PubliCola’s TechNerd, Glenn Fleishman, has a post up on BoingBoing about RealNetworks’ decision to settle in lawsuits brought by several movie studios, the DVD Copy Control Association (DCCA), and Viacom over its RealDVD software. Glenn says that by settling, Real blew an opportunity to test specific fair-use exemptions to copyright law. He writes:
Without testing specific ideas about fair use or copyright scope in court, there’s no sure way to know whether your particular software program, Web site, tweet, or steampunk-based laser decrypter isn’t in violation. When the MPAA or a studio sues you, you could potentially plow through millions of dollars with no idea of the outcome. [...]
That what was made the RealDVD suits so exciting, because Real has hundreds of millions of dollars in the bank, and had a pugnacious CEO, Rob Glaser. Glaser faced down Microsoft over unfair competition and got nearly $800 million from the Windows maker. (Glaser was forced out as head of Real a few weeks ago, although he intended to move on after an executive search; he remains chairman of the board and owns nearly 40 percent of the firm.)
Even better, Real wasn’t promoting piracy, or the broad right to rip DVDs into an unprotected format and then move them onto all kinds of devices for playback. RealDVD was very very narrow in purpose: can individuals buy software that converts one kind of protected content on a specific physical medium into another, with even stronger encryption?
Read the whole thing here.
