Viva La Cola!

Founded in January 2009, PubliCola is a blog about Seattle written by journalists who are dedicated to non-partisan, original daily reporting that prioritizes a balanced approach to news. Started by longtime local editor and award-winning reporter Josh Feit, PubliCola is the first online-only news site in state history to get media credentials to cover the state capitol.

PubliCola was off and running. In June 2009, PubliCola hired another award-winning journalist, super-sourced Seattle city hall reporter Erica C. Barnett.

People were afraid that blogging would change journalism. Instead, we believe journalism can change blogging. Twenty-first century journalism may look and feel different, and yes Erica isn't afraid to get cranky, but we're committed to making sure online news still delivers independent, reliable, even-keeled coverage. And most of all, we're committed to making sure the coverage sparks honest civic debate.

Bringing you cola for the people, PubliCola is named after Publius Valerius PubliCola, the alias for the authors of the Federalist Papers—the original bloggers.

The first online-only news site in state history to get media credentials to cover the state capitol and Seattle city hall, PubliCola has been called a “must-read” by the Seattle Post Intelligencer and a hot “New Media Mover and Shaker” by Seattle Magazine—which also cited our own Erica C. Barnett as the city's No. 1 news nerd.

Why Don’t More Women Ride?

This was originally posted on Friday.

Significantly fewer women ride bikes than men. It’s a subject I’ve touched on (very briefly) before, but it bears further exploration.

An article in October’s Scientific American reported that men outnumber women cyclists 2-to-1 in America—a fact the writers attribute in large part to cycling infrastructure. They argue that if there were more protected or separated bike lanes running through cities (and not just along waterways and green spaces) more women would ride.

Some local cycling advocates, however, say that infrastructure is just a small slice of the problem and that things like secure bike parking and appropriate equipment play much larger roles in keeping women from using bikes as transportation.

As I guy, I bring a pretty limited perspective as to what’s keeping women off bikes. So I posed the question to Every Day, commute specialist with the Bicycle Alliance of Washington. Day, a bike commuter for more than 20 years, teaches workshops on safe commuting, basic repairs, and proper equipment selection. She says that the conventional wisdom that a lack of bike lanes or trails poses a significant barrier is no more true for women than men. In her view, the number one reason more women don’t cycle is a lack of safe, secure bike parking.

“Imagine you’re a woman on the UW campus going to unlock your bike in a dark area of campus at night,” says Day. “Whether it’s just perception or not, women feel more vulnerable. Bikes feel more vulnerable.”

Day says she’s “by no means saying that women are afraid of bicycling.” But bicycling for transportation means riding at all hours of the day, in all weather, which often means that the beginning and end of the ride is going to involve locking up your bike on a dark street or in a dark parking lot.

To address the issue of secure bike parking (for both bicyclists and their bikes), Bike Alliance introduced the Bike Station (recently rebranded the Bike Port) in 2003. It’s an indoor bike storage facility in Pioneer Square a block north of King Street Station that can be accessed 24/7 by key card.

Instead of standing in the dark and rain, commuters can enter the locked Bike Port, change at their leisure, and use the bathroom in comfort and safety. There are bathrooms, lockers, basic tools and a work stand, and a vending machine stocked with emergency repair supplies. It costs $100 per year ($10 a month, or $2 a day) to use the facility.

The number two impediment for women, Day says, is finding equipment that fits and suits their needs. Until recently, major manufacturers put little to no effort into designing bikes for women. Because the majority of a woman’s height is typically in her legs, riding a bike designed for a man often means being stretched beyond comfort in the upper body. Riding a saddle designed for a man (women’s saddles are often wider to accommodate wider hips and have cut outs to accommodate “soft tissue”) has caused serious discomfort as well for many of the women cyclists I know.

Fortunately, bike fit is significantly less of an issue than it was even five years ago. Some of the biggest companies in the industry—like Trek, Giant, and Specialized—have introduced women-specific versions of their road, mountain, and commuter bikes.

