reward, they will just make sure they use rubber hoses outside of video range.

  • bobbydee

    Sean: Rewards won't work either. They walk away now with no dicipline. They will continue to stick together so as not to lose their bonus.

  • seandr

    Ok, Morning Fizzy, what's your strategy for forcing stricter punishment on the police force, joining hands and singing kumbaya?

    Whether you realize it not, this city (like most cities) has limited power to make its police force do what it doesn't want to do, at least as long as they are unionized. They don't want stricter punishments. We don't want a strike.

    As for the $100,000 average, my point is that the recent pay hikes should have been conditional on performance. Rewards are the best leverage we have, and we just gave it away without getting anything in return.

    P.S. In my proposal, if the citizen who gets beat up off camera complains, no reward.

  • seandr

    Cops are people. People are greedy. Greedy likes money.

    If the rewards are granted by a citizen committee based on number of complaints, regardless of whether they are substantiated by SPD internal investigations, I don't see how or why cops would screw their best performers out of a big chunk of cash.

    And I can definitely imagine a cop keeping this money in mind as he decides whether its worth taking his frustrations out on someone.

    And to be clear, I'm not saying we should do away with punishment, I'm just doubtful that it will ever be sufficiently effective given the inherent power of the police over the city.

  • N8

    All Hispanics probably look the same to this officer.

    If the robbery victim reported that it was four white guys, would they have stopped all small groups of white guys in the area and threaten to beat the fucking [American] piss out of them?

  • Unknown

    I hope all the cops that were standing by watching and did nothing to stop their “homey” cop, are also reprimanded. This type of action is no different than the family members who stood by Clemmons.

  • http://twitter.com/fattailed fattailed

    FYI, it is against the law here and i believe in every state for police to go on strike. The fear of police unions is the fear of the organized armed Right, it's nit about labor law.

  • http://twitter.com/fattailed fattailed

    … And about wanting to kick all Latino-looking seattleites based on suspicions about one. Hey wait, that's exactly what happened!

  • dorsolplants

    Two wrongs don't make a right

  • seandr

    Thanks for that fact about strikes. What do you mean by “fear of the organized armed Right”?

    Perhaps I'm overestimating the power of the unions, but if that's so, what else can explain why police reform has been so elusive, even in liberal cities where basic accountability measures are generally quite popular?

  • dorsolplants

    A good start would be increasing the amount of Anti-Racism trainings that the Seattle Police receive. Other parts of the country provide a decent bit more training on subjects such as Racial Profiling. Not the complete solution but an essential first one that's long overdue.

  • jefe

    I have an example – King County Corrections Guild spearheading an initiative to reduce the County Council from 13 to 9 members (which eventually passed). They are not cops, but have you seen the number of Directors the King County Department of Adult and Juvenile Detention has gone through in the past few years? Coincidence?

    Remember that cops have enormous discretion over who they arrest and who they do not.

  • http://deadcatsbounce.blogspot.com Gomez

    “So don't worry, the Police are investigating themselves, and as always, that's sure to get to the truth.”

    Ahahahaha… like with that cop who assaulted an innocent black man for no reason and not only kept his job but got PROMOTED?

  • Education Reformer

    Here's a really effective anti racism training program:

    Sue the crap out of this cop and any who stood by watching for racial discrimination violation of civil rights and assault, so that they lose their (i) bank accounts (ii) cars (iii) good names (iv) careers and (v) houses.
    This will also break up their marriages.

    The net impact will be a tremendously educational experience for any other racist cops out there.

  • East Coast Cynic

    Seattle needs a long overdue Mollen Commission styled investigation of Police misconduct. Its seems like whenever there is an incident of local Police abuse of a citizen, the department settles out of court with minimal or no penalty to the officer (and in some cases, a promotion of the officer, i.e., the Alley-Barnes beating).

  • seandr

    I take your point – the onlookers were indeed complicit.

    But the cop didn't gunning these kids down like Clemmons did. I have to believe, perhaps naively, that if he did, the others would intervene, or at least testify against him if intervention wasn't possible.