But getting people onto the right bike is still a huge issue. A skinny-tired road bike and a backpack might work fine for commuting to the office (though there are better options out there), but it can’t rival a car for running errands around town and dropping the kids off at school (and the dozen other places parents have to chauffeur their children every week). Day says cargo and electric-assist bikes are key to the viability of bikes as transportation. Cargo bikes give you room to  pick up a week’s worth of groceries and the kids. And electric-assist bikes use a battery-powered motor to help you up hills. Day says that sore joints and muscles are major concerns for many of the older women she talks to at events.

Groups like Cascade Bicycle Club and Bicycle Alliance offer plenty of classes that are open to everyone, but there are few women-specific classes. The Bikery in the Central District occasionally offers a class called Basic Bike Maintenance for Women, Gender Queer, and Trans Folk. Their website says the class is for “people who are looking for an intentional alternative to the traditionally male dominated bike-shop environment.”

Nationally, the Association of Pedestrian and Bicycle Professionals is  working on a project trying to figure out how to get more women into cycling as part of their broader effort to “change transportation culture.”

A major component of the APBP’s early effort is a survey for women and girls that they’re conducting through May 15. As such, the questions focus heavily on women’s experiences riding on streets, their interactions with cars, and their comfort on bike trails vs. bike lanes. But it also includes questions about other provisions women might want (in the office, around town) to make cycling easier. The APBP says the aim of the survey is to give engineers, city officials, and transportation planners the information needed to design improved, practical cycling infrastructure.

It’d be great to see the number of male and female cyclists equal out. If nothing else, it would basically double the number of cyclists out there, increasing visibility and acceptance. Things like the APBP survey, Bike Alliance’s Bike Port, and The Bikery’s classes for women are small steps in the right direction, but there’s clearly many more changes needed to close the gender gap.




  • seabos84

    there is a market for good trikes, and it isn't served.

    a little history – I started riding again when I was 24 – just a different way to get to work downtown instead of the rattler. I got hooked on the good feeling, and, for all you baseball fans – ya know the “Citgo” sign you can see in Fenway park looking towards the outfield? – well riding through Kenmore Square at night was a BLAST when I was 25 … 25 years ago.

    I'm lucky I'm not dead.

    Now, I have more fear of getting splattered, and I think a too defensive approach to riding is as dangerous as a too offensive approach.
    I have all these hip / knee / foot owies from decades of ignoring everything as much as possible.
    I have these stupid bi-focal glasses & when I look down & I look up fast stuff is swimming.
    I don't have the balance or reaction time I did 25 years ago.

    Give me a good trike! I can eliminate several variables – balance, dodging road junk that will kill me on a 2 wheeler & will kill me while I'm dodging it –

    The pedi-cabs are almost right for a trike – they have all the gears you need – they're also too wide. Face it, most of us don't need to haul around 200 * 2 piles of blubber on a regular basis, plus ourselves.

    rmm.

  • sarah68

    More women than men work in non-professional jobs which demand that they be looking “normal” from the time they enter the office, and they don't have (or aren't allowed to use) shower/dressing facilities to clean up after their ride.

  • Stephanie Pure

    What sarah68 said. Women are judged on their looks more so than men. More specifically, women's pay is based on how they look (for example, women who wear make-up earn more.) It's not worth the drop in pay to come to work looking less professional than your other female colleagues. (Not to mention that women earn less than their male colleagues regardless.) Sure, most women would love to dress down every day, but they can't afford to.

    Furthermore, most women cannot come to work with a shirt, tie, pants and shoes. They often require jewelry, accessories, layers, even specific undergarments to go with certain outfits (nylons with a dress, for example). It adds another layer of planning to an already-busy women's day. Plus, if the woman is a mother, pet owner, caretaker of an aging parent or all three, getting out the door in the morning is hard enough without this additional layer. (Perhaps if the statistics on men sharing household responsibilities shifted toward a more balanced direction, that might help more women ride their bikes to work.)

    Thankfully, outfitters like Title 9 and Athleta have 'performance' clothes that can help women still look work-appropriate. That's a step in the right direction. Safer routes can “lift all boats” and help encourage all commuters to choose bike-riding. And lastly, making car commuting too expensive for daily use will also help everyone have different expectations on how someone should look when they come into the office. (Copenhagen has a massive amount of bike commuters of both genders because a) they design for it and b) its too expensive to drive your car every day.)

  • morning fizzy

    Oh please – http://www.publicola.net/2010/02/10/city-employ…

    these are some of the top earners at the city and hardly dressed up or with make-up.

    Women don't ride because they don't want to.

    “And lastly, making car commuting too expensive for daily use will also help everyone have different expectations on how someone should look when they come into the office.”

    Really?

  • P Webb

    I used to be an avid bike commuter–before I had children. In my wildest dreams I didn't think I would ever be driving around town in a mini-van and NOT cycling, but that's what happened. Not because I didn't try–I had the Burley, I had the trail-a-bike…but it just didn't WORK for us. Then my husband, (who was still commuting via bike after kids) got cancer. Again, never in my wildest dreams. Where once I had the ability to think about things like taking the extra time to do something as positive in all regards as cycling, I simply COULDN'T. I don't think my circumstances are much different than many women like me with kids and aging parents–our responsibilities to others have taken over and we are hanging on for dear life. Of course my body fell apart along the way, too.
    I am trying once again to get back on my bike, because I LOVE it and I intend to ride til I die. But, thinking women have the same set of circumstances as men, that they should be riding to work as much as men, well, that's just a nice dream. Our lives as women/caregivers are simply DIFFERENT than men.
    I'm glad the guys are riding to work. Keeps them fit and in a better mood for when they get home to take over for the Moms!
    My husband passed away in 2006. I'm sure he's riding some beautiful trails somewhere…

  • kurisu

    Changing public parking rates to be market rate would be a start.

  • morning fizzy

    How many people use street metered parking for work?

    And it would be a start of what, not caring what people look like when they come to work?

  • T.Chen

    Biking, for some people, is about being macho and giving a finger to the rules. In the U-District I often see hipsters with their trendy old man caps and their tight tapered pants on fixies blowing through red stop lights. These people are almost never women.

    Biking, under certain conditions, is or is perceived to be less safe than other methods of transit and women are more concerned about safety generally.

  • M.C. P.

    look there are gender differences that aren't mens' fault, ok?
    women don't like risk as much as men do.
    they aren't macho. don't get such a kick out of physical feats.
    less upper body strength.
    more subject to asshole men who are violent.
    more subject to rape. sorry, there it is.
    so no matter what you do to the bike, ahem, they are not going to feel so safe nor be as strong, physically.
    as to how they dress at work, you gotta be kidding. no one in seattle dresses at all…we look like we just came off a fishing boat, generally.

    btw if you know of a workplace where men have showers and women don't, please immediately call any attorney, sue them, and you will pocket some money real quick.

    bottom line is it's actually freakin' tough to cycle here with the rain and the hills and it being dark at 4:30 pm part of the year.
    and because we don't have good bike lanes. heck, our streets are destitute of walkers, too, and while there are a few areas with pedestrians…actually most streets are empty of pedestrians.

    bottom line is there is social value in the protection offered by a car. in addition to mobility. not gonna change that.

  • hesj

    The gender gap that exists within the cycling community exists far beyond unequal commuter demographics.

    As a female commuter, racer, and former bike shop employee, I have noticed the my male coworkers and teammates have difficulty in creating an environment that is open and embracing of women looking to break into the sport.

    When I worked in a bike shop, women would talk to me about specific concerns that they had about biking. Whether it was about saddle selection or commuting clothing, women felt like they could ask questions in an environment where they could be understood and supported. I think an effort on the part of bike shops to employ more women would help encourage more women to get on two wheels.

    I have found breaking into the racing community a challenging task. Established competition is cut throat and mixed gender teams have extremely unbalanced gender distribution. Traditionally male teams attempting to incorporate women onto their racing rosters need to make an active effort to make women feel included. This means no sexist jokes, no gender normative assumptions (about motherhood, fear of cars, or anything else), and embracing different body types that reflect the extra curves and weight that women often carry.