  • Barleywine

    I am so happy to see all the comments here.

    In the Rainier Valley (I won't mention the Crime Council, 'cause I've done that) there is a Crime Council that has such a cozy relationship with SPD it's scary.
    As I see it, they hipe the crime there and call loudly for more police, and the police then take care of the business owners and developers that make up the council. It's been written about (neighborhood policing) as at first a success, then a dismal failure. Search Amazon (or better, Google Books) for books specifically about the Seattle experiment.
    They even have their own disgruntled South Seattle Cop that gives both good insider info, and support for the old, failed system. But to him the failed system is the bastards downtown that sent him to South. Oh, the crowd loves him. He'd support the officers in this story.

    Right now they are using “crime” as an excuse to take prime Columbia City property from Angie's tavern, an old-school minority (mostly black) hangout. And lately Jumbo's Chinese restaurant, which happens to be in a building that also hosts raves. They want it for a Trader Joe's. Good location and parking.

    So much has already been said about the police, mostly good officers & a few untouchable bad ones. But I wanted to add that this particular group supports bringing Anne Kirkpatrick from Spokane as our next police chief, so be warned.

    They are not NIMBYs. They are something far, far more frightening. They are people desperately hoping to increase (or at least not lose) political power, at any cost. And they hate all the damn liberals.

  • Meinert

    Interesting and sad that not one political leader came out with even a statement about this today, other than the mayor saying the SPD was investigating itself. Where is the public outcry over an obvious case of racially motivated police brutality? Where are the politicians who want citizens to act responsibly but don't seem to hold officers to the same standards? The silence is painful. No wonder the Police don't feel the need to change, there is a vacuum in our city's leadership.

  • East Coast Cynic

    Either too many native seattlites on the city council used to looking the other way, or the cops have dirt on some council members.

  • Barleywine

    “Where is the public outcry”

    Good news and bad news:
    Good news is that the public outcry is right here.
    Bad news is, like the homeless thing and everything else, it's all just a soundbite. Another story is a-coming.

  • Farmer Ted

    ” that it was four white guys”

    well, how often does that happen in Seattle…once a year?

  • Farmer Ted

    Oh please, they barely touched the guy. Don't get hysterical ladies.

  • Farmer Ted

    Keep the tinfoil on tight.

  • Farmer Ted

    I respect the cops…but then again, I'm not a criminal.

  • Barleywine

    I wish it were just a wild conspiracy theory. But it's a conspiracy.

    Spent the last few years connecting dots, and I've narrowed it to it's source. One sad MFr.

  • giffy

    I don't know. I think you have to not hire or keep racists on the force. Some guy who is not a fan of Hispanics is not going to be swayed by some training.

    But then I have yet to see anti racism or anti harassment training that was worth much of anything to anyone other than the people paid to put on the training.

  • Donolectic

    Oh, by criminal, you must mean “white” because apparently the “mexican” “homey” who got his his head kicked in wasn't a criminal either.

  • Donolectic

    You're a charmer aren't you.

  • kam26

    Very good article. I perhaps naively assumed that there was not that much prejudice in Seattle toward Hispanics or at least that it would not lead to violence against innocent people. This incident points out how dangerous things can get. This is not an incident or situation that should be shoved under the rug.

  • kam26

    Actually, I liked your article, but as of this writing, Councilman O'Brien has come out with a statement (at least on Facebook), which is what led me to your article. Still, as citizens, we have to protest this incident and anything similar really loudly.

  • Meinert

    It's definitely great to see O'Brien come out on this issue. I hope he looks into why it took two weeks for Diaz to take this cop off the street and start the investigation. The Department knew about this incident long before it was made public. Does the SPD only “investigate” police abuse when it's made public?

  • sarah68

    A statement on Facebook? That's just great. He could have done so to Publicola; he could have done so to the on-line Seattle P-I or the Times, or to TV stations. But no, to Facebook, which most people over 40 (and most people ARE over 40) don't exactly obsessively track.