    While I think that the above responses and the APBP survey outline some important obstacles that disproportionately affect female cyclists, I think that there needs to me more focus on creating a cycling community. Female riders should take time to encourage other women that express an interest in the sport, and our male counterparts need to abandon the “keep up with the boys” mentality in favor of helping the two wheeled revolution grow!

  • Entitled Hipster

    Thank you. Men don't realize how much basic preparation women go through to be “acceptable” in public. But they sure won't shut up when a woman fails to cover all bases. Wives, stop hiding from your husbands all the stupid grooming and extra tricks, it will be better for everyone.

    Additionally if you've ever worked in a tech office, with or without showers, a number of men will not shower and have no problem being sweaty and stinky all day long.

  • Entitled Hipster

    Morning Fizzy, just because a woman isn't made up like Morgan Fairchild or Kim Kardashian, it doesn't mean those women didn't style their hair or wear makeup. Nearly all the women in that pic appear well groomed, wearing professional clothes, and subtle makeup. It's poorly taken/lit photo as well.

  • Stephanie

    And they probably make less money than their male counterparts who may also be sweaty and stinky. That's the point.

  • Stephanie

    Oops, wrote that too fast. I thought you said the women were sweaty and stinky. Carry on…

  • Stephanie

    Both men and women are responsible for sexism. I'm not sure where it has been said that gender differences are men's fault. (In fact, women famously judge women by their looks just as harshly, if not more so, then men.)

  • UnregisteredUser

    Bikesport in Ballard does a great job helping women select comfortable, bikes that are are a good fit. They also offer classes for women in basic bike maintenance.

  • melinda

    Who on earth is saying that men are at fault for women not riding bikes?

    As a person who thinks of women as “we”, not “they”, I have to say that you should listen to the women in this comment thread for the answers.

  • melinda

    I think it's because cycling is still seen as “alternative” or “weird”. Just being a woman is enough to feel like you're rocking the boat sometimes, so women are less likely to do something on top of that that's rocking the boat, too. I suspect that you can substitute “woman” for “person of color” in this sentence and it is still true, too.

    I think that having biking places seen as viable and normal instead of an activity that you need a special mindset and a special outfit to do will go a long way towards getting more women on bikes. Everything that people suggest in this thread is part of that!

  • melinda

    er, sorry, I meant “substitute 'person of color' for 'woman'”.

    Also, having a mayor who bikes around as transportation is a good start. But what does his wife do? Odds are that she's responsible for shuttling kids, groceries, etc, and using a bike for that is not nearly as easy as getting just yourself around.

  • sarah68

    Walk into any office in Seattle and see if anyone looks like they got off a fishing boat.

    And there are different types of risk from those that are primarily physical. When a woman seeks a job in a male-dominated field, she risks ridicule and all sorts of other unpleasant side effects of her choice of career. Would men risk that sort of thing, even a strong, bicycle-riding, hard-muscled man? I doubt it. But maybe that's a stereotype, just as yours is.

  • Occasional cyclist

    In Copenhagen, biking is so easy that people wear their traditional office clothes en route to work, even skirts, hose and heels; or jacket and tie for men.

  • http://carfreedays.com/ anne

    I've been using a bike as my primary mode of transportation for a few years now.

    Like any transportation choice, using a bike to get around (or not) is a personal. We had a similar discussion (about why most everyday cyclists in the US are men) at carfreedays last fall. We asked the question why don't women ride. The most popular reason women gave was concern for safety. Others included lack of cycling infrastructure, convenience and vanity.

    At one time or another, I've given all of those reasons for not riding. But once I tried it and started riding on a regular basis, all of those excuses melted away and I was hooked. Mostly because getting around on a bike is fun – for me it beats riding in a car or taking the bus hands down.

  • Liz

    I actually changed jobs five years ago so that I could ride my bike to work. I live in Ballard, and was working at Harborview. I was too afraid to ride to HMC, because there really are no decent bike routes, so I finally decided to move to UW. Biking works great for me, because I'm very close to 8th Ave NW, which has a well-traveled bike lane that brings me to the Burke-Gilman, and at the U, I have a bike locker right outside the entrance to the hospital. But there are a couple of other factors that make it all possible. Most importantly, my husband is available in the afternoon and evenings to shuttle our children around. Also, I change from my sweaty bike clothes into scrubs when I get to work, and I settle for a low-maintenance look. I couldn't do this if I were in a position that required me to adhere to “business casual”. I sometimes feel bad that my hair always looks like hell, and that I'm not nicely made up like most of my co-workers. But most of the time, I just feel extremely grateful that it works for me, because my commute is AWESOME!

  • susiearak

    This is a very interesting article. I commute on my bike almost every morning and never really thought about the proportion of men:women on other bicycles. I think that there are plenty of options out there for women, so I'm not sure that equipment is really a main reason that more women don't cycle. I have a smaller frame bicycle by Montague, it fits me really well and folds to fit in my closet to boot!

  • Stephanie Pure

    “Vanity” is a bit of a stretch. I'd much rather wear jeans and sneakers to work, but while some men still look professional wearing jeans and sneakers to work, I don't. I look about 15-years-old. It's not vanity, it's necessity.

  • Sally

    Women don't ride as much as men because they are not as reckless. I tried riding to work from -downtown-from Capitol Hill and every day, I had my heart in my throat due to someone's lack of attention. Women don't get killed on snowboards, in diving accidents, and by accident in general, because we don't have the testosterone necessary to have as much “it will never happen to me”. Lack of safety-mostly from accidents, from my point of view is the KEY.
    And in most family's, when it's time to transport the kids, mom does it. Most. Not all.

  • kurisu

    Although it goes against the typical ratio, I personally know more women than men who bike commute. I wouldn't describe any of them as reckless or bicycling as a reckless activity. In fact, in countries where bicycling is encouraged better than in the US, there are more female than male bicyclists.

  • Tangent

    “And lastly, making car commuting too expensive for daily use will also help everyone have different expectations on how someone should look when they come into the office. “

    Uh, no. It won't.

  • http://spifflines.blogspot.com/ John Bailo

    Traffic in Puget Sound is so bad that bicycling has become the sport of grizzled bums, high energy whippet like software engineers, and action crazed suburban boys. Let's build more highways, more bikeways and restore neighborhoods to tranquility and allow everyone to bike again.

  • Bonnie

    I've been a lady bike commuter for four years now. When I started, I was working a job that required business casual — I changed in a bathroom stall every day, and kept my dress shoes in a drawer in my desk. I've been lucky in jobs since then to not have a dress code to deal with, but yeah, days I want to dress are days I don't ride. People are surprised to see me at parties in classy clothes because I don't/can't wear them every day. Sure, it's very nice in the Netherlands to ride in business wear, but maybe they don't have hills? Or rain? That's my rant about biking vs. looking nice as a lady.

    Also, I'm kind of shy in general, and I only go to one bike shop (Recycled Cycles!) because I feel like the guys (ok, maybe I have seen one female employee?) are not too judgmental and willing to answer my questions about my bike. When I have gone to other bike stores, I often feel like I'm not cool enough — or maybe not cute enough — to ask these skinny boys in their Italian cycling caps my questions. And I'm still in my 20s. When I am 40, that gender/generation/culture gap is going to seem insurmountably huge.

  • lookingforward

    Seriously? The way to get more women riding is to build more highways?

  • David B.

    Bonnie – you should checkout Montlake bikes as well. My girlfriend and I were there a few weeks ago and were helped by two female employees. It was a pleasant experience – no bike-shop-employee-attitude like I've gotten at many other shops.