  • Meinert

    actually on Facebook and his Council blog. – http://obrien.seattle.gov/2010/05/08/sad-day-fo…

  • West Coaster

    please don't categorize naive Seattleites with such a broad brush, mr. east coaster. There's lots of highly sohpisticated people here and on our city council, and in fact, being naive is a virtue; we're not so cynical.

  • morning fizzy

    The Stranger links to a longer version of the video, which makes it clear that the cops knew the video was being shot by the end of the tape. They knew this was coming out before the reports were filed.

    Has Publicola or anyone received the incident reports?

  • Barleywine

    Wasn't just the one “Mexican homey” guy, but also a woman who kicked him. I'm all for equality in the workplace, but jeez…
    Guess she'll be promoted, too.

    My nephew went through all the education and training to be a cop, then decided that he just couldn't work with them. For some reason he had moral problems with it and just couldn't develope the ability to kick the s–t out of an innocent person (or a guilty person, for that matter).
    What a wuss.

  • kam26

    To Sarah68,

    Not to be repetitive, but O'Brien made a statement on his Council Blog, which was linked to Facebook. I personally saw it because of Facebook, which is not O'Brien's fault (and I am definitely over 40, by the way).

  • ratcityreprobate

    I have wondered from time to time if steroid use could be a factor in these incidents. I can imagine that officers in high stress units may feel a need to bulk up for self protection and turn to steroids with bad consequences. That is just speculation on my part as I have tried to figure out why these incidents occur with some regularity.

  • sarah68

    I'll be pilloried for making such a stereotypical remark, but possibly people who are attracted to being policemen (and I mean men) especially want to be physically strong and so may be tempted by steroids. I don't know whether steroids increase other types of emotionality besides anger–for instance, crying during public apologies. I'm really sick of seeing guys who do awful things crying when they're caught or convicted.

  • http://spifflines.blogspot.com/ John Bailo

    Was the victim here legally?

  • PoliticalComedy

    I wonder how they do things in Arizona.

  • morning fizzy

    What difference would it make? He wasn't stopped or arrested for being here illegally and even if he had been, that wouldn't excuse the behavior.

    Please, Mr. Bailo, show us your papers.

  • morning fizzy

    Think the female cop was on steroids too?

  • http://spifflines.blogspot.com/ John Bailo

    Well, was he?

  • Sinic

    Did Ofc Cobane really cry? Anyone see any tears? Or is he just a great actor too?

  • morning fizzy

    I don't know or care if he is a citizen, holds a green card, is here illegally or is a replicant in relationship to this incident.

    He was released by the police and not to the INS.

    As has recently been in the news, no one is required to show the police ID in WA if they are not arrested.

    Are we sure Cobane is here legally?

  • http://spifflines.blogspot.com/ John Bailo

    So, you're saying that this criminal should have been released even though he violated the law by being in the country illegally?

    http://www.bizjournals.com/phoenix/stories/2010…

    “A national poll shows 59 percent of Americans support Arizona’s controversial new immigration law.”

  • jboogy

    Seattle and Washington state as a whole are racists. you're cops did not surprise anyone outside this state when they carried out this fiasco…..as a matter of fact, the other 48 states (Alaska is like you) see Cobain carrying out the will of the people.

  • tvguide

    There should be no room in the SPD for officers that discredit the whole force, which is mostly made up of very good people.

  • fount

    How is it that you can call this person a criminal?

    You're assuming every latino is automatically here illegally? And if they are here illegally, our laws regarding treatment of suspects don't apply to them?

    You'd be pretty comfortable in a dictatorship, I imagine. Whatever the strike force says is law, is law.

  • sarah68

    Tiresome strawman arguments, J.B.

  • http://www.joeszilagyi.com/ Joe Szilagyi

    “what's your strategy for forcing stricter punishment on the police force, joining hands and singing kumbaya?”

    Civilian oversight boards that have the power to hand disciplinary issues directly to an elected 3rd party to bring criminal charges: the City Attorney, and public record all disciplinary investigations at their conclusion. If the cops are clean they'll have zero problem with this. If the union tries to fight this you step over them. This is a legal and legislative matter, not something for the police to decide. Everyone has to be answerable to 3rd parties. The police should have no–NONE–input on who gets onto the oversight board.