  • alice

    i work for a bike shop, and im always trying to get them to give over more space to woman specific stuff rather than just shoving it all in a dark corner. if its easy for women to feel accepted, and for it to be easy for them to find well designed, well fitting clothes/bikes/saddle etc then they will cycle. a good fitting bike that you feel comfortable on inspires confidence in itself.

    luckily my work is quite casual, and due to the short distance i 'commute' (its only two miles) i never really get wet from rain/hot+sweaty, so i dont really have the issue with having to look presentable, but even so, if a guy where to come in having got soaked in the rain all he would need would be dry clothes and to towel his hair, whereas a girl would need to restyle her hair, remove the rain smudged make up and re-apply (plus the dry clothes).

    with regards guys being 'braver' than girls due to testosterone or whatever, i dont think thats true, its just guys tend to keep cycling throughout their lives where girls are more likely to have not cycled since they were 10 or so, and now at 20+yrs it seems a long time since they were confidently whizzing around on two wheels.

  • Steph125

    Bonnie, If you keep riding until you are in your 40s you'll look like you are in your 20s!

  • Bonnie

    That's the plan! ;)

  • Guest

    I am a fairly hard core recreational biker but bike commuting is a total pain in the a**. Women who don't have casual-dress workplaces and who have a life outside of getting to and from work really don't have a prayer when it comes to bike commuting. To obtain a formal professional, office-ready look after riding a bike 30 minutes would take a full set of additional clothing, shoes, and undergarments, makeup kit, shampoo/conditioner, comb, brush, hair dryer, hair product, and access to a shower, sink and mirror for enough time to accomplish the transformation. Men, on the other hand, can bring pants, shirt, socks and boxers, leave their shoes at the office, rinse off for two minutes and be done.

    Personally I do not want to take the time to pack all of that stuff and schlep it to the office every day. Nor do I have access to a shower at work anyway, so it's just not worth the effort. I'd rather go ride for fun after work.

    I don't judge women for not wearing makeup at the office but the rest of the professional world sure does. That goes for styled hair, professional yet feminine clothes, and matching shoes. Men just do not have to put the effort into preparing for the office that women do.

  • cejp

    Absolutely. Couldn't agree more. I've been riding bikes for years and commute on my bike daily…the bike shops are my biggest obstacle. I'm in the military so I move a lot and finding a friendly bike shop without snobby guys who won't even look up to help me or talk down to me is SO ANNOYING. I have high quality bikes, a lot of knowledge, and am a competitive racer and often I don't get the time of day. I remember how intimidated I was just to walk in to the store to buy my first bike. It shouldn't be that way. I now look for bike stores who have women. I think getting more women into bike stores would have huge effects on getting more women to ride.
    I love watching bike racing on TV, but I really wish there were more well known women bikers who were highlighted on TV…people I could root for and tell young girls about. Role models matter in what sports people choose. The pro cycling community should do more to highlight the women in their sport and get young girls interested.

  • amy

    Women don't have to commit to going everywhere on bike. Take one thing, eithr commuting, running errands, or pleasure riding and start with that. Make one less trip in the car each day and see how that feels.

    If you can go casual to work one day, ride that day, pony-tail the hair, do a baby-wipes bath in the restroom and let tongues wag. People are under the impression that you sweat a lot on a bike, but if you leave early morning, it stays pretty cool and you get free air conditioning. Humidity ruins that deal, but that only eliminates riding in the height of summer for most of us.

    I think people judge you for your independent spirit and courage more than they judge you for your “professional look”. Get on the damn bike and ride.

  • Josh

    Hmm. That more people don't ride bicycles is an interesting phenomenon. People who claim bicycles are “too dangerous to ride” aren't being honest with themselves. The primary issue seems to be one of perceived social status, especially in America. Because most people would like to be perceived as having a high social status, they drive fancy cars with shiny rims, own houses, and wear flashy jewelry. Indeed, laziness seems to be synonymous with luxury. What kind of rich man doesn't own a TV remote, makes all his own food, cleans his own clothes, busses his own table, and exercises WITHOUT vain motivations?

    I'm confident that the lack of female riders results from society's conception of beauty. For some reason women aren't supposed to be sweaty. Women aren't supposed to be seen exerting effort. After all, who watches the WNBA? Most of it is too complicated for my small brain, but it seems to me that females would benefit from the sweat that washes away unnecessary makeup.