    Cop breaks the law, they get their legal bell rung. Being a cop cannot offer a single piece of legal protection that a regular citizen would not enjoy or it's ripe for risk. They do a shitty job, and 99.9% of them 99.9% of them do it fantastically. They should be all for something like this, because it would benefit them heavily. Vindicated on bullshit charges? It's published and you're cleared for the world to know.

    At the same time, if you bring bullshit charges AGAINST the cops, you need to legally penalize that–again, legislative. You close the open circuits on both ends.

  • http://www.joeszilagyi.com/ Joe Szilagyi

    I posted this above, but here it is. Thoughts?

    Civilian oversight boards that have the power to hand disciplinary issues directly to an elected 3rd party to bring criminal charges: the City Attorney, and public record all disciplinary investigations at their conclusion. If the cops are clean they'll have zero problem with this. If the union tries to fight this you step over them. This is a legal and legislative matter, not something for the police to decide. Everyone has to be answerable to 3rd parties. The police should have no–NONE–input on who gets onto the oversight board.

    Cop breaks the law, they get their legal bell rung. Being a cop cannot offer a single piece of legal protection that a regular citizen would not enjoy or it's ripe for risk. They do a shitty job, and 99.9% of them 99.9% of them do it fantastically. They should be all for something like this, because it would benefit them heavily. Vindicated on bullshit charges? It's published and you're cleared for the world to know.

    At the same time, if you bring bullshit charges against the cops, you need to legally penalize that to 'reward' the people abusing the system–again, legislative. You close the open circuits on both ends.

  • http://www.joeszilagyi.com/ Joe Szilagyi

    This is some of the most fail trolling I've seen in quite some time. Well done.

  • http://www.joeszilagyi.com/ Joe Szilagyi

    “A national poll shows 59 percent of Americans support Arizona’s controversial new immigration law.”

    Something like 60% of the people think that evolutionary science is fake and that God created the dinosaur skeletons exactly 5,000 years ago as Easter eggs for 17th-21st century scientists to discover.

    300 years ago about 59% of Americans probably thought Blacks were better off in chains.

    Whats your point?

  • Barleywine

    From Cris Stephan, 2/19/10 on Seattle Transit Blog:
    “Because Pat Murakami, Ray Akers, the “Save our Valley” crowd, and John Fox want to turn everything into a debate about concurrency, environmental impact, etc. They don’t want any change in SE Seattle at all.”

    From the Arai Jackson Ellison Murakami website:
    “AJEM was the prime consultant and architect for Sound Transit for the Link Light Rail stations in Rainier Valley in South East Seattle along Martin Luther King, Jr. Way.”

    Chris doesn't mention the “architect” of the anti-density, anti-change crowd in South Seattle. But the next time you get your mouth stuffed with mercury fillings, you can thank him.
    The anti-density thing is just to protect that small group from finally getting light shined on them. They want dense cover, and I really can't blame them for that.

    This is the same group that successfully kept Casa Latina out of our neighborhood. Beat the Mexican piss out of them.

  • http://twitter.com/LuigiGiovanni Luigi Giovanni
  • mathewrenndawgrenner

    The Cops have my respect because they are the good guys 99% of the time. A couple of bad cops does not change it for me.

  • East Coast Cynic

    I said native (as in native born), not naive. However, some of the council members may naively assume that there are no structural problems with the SPD.

  • Smartlatina

    @ Farmer
    did you mean how often does it happen that four white guys attack people in Seattle?

    and if it would have been a gay guy being beaten, I think there would be more public response.

    I met very good SPD officers and I'm hoping they learn from this experience and realize that they too are subject to the laws that govern us.

  • Why

    Hey Seattle, you police your own city…you got it! enjoy the neighboorhood.

  • http://maverickmoneymakersreview.ws/ Maverick Money Makers Review

    i think it is so great site!